26 ms·
Where’s the Apple M2?
- Recurecur 5y agoThis is a silly take, primarily because it's centered on a single benchmark, Lightroom image import. Image import is generally I/O bound, so not a good fit for CPU comparisons. The GPU issue is relevant, we'll see how the M2 does there. Will Apple need a discrete GPU to compete? All that said, the M1 is most impressive in terms of performance/Watt. We'll see how the M2 holds up against Threadripper/Epyc once the Mac Pro refresh is done and it's benchmarked with many CPU/GPU bound pro workloads. The M2 should be nice for Macbook Pros though. Looking forward to it!
- deregulateMed 5y ago>Will Apple need a discrete GPU to compete? I can already hear the talking heads now "Most users don't need that power(but apparently they need the power of the m1?)" If I know Apple, it will be medium end at extraordinary prices. Post purchase Rationalization will cause users to praise it regardless.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Zababa 5y agoThe other silly thing is that it's presenting the M1 as a big change that they could do again, while it's the result of a series of incremental improvment on the iPhone, and a big change with vertical integration on the laptop that they can't "do again".
- dnhz 5y agoI read the article as arguing the low hanging fruit are picked, and that performance can't quite make another leap. Can't bump up clock speed because it'll use more power or because the CPU design won't support it. There isn't evidence that Apple's team has run out of architectural improvements however, so I do think performance gains are still out there. Plus there's always the possibility of going to smaller semiconductor processes.
- gumby 5y agoI think he’s actually making the point you are: that a step that large is probably impossible at this point in time. Not that I would have expected the step function they did manage to pull off either…
- pvg 5y agoprimarily because it's centered on a single benchmark, Lightroom image import. It's not a very interesting article but it specifically talks about the relative non-importance of that particular benchmark, beside the results being largely a wash: I sorely miss the benchmark I saw in some other publication but can’t find now, where they measured the interactive performance when you load up a series of photos on-screen. These import & export measurements are useful, but frankly when I do that kind of thing I go read email or get a coffee while it’s happening, so it doesn’t really hold me up as such. To date, I haven’t heard anyone saying Lightroom is significantly snappier on an M1 than on a recent Intel MBP. I’d be happy to be corrected.
- andy_ppp 5y agoOne mans new cpu that’s as fast as the highest end Intel chips at the entry level is another persons not snappier. This is the Louis C. K. thing about Internet on a flipping plane not working perfectly and people being super entitled to nice things!
- sudosysgen 5y agoThe highest end Intel chips are really middle of the pack AMD chips, which is the other competitor the M1 is really competing against. All in all its much more of a wash.
- lilyball 5y agoAll I want is a 16" laptop with an M1 and 32GB of RAM. And the extra RAM is just so I can comfortably allocate RAM to VMs.
- dunham 5y agoAnd maybe more two ports?
- rootusrootus 5y agoYES please. I'm generally quite happy with my 13 inch MBP. But I do wish it had two more USB-C ports. Would make things less complicated. I don't really even want a bigger MBP (I have a 16 inch as well, if I need screen real estate, but I really like the portability of the 13). Just the same laptop with four ports would be 80% of ideal. The last 20% would be more RAM.
- asah 5y agoyou read my mind.
- 0xy 5y agoThis but 64GB. Docker, Chrome and IDEs alone regularly consume up to 50GB memory on my Intel MBP. Plus, why the stupid monitor limitation? A "Pro" MacBook needs to be able to have 2-3 monitors with no compromises.
- Apocryphon 5y agoIt’s been a month since WWDC. Wait until fall, that’s when the hardware announcements come anyway. Why complain so early in the year?
- historyloop 5y agoIt's always a great time to complain.
- etaioinshrdlu 5y agoCan we also take a moment to reflect on the odd shape of the M1’s heatspreader? It looks like a normal heatspreader sawn in half.
- floatingatoll 5y agoPerhaps it’s just “We turned out to only need half of the design thermal capacity” meets “let’s break the mold” in half.
