5 ms·
Also stated as "The purpose of the system is what it does". If the system as designed is concentrating wealth in the hands of a few individuals (who themselves
by ModernMech 5y ago
Also stated as "The purpose of the system is what it does".
If the system as designed is concentrating wealth in the hands of a few individuals (who themselves helped set up the system), how can we say it's not working as intended? It seems to be working out very well for them.
- WalterBright 5y ago> concentrating wealth This implies that wealth is zero sum. It isn't. Creating wealth, which is what businesses do, is not "concentrating" it.
- triceratops 5y agoYou're talking past each other. If a business achieves a 10x leap in productivity and lowers prices for its customers, has it created wealth for others? Yes. If that business is owned by a single person, has that person's wealth relative to the rest of society increased? Also yes.
- WalterBright 5y agoI agree with your points. However, Creating wealth is not concentrating it.
- ModernMech 5y agoBusinesses create wealth, and then capture the vast majority of it in the process. Rising inequality should be proof enough for you that wealth concentration is happening.
- nickpp 5y agoNo, the greater society is actually enjoying the vast majority of value created by a business. You know, the people happily giving their money to the business in exchange for goods and services.
- ModernMech 5y agoWealth and value are different things. Value can be created without billionaires capturing most of the wealth.
- nickpp 5y agoIt’s essential that the people who built those businesses receive a corresponding amount of wealth in exchange: it is their main motivator to create the business in the first place. Businesses which, remember, add a tremendous amount of value to the society - value which is much greater than the wealth their founders receive. No billionaires implies no founders. No founders implies no businesses. No businesses implies a poor, stagnant society where every body suffers. Kind of like all the communist experiments of the last century.
- ModernMech 5y ago99.999% of business owners are not and never will be billionaires. There's plenty of upside and profit for business founders without the promise of them becoming so obscenely rich. > No businesses implies a poor, stagnant society where every body suffers. Kind of like all the communist experiments of the last century. This is just not a fair characterization; for example the Soviet Union was hardly stagnant -- in the span of 30 years they went from an agrarian society to being the first nation on Earth to launch a satellite and the first man into space.
- WalterBright 5y agoBig business are the engines that drive the economy. For that you need billionaires. A nation of small businesses sounds attractive to many people, and it's been tried more than once, but it just doesn't work. You're never going to have chip fabs, automaking, steel smelting, oil refining, ship building, turbine making, etc., without big business. The Soviet Union has been described as a third world economy with a first world military. The US is a first world economy and a first world military. Thanks to the free market. BTW, you can buy Soviet built cars. The only people who buy them are collectors who take a perverse pride in their awfulness.
- WalterBright 5y ago> then capture the vast majority of it in the process No they don't. I buy things when I get more than my money is worth. So does everyone else. It's how trade works. Businesses are not extracting wealth from me or you.
- ModernMech 5y agoLike I replied to the other poster, you are confusing value and wealth. Let's say a company makes food. It costs them $2 to make and they sell it for $5. You buy it and eat it. Are you now wealthier? No. Your wealth actually decreased $5. Why would you enter this transaction if it made you less wealthy? Well because the food has some utility for you. You buy things when you get more "utility" than your money is "valued". But at the end of the transaction, you are not worth more. On the other hand, the company's wealth increased $3. We call this increase in wealth "profit". It's the whole point of a business, and they extracted it from you. An exchange of goods and money occurred. Your wealth decreased, while their wealth increased. Is that not extracting wealth from you?
- WalterBright 5y ago> Is that not extracting wealth from you? Nope. What I did with what I purchased has no relevance to the transaction. For example, I could have resold the food in my restaurant for $10. Wealth can certainly be destroyed. The people doing the destroying are "extracting", not the people who sold it to them. > you are confusing value and wealth Not at all. I think you'll find it impossible to define the difference.
- ModernMech 5y ago> I think you'll find it impossible to define the difference It's not that hard... Value is the dollar value you assign a thing. In large part this is subjective except when it comes to money, which only works because we all agree it has the same value. Wealth is the sum total value of all your assets, minus all your debts. If all your wealth is not in dollars, this can be subjective too depending on who is assessing the value of the assets. Let's say we both have $10 in cash. The total wealth in our economy is $20. I exhaust $2 to make the taco, you give me $5 for the taco. My wealth is now $13, we can all agree. Your wealth depends on the value. Since it is a taco, it has no intrinsic dollar value attached to it. The amount of value you assign the taco will depend on how hungry the buyer is. But if you eat that taco the taco is gone. Forever. Your wealth is now $5, and mine is $13. $2 is now missing from the economy, but like the second law of thermodynamics it all depends on how you define the bounds of the economy, as it's likely circulating elsewhere now and potentially creating assets rather than consumable goods. But you can see in this case I didn't actually create any wealth. I created value, and it was destroyed by you, but I ended up wealthier. If you resold the food in your restaurant for $10 all that means is someone else valued the taco more than you. The analysis is the same though.