2 ms·
I didn't mean it to be an accusation, although I see how it could be seen as such. So apologies! Praktische Konkordanz gets very technical fast, but if you hav
by Tomte 5y ago
I didn't mean it to be an accusation, although I see how it could be seen as such. So apologies!
Praktische Konkordanz gets very technical fast, but if you have a limitless basic right (so that the Basic Law doesn't spell out limits itself – freedom of art would be such a limitless basic right), it may only be limited by other basic rights.
If I paint a picture on the wall of your house, a surface reading or literal interpretation of the Basic Law might come to the result that since the exercise art is free, nobody can stop me.
Obviously that would be stupid. :-)
But in order to limit that basic right we need to find another basic right that is being infringed upon by the limitless exercise of the first basic right.
In this case the most obvious one is the right to property.
And then you get a lot of legal analysis why in this specific case limiting the right to free exercise of art should indeed be limited, and where exactly the limit lies.
I mean it's all obvious, right? I doubt that any legal order would actually use strict priorities to basic rights, but that's my point: if you spell out scenarios Schmidt's words aren't improper, nor surprising.
She could mean something broader, more nefarious, but just from reading those words I can only conclude this is totally common interpretation of laws and constitutions.
People on Twitter just choose to interpret those words unfairly, because… Facebook.