- philistine 5y agoIt's literally designed to fit in the space previously used by the fan. They took all the internal shortcuts they could NOT to redesign that machine.
- compactdisc 5y agocame here to say this, kinda. m1 is a chip designed to fit into their current lineup. it makes sense to launch m2 with redesigned hardware or after a hardware redesign. ergo, the M2 will need to fit in the chassis of the new iMac. hardware redesign + new in-house chip = a lot of time I'd be amazed if this even drops this year instead of early 2022 with how long apple's release cycles are. think they'll prob roll out the smaller MBP, the Air, the mini redesigns in the fall/winter, while keeping the current 16" lineup. they'll launch the 16" and larger iMac at next summer's WWDC.
- etaioinshrdlu 5y agoHow do you know it was designed for their current lineup?
- BugsJustFindMe 5y agoIt's exactly the same design as the A12X.
- aledalgrande 5y agoI am constantly between 22-25GB so I definitely need that 32GB RAM. Maybe 64GB for future proofing. I kinda gave up on GPUs on Mac.
- xs 5y agoBut you aren't using an M1. The article says M1s can only go up to 16GB of memory, and the M2 should be able to do 64GB.
- aledalgrande 5y agoThat was my point. That’s why I don’t have an M1.
- historyloop 5y ago"Eight months without perceptibly faster chip!" Get a load of this guy. Can't even wait even a full year, he wants his CPU revolutions every 4 to 8 months.
- philistine 5y agoApple has frustratingly skipped entire Intel generations in the past, leaving their computers to languish for years without updates. If the big Macbook Pro is only released this Fall or next Spring, it will be business as usual for Apple. Same goes for an update to the M1 Macbook Air. I expect that machine to be updated next year at the earliest, with something akin to an M3.
- historyloop 5y agoI wonder if they can't ship the same M1 but with some external RAM and GPU. It won't speed up some apps, but it'll help with Pro apps.
- p_l 5y agoIf you look at all sorts of limitations on the M1 macs (less ports, only one external screen except on Mini where its one DP and one HDMI) it's plain that it's paying the price for using a phone SoC in a general purpose computer - no generic expansion buses, connectors optimised for phone use case, etc. And they are banking hard on unified memory model in all sorts of marketing zbut it's unclear if it's the cause or effect of ring unable to use external GPU.
- matthewfcarlson 5y agoI think this person has no idea how much work goes into bring a product up. It's an incredible amount of work and time that goes into it. And that's with code from Intel/AMD/Qualcomm + reference designs. Designing the silicon and the board and the firmware in under a few years is absolutely ridiculous. To do so in 8 months is ludicrous.
- 5y ago
- chrisseaton 5y ago> But it’s been eight months since the M1 shipped A whole eight months? How often does he want Apple to release new products? What's his problem?
- AgentOrange1234 5y agoI’ll be very surprised if they abandon the yearly cadence they’ve settled into for the phones.
- saagarjha 5y agoMacs are not phones, I don’t see why they need to be updated in the same cycle.
- fouc 5y ago> To date, I haven’t heard anyone saying Lightroom is significantly snappier on an M1 than on a recent Intel MBP. I’d be happy to be corrected. This seems to be throwing the baby out with the bathwater. People have mostly been saying that everything else is snappier on an M1, app launches, task switching, etc.
- philistine 5y agoYeah. Everything is so FAST on my M1. At this point I'd say the fact it has Classic in the name explains why it's slow.
- JyB 5y agoEverything is really really fast, and it never heats up, and it's silent, and the battery last longer. I've been super impressed, biggest 'jump' I felt when going into a new laptop.
