4 ms·
This is a very frightening belief. How long until posting a negative comment to a blog is "unautorized access" to that blog? Gaining access was easy: all you
by jrockway 15y ago
This is a very frightening belief.
How long until posting a negative comment to a blog is "unautorized access" to that blog? Gaining access was easy: all you had to do was type a comment and hit submit. But some Powers That Be decided they didn't really want you to post that, so now it's a federal computer crime.
Land of the free.
- _delirium 15y agoThat's currently unsettled, and yes a lot of computer-crime experts (even typically law-and-order-leaning ones) consider it a huge problem--- it might actually be a federal crime to post a comment on a blog in violation of the blog's Terms of Service. This case is currently winding its way through the courts, and will hopefully be overturned: http://volokh.com/2011/06/14/petition-for-rehearing-filed-in-united-states-v-nosal-ninth-circuit-case-on-criminalizing-violations-of-computer-use-policies/ http://volokh.com/2011/06/14/petition-for-rehearing-filed-in...
- kronusaturn 15y agoThis problem extends way beyond hacking laws—the average person in the US probably commits several felonies a day: http://www.threefelonies.com/Youtoo/tabid/86/Default.aspx http://www.threefelonies.com/Youtoo/tabid/86/Default.aspx
- jrockway 15y agoI read this book and think that federal crimes are punished too harshly, but the people profiled seem far from average.
- tptacek 15y agoSpeaking of "TV drama levels of understanding of criminal justice"... :) With only a few exceptions, persons accused of crimes are not presumed to have mens rea. Statutory rape, for instance, has "strict liability"; even if you don't know you're committing a crime, you're liable. Most criminal offenses are not like this. The state is required to establish mens rea. A prosecutor could say that a ToS-infringing blog comment is a criminal violation, but unless that prosecutor can establish that the comment was made in purposeful, knowing, or reckless violation of the ToS, they'd be wasting their time.
- awj 15y agoYou're getting hung up on the "access" part, it's the "authorization" that's important. In your example it would likely be almost impossible for the blog owner to prove that someone intent on posting negative comments was not authorized to do so. As a side note, I think we all should be more careful with "omg, we're losing our freedoms!" comments. They're usually not as clever as they feel at the time, and have the dangerous property of inuring us to such claims.