3 ms·
>It utterly fails to answer why anyone not at the top of the power curve would want society to be structured this way - most of the described "Social Contract"
by gruez 5y ago
>It utterly fails to answer why anyone not at the top of the power curve would want society to be structured this way - most of the described "Social Contract" seems to imply precarity, [...] and living at the edge of financial disaster for most.
How much of this is due to wealth distribution and how much of this is due to human nature? eg, 60% of Millennials Earning over $100k Live Paycheck to Paycheck (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27581105 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27581105)
- triceratops 5y agoIt would be interesting to know the geographic distribution of those millennials. Living paycheck to paycheck when earning $105k in Oklahoma seems irresponsible. In SF, depending on your situation, that may not be so unreasonable. Moreover, how does that compare to other people (i.e. non-millennials) who make over $100k? The average (not median) savings rate in the US is pathetic - something like 10%. And that's obviously skewed by high-earners and FI/RE types. So 40% of millennials living below their means might actually be quite good in comparison.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwawaygh 5y ago> How much of this is due to wealth distribution and how much of this is due to human nature? Probably not much. 1. The VAST majority of people who are living paycheck-to-paycheck are not making $100K. According to the same report, Seventy-two percent of those who make less than $50,000 live paycheck to paycheck. Do some high earners live paycheck to payccheck? Sure. But the VAST majority of people living paycheck to paycheck are not high earners. 2. The death of pensions matters. In the post-pension world, maxing out your 401K and then some is a bill. Period. $100K - $20K = $80K. That's almost certainly "paycheck to paycheck" territory if you're raising more than one kid without a spouse, even in low CoL areas. When comparing earnings across time, it's almost more important to consider pensions in addition to inflation. 3. The background of people making >100K also matters. Many people making over $100K are well-educated, which often means significant debt and/or catching up on retirement savings. Think doctors, lawyers, PhDs, etc. 4. CoL also matters. Many people making >$100K are living in a high CoL areas. $50K in Dacatur, IL = $114K in SFBA.
- handrous 5y ago> 2. The death of pensions matters. In the post-pension world, maxing out your 401K and then some is a bill. Period. $100K - $20K = $80K. That's almost certainly "paycheck to paycheck" territory if you're raising more than one kid without a spouse, even in low CoL areas. When comparing earnings across time, it's almost more important to consider pensions in addition to inflation. The death of pensions also frees up (lots of) money for zero-sum competition, especially the kid-related variety, which includes housing in desirable (=the schools are safe and have good outcomes) areas, or private school tuition, tutoring, et c. If you want to save but half your peers have already chosen "defect" and are putting an extra $20,000/yr toward their kids, who will be competing with your kids for scarce resources in the not-so-distant future, it gets damn tempting to make a choice that's very bad for your retirement but gives your kids a better chance of, if not rising, at least not dropping in socio-economic class.
- gruez 5y ago>1. The VAST majority of people who are living paycheck-to-paycheck are not making $100K. Right, because the VAST majority of people aren't making $100k. > According to the same report, Seventy-two percent of those who make less than $50,000 live paycheck to paycheck. In other words, increasing your income by more than $50k, only decreases "paycheck to paycheck"-ness by 12 percentage points. That seems to support the thesis that it's due to human nature rather than income distribution. >The death of pensions matters Everything you pointed out is true, but I don't see how it's relevant to the discussion of whether it's human nature or wealth distribution. The point of my original comment is that people live paycheck to paycheck despite having a lot of money, suggesting that it might not be a money issue but a human one (rat race, hedonic treadmill, etc.) >3. The background of people making >100K also matters. Many people making over $100K are well-educated, which often means significant debt and/or catching up on retirement savings. Think doctors, lawyers, PhDs, etc. The debt is higher, but not enough to account for the difference. If your income goes up by 242%, your student debt (and therefore payments) only goes up by 20%[1] [1] https://www.urban.org/urban-wire/which-households-hold-most-student-debt https://www.urban.org/urban-wire/which-households-hold-most-..., comparing the debt/income ratios of households in the second quartile and the 75-90th percentile. >4. CoL also matters Agreed, we need a study that controls for cost of living
- jonnycomputer 5y agoA lot of millenials have families now. 100k is not that much, especially if it is before taxes, health insurance, retirement.