3 ms·
This was struck down by the courts by the way. Why? If unauthorized access is a federal offense, and unauthorized access can be determined by (e.g.) a EULA, the
by pyre 15y ago
This was struck down by the courts by the way. Why? If unauthorized access is a federal offense, and unauthorized access can be determined by (e.g.) a EULA, then it basically allows a business to dictate criminal law. For example:
1. This would allow all of those 'You agree that you are not a law enforcement official' B.S. 'terms of use' on warez servers to actually have teeth.
2. "If you are a {black,hispanic,gay,etc} person, you are not allowed to access my website."
Do any of these sound reasonable? I should hope not.
- tedunangst 15y agoThat's because those restrictions are illegal themselves. "Don't download the whole database" is not an illegal restriction.
- pyre 15y ago* How about "You are not allowed to hyperlink to this page?" * How about that 'MySpace Hacking' case? From Wikipedia: Judge Wu summed up his opinion by stating that allowing a violation of a website's Terms of Service to constitute an intentional access of a computer without authorization or exceeding authorization would "result in transforming section 1030(a)(2)(C) into an overwhelmingly overbroad enactment that would convert a multitude of otherwise innocent Internet users into misdemeanant criminals." For these reasons, Judge Wu granted Drew's motion for acquittal. Government eventually decided not to appeal [16]. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Lori_Drew http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Lori_Drew
- tedunangst 15y agoI don't think hyperlinking is the crime in question for this case.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- pyre 15y agoMy post wasn't very clear. I was making two separate points.
- tedunangst 15y agoThere are two separate issues as well, whether or not a restriction is valid and the ease with which it is circumvented. Lots of EULA/TOS terms are unreasonably broad. But let's say the TOS says "use of service without a password is unauthorized". Seems reasonable. Somebody runs a program to guess passwords until they find one that works. "Ah ha," they say, "I have a password, so my usage is now authorized." I don't think a judge or jury will buy that. Even if the password was easy to guess. I believe that was SpikeGronim's point. Assuming the definition of unauthorized is legit, there's no such "it was too easy" defense. Or "I could do it, therefore I must have been allowed to do it."