- philistine 5y agoThe whole premise is flawed. Intel and AMD can release a CPU whenever they want. Even if the M2 (or whatever) is ready now, in what machine does Apple put it? And more importantly, when does that machine get released to consumers? Apple has never have had a consistent release cycle with their machines, with redesigns clearly slowing down the release cycle. They told us they were on a two-year transition, and we have until WWDC next year at the earliest to finish that transition. And looking at what happened during the first year, it's pretty clear they meant that each machine would be updated once during the transition. The Macbook Air, Mac Mini and 13-inch Macbook Pro were obviously the machines deemed to skip a redesign, and were released first. The 24-inch iMac was redesigned, and I suspect every other computer will get a redesign to go with their new chip. I suspect this Fall, after the new iPhones unveil a new set of cores, we will see those cores used to build a new chip that goes in the machines still due for an update: the big iMac and the big Macbook Pro. The M1 machines will not be updated, and we will only see a Mac Pro at WWDC 2022. Then who knows?
- sneak 5y agoI think a big part in the order of refresh is also minimizing the time spent in transition. It's in Apple's best interest to stop selling x64 arch computers as fast as possible. The logical order would be to do a blazing fast low end chip first in the Air/Mini (tbh I'm surprised they diluted the mbp brand with an iPad chip), with a higher end MBP/iMac chip less than a year later. The iMac Pro was already discontinued and the Mac Pro is vastly less important wrt the architecture transition and can easily be done last. I expect M>1 iMac and/or MBP in September.
- m0dest 5y agoAnd with the long development cycles required for silicon, any conceivable "M1X delay" wouldn't be related to disappointing performance surprises. The M1X would have already been "mostly done" at the moment when the M1 launched. If Apple is dealing with any surprises relating to the silicon, those would most likely be security issues discovered/reported in the M1 platform after launch. Only Apple knows what's on that list – it's definitely not empty – and whether any of them must be fixed before M1X devices ship.
- 5y ago
- jeswin 5y ago> But the returns on memory investment past 16G are, for most people, just not gonna be that dramatic in general and specifically, probably won’t make your media operations feel faster. This is only true for editing still images. If you're editing video (with tools like Davinci Resolve - which is free and excellent), 16GB is going to be quite inadequate.
- HelixEndeavor 5y agoIf you're editing very high bitrate or high resolution video - or both. 16G is perfectly adequate for 1080p video around 30MB/s, which most people's video will be.
- paxys 5y agoConsidering even the cheapest smartphones today record in 4K, and some go up to 60 fps (including iPhone), most people are definitely not editing 1080p videos on their macbooks.
- HelixEndeavor 5y agoI have a phone capable of 4K60, and I never use it, unless my goal is to fill up my phone's storage as quickly as possible. And I've seen reports that the M1 can handle RED RAW 4K footage with just 8G of RAM, and only stutters on 8K. Snazzy Labs even claims that it actually scrubs the timeline smoother than this $10,000 Mac Pro ever did, the only failing is 50% longer render times: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eY-S9EuJ5Xs&t=474s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eY-S9EuJ5Xs&t=474s So this once again proves that the M1 defies our standard expectations and measurements of computer processing power.
- graeme 5y ago> But it’s been eight months since the M1 shipped and we haven’t heard from Apple. I have a good guess what’s going on: It’s proving really hard to make a CPU (or SoC) that’s perceptibly faster than the M1 It’s possible the arguments in the rest of the article are correct, but this isn’t. Hardware cycles take a while and the design for the M1X or M2 was surely settled upon some time ago, probably even before the official M1 release.
- NCFZ 5y agoThere is a global chip shortage. Apple has said the shortage would impact their products.
- Zarel 5y agoYes, this. The high-end M1 iMac shipped with a cooling system more powerful than the M1 can possibly benefit from, and everyone was sure a new MacBook Pro was coming by WWDC. The chip shortage seems like the most likely explanation for both.
- selsta 5y agoNo credible leaker (Ming-Chi Kuo, Gurman) predicted a new MacBook Pro at WWDC.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoThe problem was Jon Prosser who was telling all the YouTubers it was going to happen. Even though he's been seemingly wrong as many times as he's right.
- jagger27 5y agoIt’s a bit more nuanced than that. From what I understand it’s ripples from higher up in the supply chain that are causing delays (substrate, power components, etc.). TSMC on its own is doing fine.
