4 ms·
There was a thread on Twitter a few months ago about "history balancing on a knife's edge." All the examples (many of which also appear here) are fascinating.
by AlbertCory 5y ago
There was a thread on Twitter a few months ago about "history balancing on a knife's edge." All the examples (many of which also appear here) are fascinating.
My own favorite (no disrespect to the others) is C. Wade McClusky, the hero of the Battle of Midway in WW II. He just happened to find the Japanese carriers, where no one else would have thought to look, and sink them.
Had the US lost, it might have lost Hawaii as well. Then what would have happened? I can't say and neither can anyone else.
- vkou 5y ago> Then what would have happened? All that would have happened was that the war in the pacific would have been extended by another six to twelve months. Japan had constant oil shortages[0], had over a million men tied up in a land war in China, and its naval capacity was outproduced five-to-one by the United States. [1] The outcome of the War in the Pacific was inevitable, as of December 8th, 1941. [2] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_production_during_World_War_II#Resources https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_production_during_Wor... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_production_during_World_War_II#Naval_forces https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_production_during_Wor... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Day_of_Infamy_speech https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Day_of_Infamy_speech
- AlbertCory 5y agoIt's so easy to pronounce the final outcome "inevitable" isn't it? There's no one to prove you wrong. The great imponderable of war is the population's willingness to keep waging it. I don't know what would have happened and neither does Wikipedia.
- kaesar14 5y agoSuch comments totally ignore the human element of warfare, totally agreed with you.
- labster 5y agoIt’s hard to imagine a world where the US in 1941 would not use its industrial power to assert hegemony over the Pacific after being attacked. The Japanese strategy was to neutralize the US fast enough to reduce morale for waging a losing war. But US morale remained high throughout, so it too is hard to imagine a world where the strategy would succeed even if the attack on Pearl was executed flawlessly. The anime Zipang brings up a more interesting point: had oil been discovered ten years earlier in Manchuria, would Japan have attacked the US and Dutch at all? Possibly yes: the question of “how do we defeat America?” eclipsed the more important “should we defeat America?” in Imperial Japan.
- HarryHirsch 5y agoImagine that organometallic chemistry had developed quicker, and decent Ziegler-Natta catalysts had been discovered in 1935 instead of 1955. Would the Japanese have gone to war over the caoutchouc plantations in Southeast Asia instead of relying on synthetic rubber?
- scottLobster 5y agoTo be fair, the Japanese strategy also relied on heavily fortifying the territory they took and then daring the Americans to take it back. With another 6-12 months they might have had time to build up much stronger defenses. If every island was as bad as Iwo Jima/Okinawa it's an open question how long the American public would have supported the war. We ended up using nukes for multiple reasons as it was, one of which was doubt that the American public would stomach the cost of an invasion of the Japanese home islands.
- fatbird 5y agoAt the time, the U.S. Admirals recognized that clearing the occupied islands wasn't necessary and would be ruinously expensive. Their explicit goal was to create airstrips within bomber reach of the Japanese home islands. Even with 6-12 more months to fortify, it's not obvious that the outcome wouldn't be the same, with the U.S. grabbing a few key islands and ignoring the rest.
- pas 5y ago
- random314 5y agoIf you have studied world war 2. We can make a more informed guess. The Japanese admiral considered the war doomed from the start, with the only hope being the destruction of all the 4 American aircraft carriers. The battle of midway instead knocked out of all Japanese aircraft carriers. Unbeknownst to Japan, the United states was already pumping out several aircraft carriers per month and was also developing the nuclear bomb. The only possible change could have been surrendering to the Soviet union instead of United states. However, even that seems unlikely given the N bomb.
- CamperBob2 5y agoThere's no one to prove you wrong. Dude named Oppenheimer begs to differ.
- crubier 5y agoNo one knows with certainty indeed. But we do know with high probability that the outcome would have been roughly similar given the massive unbalance of important metrics.
- canjobear 5y agoIt’s easy to wax philosophical about how we can’t predict things, and it’s true that you can never have certainty, but it really is relatively cut and dried here. There are many cases in history that could have gone the other way. But Japan was terribly outmatched in every way in 1941.
- AlbertCory 5y agoI don't dispute that and you're probably right, but I'd just ask: What would you have said about England after Dunkirk? (With no hindsight allowed.)
