6 ms·
They are a private company, etc. But here it's not what they choose to remove, not "moderation.. It's what those in power press them to remove, aka "censorship
by nine_k 5y ago
They are a private company, etc.
But here it's not what they choose to remove, not "moderation.. It's what those in power press them to remove, aka "censorship".
- antonzabirko 5y agoExcellent point, but it's important to note that currently the systems private companies use are little better than censorship. We need a non-affiliated govt agency to handle censorship/moderation requests.
- pyronik19 5y agoAs someone who leans right wing.... I have 0 trust in these types of institutions. They overwhelmingly have views that are aligned directly with the far left and they seem to exercise their authority when given it to further their own political objectives. Take the SPLC which is used by some tech platforms to decide who to censor. They wield their power to label people as white supremacist to get them banned not because they are in any reasonable persons view based on evidence have said or done things that are clearly racist.... but its just the labeling of an enemy to fit narrative. We don't need censorship with extra steps... we need free speech.
- HideousKojima 5y agoSee also the SPLC labeling people like Maajid Nawaz and Ayaan Hirsi Ali "anti-Muslim extremists."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- barbacoa 5y agoYears back a Colorado bakery refused to bake a cake for a gay wedding, the resulting lawsuit ended up going all the way up to the supreme court. The law firm that represented the baker is now officially labeled as a anti gay hate group by the splc.
- antonzabirko 5y agoWhat's the alternative? Anything private and you risk for-profit suppression just like we have now. Removing moderation is not an option imo.
- reedjosh 5y ago> Anything private You don't have to support. The government will take your support at gunpoint. This is the crux of the issue.
- antonzabirko 5y agoWhat does it matter what you support though? Case in point: twitter, fb, reddit, so on
- reedjosh 5y agoI don't have to be there, and my dollars don't go to these corps. I don't understand your point. I'm not on either of those platforms, so they're not shipping me ads. I do what I can to be private, so that their data mining doesn't get me. I have that choice. Unfortunately if I don't agree with what my government is doing, they'll still take my tax dollars and fight forever wars with them.
- antonzabirko 5y agoBasically it doesn't matter if you support them because most speech happens on those platforms and you are suppressed from there. Sure you can go elsewhere, but that doesn't work when you need to reach out to others.
- jjoonathan 5y ago> They overwhelmingly have views that are aligned directly with the far left Your president repeatedly advocated for having journalists with opposing views shot.
- rscoots 5y agoWhen did this happen? Genuinely curious
- jjoonathan 5y agoRepeatedly, at the 2020 rallies. After the applause died down, he would follow up his very sincere trial balloon with a much less sincere "just kidding." Find a clip, decide for yourself if it's a trial balloon or a genuine funny joke, but either way it's pretty damning from a freedom of speech angle. He has also repeatedly expressed a similar sentiment in other forms, like open admiration for oppressive regimes' control over the media.
- Igelau 5y ago> Find a clip, decide for yourself The onus is on you to back up that claim.
- jjoonathan 5y agoThe onus is on me to the extent that it's in doubt. I was hoping it wouldn't be, since it made the rounds thoroughly enough at the time to shift the counter-discourse from "that never happened!" to "it happened, but it wasn't a problem, because it was just a joke." I guess I'll have to spend more time wading through the cesspool of political youtube. I spent 15 minutes trying to track it down and couldn't find it. It is buried under at least three incidents with similar search terms since last year, but two of them could have had attenuating circumstances and one of them is second hand, so none of them are as singularly indefensible as the statements he made on the campaign trail about having journalists shot. If I get some more time I'll go digging again.
- 5y ago
- 0xbadcafebee 5y agoAll we need is rules about what content can be removed for what reasons, and Twitter can just follow those rules itself, with the potential for audits. That's how we handle every regulatory requirement for companies. Even taxes basically work that way. Censorship is the moderation of content that may be disturbing or cause painful thoughts or feelings. So a person leaking state secrets on Twitter, and the government asking Twitter to take the tweet down, is not censorship: it's protecting national security, or law enforcement. They're drastically different things being taken down for very different reasons. You don't need an independent body to handle either type of request because we already have mechanisms for a company to handle both. What people are getting worked up over now is the potential for governments to abuse their legal right to remove illegal content, in order to censor. Since it's the govt doing it, the govt is not going to create an agency just to wave a big flag when it is doing something bad. That would be like creating a "National Agency Of We Don't Trust The Government".
- dgb23 5y agoNot only that, they have been requesting to reveal the identity of anonymous users. There are both attempts of censorship and surveillance/espionage.
- naasking 5y ago> But here it's not what they choose to remove, not "moderation.. It's what those in power press them to remove, aka "censorship" Moderators are literally censors, by definition. Look up the definition of "censor" if you don't believe me. People need to stop playing word games to avoid the label of "censorship". Just accept that you're ok with some types of censorship and try to justify the types you support rigourously. That's the only way to avoid a slippery slope. Trying to tap dance around calling it censorship serves no one.
- pjc50 5y agoSo .. are we back to demanding that twitter delete nothing, ever, no matter how pornographic, libellous, or threatening? Or even just spam?
- reedjosh 5y agoI don't care what Twitter does. I just don't want the government mandating what it does. If a private company wants to censor, then sure. But as soon as the government requests takedowns and shadowbans, that's majorly crossing the line into infringement of free speech. The whole reason we constitutionally limit the governmental repression of free speech is because we're all made to support it. If I could chose to pay my taxes to an alternative, then fine, but we're made to pay taxes to a government that now can take down speech critical of it.
- j16sdiz 5y agoCounter-argument: Government is (in theory) elected by people, counter balanced by court. Facebook is accountable to nobody, it don't even have any competitor in social network business.
- nybble41 5y agoEven if that were "Government is (in practice) elected by people, counter balanced by court", it wouldn't be enough. The people electing the government do not have the right to use force to coerce other people (the owners & operators of Facebook in this case) into censoring content. A government or other representative elected by the people has no rights beyond those possessed by the people who voted for it—one cannot delegate rights one does not possess. And the courts are themselves part of the government. It's good to have some form of internal controls (self-regulation) to keep the other branches of government in check, but one arm of the government cannot be the sole and final arbiter of whether another arm of the same government is acting justly. Facebook is accountable to its users. It may not have much serious competition now, but there are myriad potential alternatives which could fulfill the same function, just as Facebook replaced its predecessors (most notably MySpace). Network effects are strong while they last, but notoriously fickle.
- throwawayboise 5y agoThey are a private company but they chose to position themselves as a public square, open to anyone, with no barriers to entry.