5 ms·
Gawker Is Dead and Deserved to Die (2017)
- vmurthy 5y agoThe blog post doesn't quite do justice as much as the book "Conspiracy" by Ryan Holiday does. Do read it to understand how it died. [0]https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/36681909-conspiracy https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/36681909-conspiracy
- teddyh 5y ago“The trouble with fighting for human freedom is that one spends most of one's time defending scoundrels. For it is against scoundrels that oppressive laws are first aimed, and oppression must be stopped at the beginning if it is to be stopped at all. — Commonly attributed to H. L. Mencken (1880-1956)
- nullc 5y agoThe lack of rampant privacy violation lawsuits over the past 5 years is evidence in support of the theory that our freedom didn't depend on protecting that particular vicious scoundrel. It's true that defending freedom often implies defending scoundrels. But it's a failure of logic to assume that we can't stop scoundrels, generally, if we want to protect freedom. Gawker didn't just screw up. It was habitually irredeemably horrible. If there is to be any limit to conduct online at all it seemed inevitable that they'd eventually cross it. We should be proud of our civilization that it was an orderly legal process that ended it, rather than a violent vigilante reprisal.
- dls2016 5y agoI was a long time Gawker reader. Did they push the boundary of taste and decency? Absolutely. But if you want to be fair, let’s compare their worst takes to the worst takes of other rags… or even the “paper of record” which routinely pushed the US into wars of aggression.
- chirau 5y agoWhataboutism is tiresome. Two wrongs do not make a right.
- falcor84 5y ago... but three lefts do. I'm not looking to defend Gawker, but I believe that comparing it and its impact versus competitors/substitutes is absolutely relevant.
- jgalt212 5y agowhataboutism the empirically based. For that reason along, I feel I must entertain its arguments.
- pessimizer 5y agoWhataboutism is one of the major forces that ended Jim Crow in the US.
- merpnderp 5y agoWhataboutism is just a word hypocrites invented to avoid acknowledging their blatant hypocrisy.
- teddyh 5y agoAccusations of hypocrisy is only an ad-hominem argument; i.e. a fallacy.
- merpnderp 5y agoLol, no. Hypocrisy is a type of lying. You say you care about something for a reason, but actually only care about it for another often less persuasive reason. You see it all the time in politics where people are outraged at X when the other party does it, but can't be assed to care when X is done by their own party. They're lying that they care about X. The truth is they're using it as a lie for political power.
- CPLX 5y agoHere’s a more succinct and accurate take on what happened to Gawker: Gawker always said it was in the business of publishing true stories. Here is one last true story: You live in a country where a billionaire can put a publication out of business. A billionaire can pick off an individual writer and leave that person penniless and without legal protection. If you want to write stories that might anger a billionaire, you need to work for another billionaire yourself, or for a billion-dollar corporation. The law will not protect you. There is no freedom in this world but power and money.
- linksnapzz 5y agoSuccinct, obtuse, self-pitying and dissembling. Probably a Gawker writer. If one goes around committing tortious invasion of privacy and infliction of emotional distress, one will get sued for it eventually, and possibly lose in court. Yes, even if you call yourself a "journalist" while doing so. Yes, even if your targets for abuse are icky-poo wrongthinkers like Thiel and Bollea, who shouldn't have access to legal remedies because darn it, they have declasse opinions contra to the "speak truth to power" crowd. Getting sued is getting off easy, and deep down Denton & co. knew that losing in court was the worst thing that could happen to them-it wasn't like they embarrassed John Gotti or Chapo Guzman, or someone else whose retaliation would involve semtex and garrottes.
- CPLX 5y agoYes you’re correct, being crushed by the unjust power of wealth is mildly superior to being bombed or strangled by serial murderers and career criminals. Insightful, that.
- linksnapzz 5y agoHad Gawker been sued into oblivion by one of the many, many non-wealthy that they humiliated for the lulz, would you be less upset? Or are you staking out a pro-libel position in general?
- 5y ago
- tokai 5y agoAnd nothing a value was lost. Gawker Media and the Gawker blog are gone, but all the other side-blogs are still going strong. Can't see this as a freedom of speech issue. A company with an ugly dysfunctional culture was destroyed and not much else happened.
- ubermonkey 5y agoI saw the source, and understood immediately there was no point in clicking. Gawker died because, as it turns out, Peter Thiel wanted it dead, and had enough money to buy the outcome he wanted. It was astonishing that he prevailed in the initial suit, but gobsmacking that the judge referred to issue a stay pending appeal -- which, in practical terms, meant the appeal was impossible. Gawker was murdered by a craven jackass and a broken and complicit legal system. OBVIOUSLY, though, the Federalist will come down on the side of the moneyed class and their favorite tech investor. This is because they have no principles.
- CPLX 5y ago> This is because they have no principles. They have principles. Among them is the principle that the people who amass the most resources should be the one who determine how society is run.
- kcplate 5y agoI think intentionally picking a fight with wealthy and powerful people over something that is ultimately trivial to the public but deeply personal to your wealthy and powerful target could incur a level of business risk that might not be survivable. Gawker is dead because of Thiel who very well may be a craven jackass exploiting a legal loophole, but Gawker willingly loaded that gun…just to try and temporarily capitalize on a wee bit of ad revenue off a viral story. If you are going to push envelopes and speak truth to the rich and powerful, speak a truth that has some level of impact for societal good. I am not going to weep for your gossip rag’s demise when your biggest news scoops center around outing rich guys and showcasing some old wrestlers schlong.
- Fern_Blossom 5y agoUniversity of Maine professor Michael J. Socolow: "Gawker began as a crusade to save journalism" Dying on the hill to keep a sex tape of a washout wrestler was in the name of journalism? There are real journalists out there that lost their careers fighting to publish real stories about political and corporate corruption, war crimes, human suffering and more. Not sex tapes. Gawker didn't have any real journalists. This was a group of frat boys enjoying causing mayhem in random people's lives as long as they got to profit from it. So no, you have no principles.