- floatingatoll 5y agoI think the missing premise in this article is that they control the operating system in lockstep with the CPU, and so when they optimize frameworks and objective-C internals for CPU hardware acceleration, they can require those OS optimizations for each revision of their CPU, with no backward compatability whatsoever. The best analogy I can think of is to imagine if epoll or dbus were hardware-accelerated, and every year a silicon update and a kernel update added more or improved acceleration for more and more components. We don’t yet know what the speed gains possible from reducing OS overhead are, but I bet Apple does, and I bet it doesn’t require frequency bumps at all. If someone has compiled vmlinuz into FPGA tapeout somehow, that would be a good point of comparison. (“Inconceivable!”, except not so much nowadays..) [I can’t find the tweet linked in the past few weeks about CPU-accelerated ObjC calls, but there’s an HN discussion about it that’s worth reading.]
- saagarjha 5y agoApple’s OS optimization for their processors doesn’t really look like what you’re describing, it’s more general-purpose than that except for a handful of hardware accelerators for extremely hot code.
- b9a2cab5 5y agoIf that were the case Safari wouldn't perform much better than Chrome on certain benchmarks on Apple ARM based devices. But I think "optimization" is more making commonly used instructions really fast (such as uncontended atomics) and providing custom instruction extensions to accelerate common use cases in hardware (for example, I believe there is an undocumented branch prediction hint capability, whereas afaik for x86 you can only tell your compiler to order branches according to compile-time hints).
- floatingatoll 5y agoIt’s definitely only M1, that’s for sure. But I suspect it’ll be more than that over time. We’ll see, I suppose!
- teruakohatu 5y ago> The idea isn’t crazy. The last few releases of Lightroom have claimed to make more use of the GPU Lightroom keeps claiming this on new releases, and have done for years, and users keep finding very little improvement. Adobe clearly wants users moving to the non-Classic cloud. > Anyhow, it’d be really surprising if Apple managed to get ahead of GPU makers like NVidia. Now, at this point, based on the M1 we should expect surprises from Apple. But I’m not even sure that’d be their best silicon bet. I would be very surprised, competition is intense and there is a lot of money on the table for anyone with a better architecture. Nvidia would compete for any acquisitions. Ultimately does Apple even need to compete with Nvidia? They don't care about gaming, just desktop graphics and local ML inference.
- smoldesu 5y agoWell, you had to wonder when that 5nm advantage was going to take it's toll. Considering that they spent almost an entire node and a half on increasing efficiency, it's unlikely that they'll be selling pro hardware until they can can get their hands on 3nm silicon: without some increase in chip density, they're going to continue to languish in M1 elo-hell.
- MangoCoffee 5y ago3nm is coming https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Tech/Semiconductors/Apple-and-Intel-become-first-to-adopt-TSMC-s-latest-chip-tech https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Tech/Semiconductors/Apple-a...
- joakleaf 5y agoI seriously doubt Apple would take such a big step as switch cpu architecture, if they didn’t already know how to make the first few cpu generations. That would be way too risky. If I were Tim, I would have needed a 5-10 year detailed road map from the chip-designers before making this step. The idea that Apple made the m1, and somehow got stuck now is a bit silly. Most likely, they know what they are doing. They might hit unexpected problems 3-4 years from now, but not right now. The m1x and m2 will only be incremental steps forward. That’s how the A-series have progressed, and that’s fine.
- dev_tty01 5y agoHmm. Not very interesting take. First, the M1 is the 12th chip design in the Apple Silicon series (excluding the X variants). They have cranked out a more capable, higher performing, lower power chip every year since 2010. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_silicon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_silicon Second, it's not about clock rate. That is only one small part of the story. It is really about instructions per cycle per core. Apple is killing it on that front and running wider at lower rates is a big part of how they are outperforming in performance per watt while still winning in single core performance. We may see some clock rate increase in an M2, but I suspect their basic design philosophy won't change. It is just working too well. For the curious, see https://travisdowns.github.io/blog/2019/06/11/speed-limits.html#ooo-table https://travisdowns.github.io/blog/2019/06/11/speed-limits.h.... That table shows that the M1 has a much bigger reorder buffer, large load and store buffers, huge integer and vector register files, way more branches in flight, etc. By eschewing high clock rates, they are able to really go after massive concurrency at the hardware level in a single core. 7 simultaneous integer operations, 4 simultaneous floating point, multiple load and store. It's a beast. https://www.anandtech.com/show/16226/apple-silicon-m1-a14-deep-dive/2 https://www.anandtech.com/show/16226/apple-silicon-m1-a14-de... Of course they will come out with an M2 soon. They've been doing this year after year for over a decade.
