4 ms·
That's because those restrictions are illegal themselves. "Don't download the whole database" is not an illegal restriction.
by tedunangst 15y ago
That's because those restrictions are illegal themselves. "Don't download the whole database" is not an illegal restriction.
- pyre 15y ago* How about "You are not allowed to hyperlink to this page?" * How about that 'MySpace Hacking' case? From Wikipedia: Judge Wu summed up his opinion by stating that allowing a violation of a website's Terms of Service to constitute an intentional access of a computer without authorization or exceeding authorization would "result in transforming section 1030(a)(2)(C) into an overwhelmingly overbroad enactment that would convert a multitude of otherwise innocent Internet users into misdemeanant criminals." For these reasons, Judge Wu granted Drew's motion for acquittal. Government eventually decided not to appeal [16]. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Lori_Drew http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Lori_Drew
- tedunangst 15y agoI don't think hyperlinking is the crime in question for this case.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- pyre 15y agoMy post wasn't very clear. I was making two separate points.
- tedunangst 15y agoThere are two separate issues as well, whether or not a restriction is valid and the ease with which it is circumvented. Lots of EULA/TOS terms are unreasonably broad. But let's say the TOS says "use of service without a password is unauthorized". Seems reasonable. Somebody runs a program to guess passwords until they find one that works. "Ah ha," they say, "I have a password, so my usage is now authorized." I don't think a judge or jury will buy that. Even if the password was easy to guess. I believe that was SpikeGronim's point. Assuming the definition of unauthorized is legit, there's no such "it was too easy" defense. Or "I could do it, therefore I must have been allowed to do it."