5 ms·
Platform shouldn't have the right to an opinion on content. Same way that when you open a store you can't pick and choose your customers. Platforms should jus
by scotty79 5y ago
Platform shouldn't have the right to an opinion on content.
Same way that when you open a store you can't pick and choose your customers.
Platforms should just obey law and at most create a process where users and lawmakers can express and enforce their opinion on content.
- tedunangst 5y agoShould movie theaters be allowed to select which movies they show?
- Const-me 5y agoThere're many movie theaters, but only one youtube in the whole world. Youtube and facebook are natural monopolies due to their network effect. All the older natural monopolies, water networks, electricity networks, landline phone networks, railroad networks, and the rest of them are either nationalized, or regulated heavily. It's long overdue to add social networks to the list.
- anigbrowl 5y agoThere's only one YouTube, but lots of video sharing sites. You can put your material on Bitchute, Vimeo, ....
- Const-me 5y agoYoutube's monopoly is not video hosting, there're many ways to do that. Their monopoly is their social network. People want to publish video where the audience is, the global audience happen to be on youtube, and going to stay there because that's where most videos are.
- bobthechef 5y agoNot absolutely. They shouldn't be able to show porn, for example, or some other destructive content. (And no, it's not a question of taste or opinion. That relativist claim is worthless and tired. We're not talking about vanilla or chocolate ice cream here.) I suppose in this particular case (and that matters: things like this can be particular) you would just criminalize those sorts of movies. The idea that we shouldn't do such things because government could be used to impose horrible things is a bad one. Driving a car could kill you, but you wouldn't ban cars for that reason because cars are not bad in principle nor are they so dangerous that they should be banned. They are regulated, however, and this is good.
- rhcom2 5y ago> Same way that when you open a store you can't pick and choose your customers. But you can mostly pick and choose your customers outside of discriminating against a protect class (in the US). If you don't want to do business with people with brown hair, no one is stopping you.
- dec0dedab0de 5y ago> Same way that when you open a store you can't pick and choose your customers. But you can mostly pick and choose your customers outside of discriminating against a protect class (in the US). If you don't want to do business with people with brown hair, no one is stopping you. "genetic information" is a protected class, so you could not discriminate against anyone based on their natural hair color. You could however ban people with blue hair. edit: Even if genetic information doesn't work for hair color. "Color" is already a protected class, so it's a moot point.
- gowld 5y agoHas that been tested in court?
- anigbrowl 5y agoAre you sure about that? Suppose I have a store and wish to ban redheads.
- rhcom2 5y agoI think you're confusing genetic information with phenotype. I don't think the law works like you think: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_Information_Nondiscrimination_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_Information_Nondiscrim...
- zajio1am 5y ago> But you can mostly pick and choose your customers outside of discriminating against a protect class (in the US). Yes, but this is about Germany and not US, and (AFAIK) consumer protection laws in Europe generally prohibit stores to pick and choose customers arbitrarily.
- tynpeddler 5y ago> Same way that when you open a store you can't pick and choose your customers. The same way a store can't kick someone out who's running around saying racial slurs to everyone? The same way the New York Times is required to print every letter to the editor that is sent to them? The store example doesn't hold up at all for a number of reasons and online communities have had extra legal standards since the beginning of the internet.
- jacob2484 5y agoNY Times is not a platform
- throwawayswede 5y agoNYT Opinion page (essence bullshit basically) is.
- anigbrowl 5y agoAre you arguing (consistent with your comment above) that NYT-O must publish all submissions?
- imwillofficial 5y agoNYT Opinion page is not a “public square” In America at least, there are different sets of rules for different types of business. A curated opinion piece, carefully chosen by experienced editors, is vastly different from a public swimming pool. For the first, that filter, that exclusivity, that editorializing is part of the draw. It’s good because it’s a filter, not a platform. The public pool should not be a filter, and yes, sometimes there are weird things that float in there, and it takes effort to clean up, but that’s the cost of being open to the public.
- scotty79 5y agoIf NYT does the selection and curation then it's not. Same way opinion piece inspired by what author heard from other people is not a platform for those people.
- lovich 5y agoYou can pick and choose your customers in the US at least? There’s a carve out of protections against discriminating based on membership in a protected class, but you can totally decide to get up one day and not provide service to anyone whose ever worn a hat for instance
- ihumanable 5y agoIf YouTube is a store, them taking down a video isn't them picking and choosing their customers it's them picking and choosing the product they put on their shelf. Which is generally a thing left up to the store owner and not the government.
- username90 5y agoNo, whitelists vs blacklists. A store blacklists some customers from entering, but in general most can enter. A store doesn't let most people put wares on its shelves, that is a whitelist. Youtube blacklists video uploads and otherwise allows everything, so it follows the same logic as customers entering a store.
- ihumanable 5y agoNo, product vs customer. YouTube has a product they sell, advertising slots embedded in videos. YouTube's customer is the person buying the ad slot. The video and uploader are, in a tortured analogy I didn't choose about YouTube being a small store, the product that YouTube sells to their actual customer, the advertiser. Bringing up whitelists and blacklists doesn't change that.
- verall 5y ago> Same way that when you open a store you can't pick and choose your customers. In America, you can, as long as it is not based on a protected class. The "burden of proof" (either "beyond a reasonable double" for criminal or "a preponderance of evidence" in civil) is not on the business, but on the rejected customer. Further, as this is talking about content that they are required to host, rather than restricting who is viewing a video, a more accurate analogy is a store picking their distributors. Which they obviously do.
- root_axis 5y ago> Platform shouldn't have the right to an opinion on content. Why? > Same way that when you open a store you can't pick and choose your customers. Of course you can, you just can't refuse service based on legally protected classes, that's the exception not the rule. > Platforms should just obey law and at most create a process where users and lawmakers can express and enforce their opinion on content. Platforms should operate their sites however they like within the confines of the law and individual users can decide which sites they prefer to use based on how those sites operate.
- scotty79 5y ago>> Platform shouldn't have the right to an opinion on content. > Why? Because if it has that right it should have the full responsibility for everything it publishes. With no leeway. >> Same way that when you open a store you can't pick and choose your customers. > Of course you can, you just can't refuse service based on legally protected classes, that's the exception not the rule. Depends on the local law. For example in Poland if you have a store and you put up some good for sale and mark it with a price, you can't refuse it to sell it to anyone that is willing to pay that price. No special classes, just a simple rule. If you are selling, you are selling. > Platforms should operate their sites however they like within the confines of the law and individual users can decide which sites they prefer to use based on how those sites operate. Right, and the law should say that they can't have an opinion about the content they publish, and they can't take down or promote stuff based on that opinion.
- root_axis 5y ago> Because if it has that right it should have the full responsibility for everything it publishes. With no leeway I don't understand your reasoning. When you say "full responsibility" I assume you mean legal responsibility, as in, a website that removes posts by users should take full legal responsibility if users post illegal content, but I don't see the connection between the two ideas, the illegal content was still posted by a user, what about removing posts makes the website now legally responsible for the actions of users. This would also make the site legally impossible to operate, it sounds like you're suggesting any site that removes user content should be pushed into shutting down. Am I misunderstanding?
- charonn0 5y agoStores can pick and choose their customers. It all depends on the basis for the decision.
- sib 5y agoEhhh, if a store is the analogy, YouTube is choosing their products here, which is exactly what stores do.