- saagarjha 5y ago> First, the M1 is the 12th chip design in the Apple Silicon series How are you counting that?
- BugsJustFindMe 5y agoA4,A5,A6,...,A14,M1
- mastazi 5y agoI'm not parent but the A series starts with A4 which was the first commercially released model. So between A4-A14 we have 11 generations, and M1 is the 12th.
- 5y ago
- mastazi 5y ago> Anyhow, it’d be really surprising if Apple managed to get ahead of GPU makers like NVidia. I disagree and I think that based on what we've seen with the current constraints (fanless etc.) actually Apple can come out with some very competitive products in the pro/desktop/larger-laptops space. In fact, I also think that probably the GPU will be the main differentiator between low-end and high-end Apple silicon models.
- bredren 5y agoMy hypothesis is a major push on gpu-based compute. Specializing in ML training.
- eyelidlessness 5y agoThe rumors from rumor sources are that the M1X or M2 was expected to be released at WWDC but delayed because of delays sourcing Mini LED panels. Obviously that's based on rumors, but it's a lot more plausible than the hypothesis that Apple, a company which has executed a very similar platform transition before while maintaining internal builds for their target platform, vastly overestimated their own capabilities.
- saagarjha 5y agoThere’s also a global pandemic going on that’s affecting the supply chain for a bunch of components.
- roamerz 5y agoShoot just make the MBP 16 with 2 M1’s that are designed to run in parallel and only fire up #2 when you need it.
- a-dub 5y agothere's still a lot of cool stuff that could be done in silicon: 1) cross execution caching of unchanged segments of code: if the ram state doesn't change across runs for a set of instructions, could execution be sped up by caching that ram state with os and silicon support for applying it? 2) assured computing: cryptographic guarantees about exactly which instructions executed, on which physical machine with what inputs 3) hardware support for accelerated vms emulating other architectures 4) more efficiency gains by having more stuff like the low power cores for light workloads 5) more of the cool specialty cores for accelerating ml/dsp/linalg 6) better in-silicon multitenant separation for security 7) in-silicon support for reducing memory costs of running multiple versions that are mostly similar of libraries (hardware support for containers) are just a few... apple is in a great place because their vertical integration makes some of these possible. (and the good stuff of course would eventually make it to commodity hardware)
- saagarjha 5y agoSeems a bit premature, honestly. If you’ve been paying attention to iPhones, Apple has been pushing steady improvements year after year. Some years it’s more, some year it’s less, but every year they have a new microarchitecture and it’s faster than the one from last year. I see no reason for Apple to suddenly stop being able to improve performance in their next generation chips, especially as they clearly have much more thermal and multicore headroom to spend.
- matthewfcarlson 5y agoI remember having lunch with some google engineers who lamented that they would find clever optimizations and management would save them for future generations. It makes sense from a marketing standpoint, but from an engineering standpoint it drove the engineers nuts. I get it though, it offers a good path to having consistent gains.
- dannyw 5y agoI'm going to be honest: while the author certainly has credibility, and whilst there's nothing really factually wrong with any technicals mentioned here, the opinions here seem nonsensical and show a lack of understanding of how chips are made. Apple's chip design team is working on M3 if not M4 right now.
- dev_tty01 5y agoYes, this. The M2 design has been finished for some time to allow plenty of time for testing. Same with products. I always find it hilarious when "journalists" write articles about how Apple is still debating X vs Y for some hardware feature on the next gen phones due in 3 months. No chance. Hardware is hard and takes big lead times and huge amounts of testing.
