5 ms·
My guess is that it would have taken a couple more nukes to settle things. Whoever got the Bomb first was always going to win WWII, if only because there was so
by CamperBob2 5y ago
My guess is that it would have taken a couple more nukes to settle things. Whoever got the Bomb first was always going to win WWII, if only because there was so little social or ethical opprobrium associated with atomic warfare at the time.
If forced into an existential conflict by a string of Axis victories on all major fronts, we would've turned most of the planet into a smoking crater, and there would have been nothing Japan, Germany, Russia, or anyone else could have done about it.
Everything leading up to August 6 was just so much posturing.
- maverick-iceman 5y agoBut once the dust settled...would the US hold the same moral high ground that it has today had it used 20 atomic bombs? And would the US be so magnanimous in victory had the toll been higher due to Axis victories on all major fronts (meaning that the human losses of the Axis were transfered to the Allies) up to the Atomic bombs use?
- ThrowawayR2 5y ago> "But once the dust settled...would the US hold the same moral high ground that it has today had it used 20 atomic bombs?" About 2.5 times as many people in Asia were killed by the Japanese as died in the German Holocaust. Let that sink in. Anything the US did would have been seen as negligible in comparison.
- Smithalicious 5y agoIt's not fair to equate war deaths with genocide deaths
- CamperBob2 5y agoWhat do you think the Japanese were planning to do, exactly?
- hnzix 5y agoJapan's wartime actions in Manchuria were a genocide, they followed the "Three Alls" policy: "kill all, burn all, loot all". Arguably responsible for the deaths of more than 2.7 million Chinese civilians. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Alls_Policy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Alls_Policy
- ThrowawayR2 5y agoWar deaths? Surely you jest. Most of that 2.5x were civilians and were killed by the Imperial Japanese Army in ways a lot nastier than the concentration camps; it was genocide in all but name. The depth of hatred for the Japanese among older Asians is staggering for that very reason.
- AlbertCory 5y agoThere's a special on Prime about something you almost NEVER hear about: the Soviet Manchurian invasion. Which is what finally convinced the Emperor he had to stop it. The USSR had 1.5 million troops involved, and not surprisingly won a crushing victory. Look at the dates: Aug. 9 was Nagasaki. It wasn't until the 15th that they surrendered. Up until then, the war councils actually thought Stalin would intervene and force a better peace than the "unconditional surrender" the Allies demanded. I know everyone believes the A-bomb ended the war. Unfortunately even that wasn't enough. If it was, the Japanese would have surrendered on Aug. 10. That's not to contradict CamperBob2 about the US would have done. We could only produce about one bomb per month, though, IIRC.
- PhasmaFelis 5y agoIt's hard to imagine that anyone with observers in, or news from, the European theater could imagine that surrendering to Stalin was a better idea than surrendering to the US.
- CamperBob2 5y agoIndeed. It's well documented that Wehrmacht soldiers went out of their way to surrender to American and UK forces rather than fall into Russian hands.[1] Tip to HN users: "This is indisputably true but I don't like it" isn't a good reason to downvote people. 1: https://socratic.org/questions/why-did-germans-forces-surrender-en-masse-to-u-s-and-british-forces-rather-than- https://socratic.org/questions/why-did-germans-forces-surren...
- coldtea 5y ago>Indeed. It's well documented that Wehrmacht soldiers went out of their way to surrender to American and UK forces rather than fall into Russian hands.[1] That's because Wehrmacht soldiers and their pals have warred on USSR, and took millions of lives and caused untold suffering there. The Japanese, at that point, not so much. So, angry retribution against Wehrmacht soldier scum was to be expected...
- slothtrop 5y agoMaybe not even that. By the time they dropped the nukes, 90% of structures in Japan were razed, in a far more deadly manner. Russians were a looming, merciless threat the Japanese leadership was very conscious of. There has been the suggestion that use of the Bomb had allowed for a good excuse to surrender to the U.S. then and there, because dealing with Russians would have been worse. I'm writing this from memory of an article on foreignpolicy dot com 5-7 years ago