2 ms·
A couple problems off the top of my head: 1. Everything is harder to work with: you have to deal with less reliable networks and storage, computers which aren'
by acdha 5y ago
A couple problems off the top of my head:
1. Everything is harder to work with: you have to deal with less reliable networks and storage, computers which aren't on all of the time, very slow uplinks, etc. Since these aren't professionally managed systems, too, you have less visibility — did that node just drop offline because the hard drive failed, losing everything, Comcast is having a bad day, the owner just bought a new one and wiped the old one without unenrolling it, or because it rebooted and is almost back up?
2. People are selfish: I don't want Netflix getting slow because you decided to retrieve your data, I'll complain if I hit a storage limit on my computer due to your stored backup data, etc. This forces you do deal with things like traffic shaping and storage rebalancing more aggressively and those are hard problems to get a popular balance on. Consider, for example, what happens when someone uses your service and it goes well but then they run out of space and need to clear some up in a hurry (_especially_ if they put on their cowboy hat and just delete a bunch of large files because they know they aren't the only ones with a copy).
3. The solutions to the previous problems make the cost problem worse: storing more copies can avoid some of the problems but then you need to figure out how to get the network to support, say, 5 copies instead of 2-3.
4. Consider what happens the first time the police bust someone for a major crime and their data is backed up on your computer. Not many people are enthusiastic about going into court to prove the negative assertion that they didn't have a decryption key.
Only peering with trusted systems avoids some of these issues but not all and the _big_ problem is that the upper bound for how much this service is worth is basically the cost of iCloud/Dropbox/S3/Backblaze/etc. The savings you can get between the fixed operational costs and what those services charge is probably not enough to support development.