- vlovich123 5y agoThat is typically true. However, when developing risky new HW, it's not uncommon to have all variants built & do a late-binding decision. It's expensive but it gives SW & HW engineering more time to flush out a marquee feature (e.g. I don't doubt that FaceID may have had TouchId as a fallback until late, although probably not as late as a month or two before announcements).
- bredren 5y agoWe’ve also seen some unexpected stumbles leading to late changes. The failed release of shaped batteries in the 2016 MBP [0], and the jet-falls-off-the-aircraft-carrier release of AirPower. [1] I generally agree Apple makes plans in advance and follows through on them. However, the company seems to push very hard on some product release deadlines and sometimes they miss. [0] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-12-20/how-apple-alienated-mac-loyalists https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-12-20/how-apple... [1] https://www.bloombergquint.com/technology/apple-cancels-anticipated-airpower-wireless-charging-accessory https://www.bloombergquint.com/technology/apple-cancels-anti...
- dev_tty01 5y ago
- xmodem 5y ago> I have a good guess what’s going on: It’s proving really hard to make a CPU (or SoC) that’s perceptibly faster than the M1. Here’s why. This is daft. Chips are not something that you can finalise the design of and have in customers hands tomorrow, next week, or next month. Whatever pro-level AS device Apple ends up shipping, the design of it was finalised by the end of last year at the latest. What's far more likely is they either never planned to ship it ad WWDC, or (more likely) they're affected by the same market dynamics as everyone else in terms of the ongoing semiconductor shortages.
- numair 5y agoThere are two theories to what is going on: 1) The best silicon designers in the world have hit a wall and can’t improve on a processor they shipped to production a year ago. 2) There is a massive, global-scale supply chain disaster that is largely hidden from the end consumer which is secretly driving every major manufacturer insane. It seems that a bunch of industry “insiders” want to go with option 1; personally, I’ll take the second option.
- dev_tty01 5y agoThird theory. There is no problem. Apple is executing their plan on the two year schedule they announced. They are releasing hardware on the schedules they always have.
- boardwaalk 5y agoNot even a year. All I’ve heard is that the mini LED screens for the next (M1X) MacBooks haven’t been available in volume/to spec quite yet. I’m really not thinking there’s any real delay of concern here yet. Not enough to write the above article and speculate somewhat needlessly.
- mberning 5y agoAssume they had a finalized design for M2 at the same time as M1. If their plan was to produce and roll out machines based on M2 shortly after the release of M1 they likely were not able to do it as planned due to COVID bottlenecks. Almost every company that produces physical products had to focus their resources on producing high volume parts. This has happened quite a bit in trailer manufacturing for example. All of the raw materials are going towards high volume selling trailer models. Niche trailers models are not being made in any significant quantity.
- UncleOxidant 5y ago" But it’s been eight months since the M1 shipped and we haven’t heard from Apple." Sheesh, 8 months is not a long time as far as these sorts of things go. Wasn't the M2 not expected until next year at the earliest? Given the current semiconductor production issues that might even be optimistic.
- sroussey 5y agoGeez, does he not know long it takes just to fab a chip? Find a mistake, fix, retype, and start over.
- phire 5y agoThere are two routes Apple could have take for the 2nd Apple Silicon chip. 1. Apple could take the M1 design and just increased the number of Firestorm CPU cores (along with everything else). It would be an M1X, along exactly the same lines as the A10X and A12X. 2. Apple could create a next generation design with the eight or more of same Firestorm-next cores we will see in the A15 Bionic. Call it the M2. The M1X would have been easy enough for apple, and I think if it existed, we would have seen it by now. But it would have suffered from many of the same flaws that the M1 suffers from. The inability to drive more than two displays being a notable one. I think apple decided to skip the M1X and go straight for the M2. But it's a little too early for the M2 to launch. As it will be using the same cpu and gpu cores as the A15, it kind of needs to launch at around the same time at the earliest; Maybe a month or two earlier as they don't need to stockpile as much silicon for the M2s. My prediction is that we might see an M2 announced in August or September.