- vkou 5y agoAfter Dunkirk, England was at the head of an empire that numbered over half a billion people - a quarter of the world's population, a similar industrial output to Germany, uncontested dominance of the seas, and a sympathetic United States that was supplying food, munitions, and warships. It was a far closer fight than the United States and Japan. An invasion of the isles would have been impossible to pull off, and the war would almost certainly had gone the same way that it did - years of fighting over African colonies.
- xref 5y agoRemember Japan was angling for a peace where they got to keep a lot of their conquered territories, even if the US could manufacture more stuff eventually it doesn’t mean we wouldn’t have settled to end the war. America still takes a lot of flack for demanding unconditional surrender which led us to drop two nukes on Japan. “The US could have just accepted peace terms with some concessions to Japan, then they wouldn’t have had to drop the bombs” is the line of argument.
- CamperBob2 5y agoMy guess is that it would have taken a couple more nukes to settle things. Whoever got the Bomb first was always going to win WWII, if only because there was so little social or ethical opprobrium associated with atomic warfare at the time. If forced into an existential conflict by a string of Axis victories on all major fronts, we would've turned most of the planet into a smoking crater, and there would have been nothing Japan, Germany, Russia, or anyone else could have done about it. Everything leading up to August 6 was just so much posturing.
- maverick-iceman 5y agoBut once the dust settled...would the US hold the same moral high ground that it has today had it used 20 atomic bombs? And would the US be so magnanimous in victory had the toll been higher due to Axis victories on all major fronts (meaning that the human losses of the Axis were transfered to the Allies) up to the Atomic bombs use?
- ThrowawayR2 5y ago> "But once the dust settled...would the US hold the same moral high ground that it has today had it used 20 atomic bombs?" About 2.5 times as many people in Asia were killed by the Japanese as died in the German Holocaust. Let that sink in. Anything the US did would have been seen as negligible in comparison.
- Smithalicious 5y agoIt's not fair to equate war deaths with genocide deaths
- CamperBob2 5y agoWhat do you think the Japanese were planning to do, exactly?
- hnzix 5y agoJapan's wartime actions in Manchuria were a genocide, they followed the "Three Alls" policy: "kill all, burn all, loot all". Arguably responsible for the deaths of more than 2.7 million Chinese civilians. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Alls_Policy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Alls_Policy
- bsder 5y agoNot much. Japan couldn't possibly have kept Hawaii past the middle of the war. There is a nice video somewhere on YouTube that shows the production of US naval ships vs Japanese naval ships in scaled time. It is shocking the amount of ships that that US was producing starting near the middle of the war. A new destroyer or cruiser rolled out every couple of days. Japan wasn't even close. I imagine that staffing the ships at some point was going to become a problem.
- GrumpyYoungMan 5y agoProbably Military History Visualized's "Why Japan had NO Chance in WW2": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9ag2x3CS9M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9ag2x3CS9M . Go to the 12:30 mark for the the near-final ship totals.
- tomcam 5y agoI’ve never heard of that channel before. That visualization leaves absolutely no questions.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoMost if not all of the US Navy was in the Pacific and there were enough defenses that the Japanese could not have taken Hawaii. The reason they could take much of Manchuria and southeast Asia is their defenses were mostly filled with pre WWI era weapons or had little to no defenses. They just blitzkrieged the entire place. Hawaii had significant modern defenses capable of warding off an invasionary force. Which is why Pearl Harbor wasn't a legitimate invasion. Japan just wanted to knock out US involvement. They didn't honestly want a long term conflict and take over like in "The Man in the High Castle."
- ternaryoperator 5y ago>Had the US lost, it might have lost Hawaii as well. Then what would have happened? I can't say and neither can anyone else. Once the US had nuclear weapons, the result was not in doubt. Putting aside nuclear arms as your comment seems to do, the question is not nearly as open as you make it out to be: Japan was heavily outmatched in resources, facing an array of enemies while having no significant allies of its own in the Pacific theater. So, even on a non-nuclear basis, they were in deep trouble. The best they could have hoped for was a stalemate: the Allies reclaim all lost ground, but don't invade the Japanese mainland.
- piokoch 5y agoUS could not lost. Japan was running out of resources - steel, oil (in fact blocked access to resources was what pushed them to the war they could not win). Maybe war on Pacific would last a bit longer, probably it will cost more lives, but from the beginning it was lost for Japan. That's why using atomic bomb had no real military justification, it was just a very powerful political demonstration and USA retaliation on Japanese people.
