2 ms·
Strong agreement here. The principle driver of antisocial behaviour online seems to be impunity, immunity, and/or disinhibition. Anonymity and/or pseudonymity
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Strong agreement here.
The principle driver of antisocial behaviour online seems to be impunity, immunity, and/or disinhibition. Anonymity and/or pseudonymity are related, but nowhere near identical.
As Yonatan Zunger, chief architect of Google+ (and now an ex-Googler) pointed out, compulsory identification amplifies rather than removes power relationships. This is his principle (and IMO devastating) response to David Brin's Transparent Society argument. Minorities and the disempowered obliged to identify themselves lose even more power in the bargain.
What empowers abuse is the ability to inflict harm without perception of risk, whether that perception is accurate or not. Disinhibition reduces perception whilst overall risk remains high. (The concept is captured in the word "assassin", deriving from the Arabic, hashīshīn, referencing hashhish --- assassins had reduced inhibitions through pharmaceutical influence.) Legal immunity, the cover of a crowd, operating extrajurisdictionally, cover of a state or other significant actor, or simple mass delusions can all provide the reality or appearance of impunity.
Mandating identity itself creates new avenues for abuse, including the revoking of official credentials, bureaucratic incompetence, bribery, and the potential of a "permanent archive" of all accesses (already substantially present through numerous mechanisms) which can be mined at arbitrary future dates, but as-yet unknown entities with as-yet unknown motives.
I'll note that I'm one of numerous reasonably-well-know pseudonymous HN members.
- meowkit 5y agoThis is well stated. In case you read this reply, have you looked into decentralized identifiers (DIDs)? Any thoughts?
- dredmorbius 5y agoI'm (maybe) composing my own set of suggestions to Neil. A substantial bit of that is TL;DR: credible assertions of characteristics (or rights or responsibilities) might offer some solution-shaped objects. But in many cases, there's no reasonable way to accomodate identity / credential / characteristic assertion into data flows (e.g., commandline tools, proxies).
- Igelau 5y ago> buttbuttin Fixed that for you. There might be young readers here who haven't verified their ages.
- specialist 5y agoDo you have a handy link to Zunger's criticism of Transparent Society? Sorry, my search-fu is weak this morning. Based on the quality of Zunger's other writings, I'm open to what he has to say.
- dredmorbius 5y agoFortunately, the Wayback Machine seems to have captured that: https://web.archive.org/web/20180903205908/https://plus.google.com/+YonatanZunger/posts/WegYVNkZQqq https://web.archive.org/web/20180903205908/https://plus.goog... At the heart of his argument: In practice, the forced revelation of information makes individual privilege and power more important. When everyone has to play with their cards on the table, so to speak, then people who feel like they can be themselves without consequence do so freely -- these generally being people with support groups of like-minded people, and who are neither economically nor physically vulnerable. People who are more vulnerable to consequences use concealment as a method of protection: it makes it possible to speak freely about controversial subjects, or even about any subjects, without fear of harassment. (A classic experiment which you can easily replicate is to change your profile photo to that of a young woman for a few weeks. Change nothing else, even your name, and see what happens to your interaction pattern. I've seen quite a few people run this test and the results are, shall we say, quite visible) GamerGate is one example after another of why transparency has asymmetric effects. The worst-case consequence for members of the mobs is fairly minimal: they won't face social ostracism by their friends (who after all, support them), they are highly unlikely to be placed in any physical danger (the police will protect them), and their jobs are not likely to be affected either -- and if they are, they can find others. Conversely, the threats against women in the field were physical and real, and (as you'll see if you ever experience the real ability of local and federal law enforcement to deal with harassment and threat cases, for manifold reasons) there is reason to believe that they do not have access to adequate police protection. (I'd mentioned the G+ link a few times in earlier HN comments. HN's Algolia search is one of the secret strengths of HN, and is a chief reason I comment here as extensively as I do: I can often find earlier mentions of some point and reference or expand, occasionally correct, those.) (Zunger and I apparently each believe firmly in paragraph-long parenthetical digressions.) Original submitted to the queue: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27858439 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27858439