- wmf 5y agoBut [M1X] would have suffered from many of the same flaws that the M1 suffers from. The inability to drive more than two displays being a notable one. No? Larger chips generally also have more I/O.
- phire 5y agoIt's not actually an I/O problem. An M1 macbook can drive a massive 6K monitor with no issues from either thunderbolt port. But try to drive two 1080p or 720p monitors. Impossible. The issue is the M1 only has two CRTCs to drive the video timings.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- j16sdiz 5y agoNot very interesting. This is more like a wishlist than analysis.
- ggm 5y agoI think a lot of the critique here is misguided. The summary at the end seemed to me entirely reasonable: writing good code for parallelism is very hard, and moves the cost upward into software which has to be really well written to work. Boosting IO and cache will help with some things, but absent clockspeed, making an M2 significantly better than an M1 is hard. I don't see why people complain its only one benchmark. to import 100MB of image data invites all of the IO, Cache and CPU to play along because this is encoded data: it has to be mapped out of one form, transformed into another, as a stream of data and its a lot bigger than either a single fetch from memory, or a single bus transaction. Its ameneble to parallelism within some limits depending on the nature of the encoding. It's also a real-world test.
- ehutch79 5y agoSo many youtube channels CONFIRMED that latops with the M2 would land at wwdc
- aheilbut 5y agoThe speed is pretty much irrelevant right now All they need to do is support external RAM so they can make a machine with up to 128 or 256gb of memory. It's easy enough, but for their reasons they have just chosen not to do it yet.
- lamontcg 5y ago32+ GB would sell me on it quite easy. 16GB is too cramped right now. Bumping the GPU would be useful as well, doesn't need to match a 3080, but an incremental improvement would be nice.
- paxys 5y ago> I have a good guess what’s going on: It’s proving really hard to make a CPU (or SoC) that’s perceptibly faster than the M1. While I don't buy this at all, I don't even want a chip that is perceptibly faster than the M1. Instead give me other "pro" features like more than 2 USB ports, 32GB RAM, multiple external displays, external GPU support, boot camp, larger SSD capacity.
- camillomiller 5y ago> To date, I haven’t heard anyone saying Lightroom is significantly snappier on an M1 than on a recent Intel MBP. I’d be happy to be corrected. LOL. Has the author even spoken with actual photographers? Also, Lightroom Classic? Seriously? Lightroom CC is blazing fast on an M1. I know because it has been my go to real-life benchmark with all the M1 Macs I tested so far (all of them). You should of course compare them with similarly priced Intel Macs. But anyway, try working on 1000+ Canon Eos R5 raw files on a MacBook Pro M1 and the latest MacBook Pro Intel, then tell me which one’s faster. I’m not sure I would be able to hear you over the noise of the Intel Mac’s fans, though. This “perception of speed” theory doesn’t hold up to explain the M1X/M2 delay. I definitely believe TSMC’s bottlenecks are a much more probable explanation.
- foobarbazetc 5y agoWeird take —- kind of the “640kb should be enough for anybody” but about one specific CPU that we know is about to get replaced with the M1X/M2. Unsure what the point is here. And there are plenty of workloads which are easily parallelizable across cores. Like compiling things. Or just running multiple programs at once. Which you can see by typing “ps”.
- bilalq 5y agoThe biggest issue for me is that the M1 Macbooks can't drive two external displays. A GPU improvement (or whatever else is holding it back here) is sorely needed for a "Pro" device. 32GB RAM would be nice as well.
- lincpa 5y agoThe Apple M1 chip is based on my "warehouse (memory)/workshop (cores&others) model". Reference: The Grand Unified Programming Theory: The Pure Function Pipeline Data Flow with Principle-based Warehouse/Workshop Model https://github.com/linpengcheng/PurefunctionPipelineDataflow https://github.com/linpengcheng/PurefunctionPipelineDataflow