- fruityrudy 5y agoThe Japanese were fanatical and vowed to fight to the very end. There is also the story where they found a couple of Japanese soldiers who didn’t realize the war ended and maintained their post for several years after the surrender. Who knows how long a ‘bit longer’ would be. And a land invasion would have been devastatingly long drawn out conflict.
- coldtea 5y ago>The Japanese were fanatical and vowed to fight to the very end. That's the official pretext / party line of the US, to self-justify the nuclear bombings (as if they ever could be justified). The reality is the Japanese were dead scared (also of the incoming Soviets) and were looking to surrender. They just didn't want an unconditional surrender, but to save some face/dignity.
- yourapostasy 5y ago> ...the Japanese were dead scared...and were looking to surrender... Just how widespread was this sentiment at that time? Reading the accounts of the Kyūjō incident starting from the Wikipedia entry and branching from there [1], I got the sense that some of the Imperial Japanese Army leadership prevarication in the very early phases of the incident up to Kawabe's organizing of the agreement was this history's knife's edge playing out again. I just lack the cultural referents to even understand how significant was the fact that after the emperor's stiffly formal announcement, there was a broadcast immediately following to confirm in lay language that indeed it was a surrender announcement. If specialist historians with the appropriate cross-cultural training can confirm it was that opaque to the Japanese themselves, then I wouldn't be surprised that the Americans misread the cues that Japanese were giving in their attempts to surrender, not helped by their selection of the Soviet Union as an intermediary that turned out to be an unreliable partner. This is all on top of the usual chaotic swirl of the fog of war. There are criticisms against the narrative the Japanese were trying to surrender but the US ignored those attempts because the US wanted to use the nuclear bombs [2]. And there are narratives that the nuclear bombs were not decisive, but the Soviets opening another front was [3]. This account gives some useful color background to the decisions' context [4]. General consensus of casual discussions (as opposed to scholarly studies, which I couldn't find) of why the US didn't use the nuclear bomb on Tokyo seems to converge upon the US leadership emerging a strategy that desires a negotiated peace with some Japanese power structure intact. So any narrative that the US "just wants to use the bombs" takes place within the framework of the demonstrated and carried out desire for a negotiated conclusion. It might not have been as simple as "we want to use The Bomb, and by God, we'll use it", it might have been used as an instrument to achieving the strategic objective. And there is definitely room to strenuously object to that use even within that framework, but for me to be convinced it was objectively black-and-white "wrong", I'd have to know more about the information and context the decision-makers on both sides operated upon, not the hindsight information we are privy to. Would appreciate any pointers to material along those lines. What I took away from that pivot point in history is war is indeed, hell. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ky%C5%ABj%C5%8D_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ky%C5%ABj%C5%8D_incident [2] https://historynewsnetwork.org/article/52502 https://historynewsnetwork.org/article/52502 [3] https://www.carnegiecouncil.org/education/008/expertclips/010 https://www.carnegiecouncil.org/education/008/expertclips/01... [4] https://www.nationalww2museum.org/war/articles/japans-surrender-part-i https://www.nationalww2museum.org/war/articles/japans-surren...
- jeffdn 5y agoYou should read Shattered Sword, by Parshall and Tully. It is one of the most comprehensive accounts of Midway I've ever read, and dives deeply into Japanese archival sources in a way that the vast majority of histories of Midway do not. The last third of the book is a discussion of the effect that Midway had on the war. The short version is that the Japanese did not have the merchant tonnage available to support operations already in progress at that point in the war. An invasion of Japan would've required landing several infantry divisions, across thousands of miles of open water, too far from any airstrips for land-based aircraft to support them. The Hawaiian islands are small, but Oahu, Maui, and Hawaii are big enough for maneuver warfare. An American loss at Midway would've been a huge setback, especially had all three carriers been lost. The rate of commissioning of new Essex-class ships, not to mention the light and escort carriers, however, would've more than made up for the loss by mid-1943, and the Japanese simply did not have the industrial capacity to sustain a long naval war of attrition. An American victory was not inevitable, but there's a fairly strong case to be made that the means by which the war was begun, by a sneak attack, had incensed the American populace sufficiently that even further serious naval defeats wouldn't've sapped their willingness to fight on. Indeed, several more American carriers were lost throughout 1942 (Hornet and Wasp), as well as the calamitous loss of four cruisers at Savo Island.
- AlbertCory 5y agoThat's a good analysis. I don't actually think they would have "won" the war. I think their aims were really to dominate Asia and have the U.S. accept that, if grudgingly. There was certainly no desire to do a Man in the High Castle thing.