6 ms·
They are talking about theft of services, not copyright infringement. In any event these charges are going to be very difficult to beat since they're federal, e
by Alex3917 15y ago
They are talking about theft of services, not copyright infringement. In any event these charges are going to be very difficult to beat since they're federal, even though there are some obvious holes in the indictment. It will be almost impossible to get any of the evidence thrown out even if there was an illegal search and seizure. His best bet is probably to get the Harvard legal team to go to bat for him, although it's difficult to say how likely that is.
- _delirium 15y agoI wasn't really commenting on the legal sufficiency of the indictment, just the rhetorical dishonesty of accusing someone of "steal[ing] well over 4,000,000 articles from JSTOR" (quote from the indictment) when JSTOR didn't own those articles. They could've just alleged violation of JSTOR's TOS and thereby theft of network services. I suspect JSTOR or people sympathetic to them had a hand in writing the indictment, though; JSTOR has a long history of attempting to spread the misinformation that it somehow "owns" its archive.
- thisuser 15y agoHe is accused of stealing bandwidth from JSTOR, not the documents. "Theft of services" not theft of property. Theft of bandwidth is almost as absurd as theft via copying. JSTOR apparently isn't interested in free transmission of knowledge
- a3camero 15y agoIf you read the indictment you'll see that they very much are not interested in free transmission of knowledge. They charge >$50k/yr for access: " For a large research university, this annual subscription fee for JSTOR’s various collections of content can cost more than $50,000."
- jackpirate 15y agoThat price actually seems pretty reasonable for a large research university. The real question is how much they charge individuals who want to get an article. My first google search (http://www.jstor.org/pss/27757488 http://www.jstor.org/pss/27757488) results in $12/article. This is very steep when you're trying to do research and don't even know if the article is what you're looking for.
- Vivtek 15y agoWell, you wouldn't want any old rabble getting access to valuable knowledge. Far better for that access to be safely controlled by the major research institutions, who can clearly be trusted to pursue knowledge in a responsible manner.
- a3camero 15y agoHow is that reasonable? Sounds like Mr. Swartz was willing to host them for free! And he would have gotten away with it too if it wasn't for those meddling police. But seriously, $12/article is ludicrous. That must be way above cost recovery or they're not doing a very efficient job of running JSTOR. Perhaps the co-founder of Reddit would do a better job...
- xefer 15y agoMost public libraries have relationships with JSTOR that allow members to access the articles online. I use the Boston Public Library and look up articles via Google Scholar. All free.
- mbreese 15y ago> somehow "owns" its archive It does own its archive. They just may not own the exclusive copyright to the contents of the archive... there is a subtle distinction.
- sqrt17 15y agoThere is no non-exclusive copyright. J-STOR is not the copyright owner, period. They do own the right to the composition of their collection, so someone who got the whole collection would be liable to infringing their right on the composition of the collection; in contrast, a random sample of articles would infringe on the publishers' IP rights rather than J-STOR's. The subtle point is that J-STOR is absolutely not interested in the original copyright owners having to hunt down abusers, because that would (in all likelihood) appear like an additional, avoidable hassle to the latter and would make them less likely to agree to have J-STOR distribute their content. [edit: apparently it's the US Attorney General more than J-STOR who is pushing this case forward] In comparison: if someone sneaks into a cinema to see a movie, you would accuse him of cheating them of the entrance fee, and not of "stealing the movie". If someone sneaks into a cinema and uses his camcorder to record the movie, he is cheating the movie theater of the entrance fee and misappropriating the production company's movie (with the suspicion that he might pirate it later), but he did not steal the movie from the theater. That would involve something like walking away with the movie theater's copy of the movie, which would fulfill the criterion that what's stolen is not there afterwards. Misappropriation of IP is not stealing. It's unauthorized copying - that certainly has the potential to harm the bottomline of the copyright owner, but with an impact that is much harder to quantify than the stealing of an actual physical thing. IP owners and friends of them who use the word 'stealing' want to frame the situation in such a way that appeal to the nonexistence of monetary loss is excluded - mostly because these same owners are investors in, and not creators of, the IP and do not have any other perspective than squeezing whatever value they can out of their investment. (The authors of the original articles probably couldn't care less about some punk illegally downloading their texts, because they don't see any money from it anyways).
- mbreese 15y ago> They do own the right to the composition of their collection This was the point I was trying to make. They own their database, even if they don't own the articles in it. The GP poster was trying to claim that they didn't "own their archive".
- dkarl 15y agoI hate to quibble over words, but a painting can be stolen "from the Louvre" even if it's there on loan from a private collection, just as you could say, "The necklace was stolen from my jewelry box," without implying that your jewelry box was the legal owner of the necklace.
- _delirium 15y agoThis is more like taking a photograph of a painting on loan to the Louvre, though--- they're alleging that a copy was made, in violation of their terms of service, of a document that they don't even own (but do host). In that case, I would think that you might be violating the Louvre's camera policy, and you might even be colloquially "stealing" something from the painting's author (e.g. if you go on to publish illicit copies from your photo), but you aren't plausibly stealing anything from the Louvre.
- dkarl 15y agoThe argument over whether something digital can be stolen at all is a different argument than the one you made in the comment I replied to. The question of taking photographs of artwork (which are not exact copies, but which have their own cultural, educational, and commercial value) is a third question which is interesting in its own right. At this pace, I'm having a hard time keeping track of what we're arguing about. In any case, my intention was not to signal my support for one of two predefined sides in a battle over the concept of intellectual property, it was just to point out stealing "from" doesn't have to have the meaning you read into it.
- anigbrowl 15y agoWell, if someone stole $100,000 of property from a storage facility, that wouldn't mean the storage facility claimed ownership of the property, just that it was the location of the theft. Maybe you're overthinking this a bit.
- dman 15y agoWell this is more akin to breaking into the storage facility and making a copy of all the Paintings stored there. The value of the goods being stored has not been reduced.
- anigbrowl 15y agoNot to torture this analogy any further, but would you feel safe storing your stuff at such a facility after something like that? No, you'd probably look elsewhere for your storage needs. Breaking in is still bad and would be the subject of criminal charges. If the US attorneys decide that use of the word 'stole' is somewhat over the top, then guess what? they can amend the indictment - just as the defense can amend their motions. My point is not that the government is correct or morally justified in bringing this indictment, but that getting hung up on terminology like this obscures the legally problematic issue of having (allegedly) bypassed the security systems to download material he was not supposed to have access to, regardless of who actually owns said material.
- Vivtek 15y agoBut: (1) JSTOR isn't a storage facility in that sense; the copyright holders do not pay JSTOR to store their items, so this is a bad analogy. (2) If the outrage is supposed to be about bypassing security systems, why is the government hung up on the "theft" terminology? Especially when JSTOR, the party arguably injured (in some way not specified), has asked the government not to prosecute? No, this is clearly a convenient way to get a politically inconvenient person labeled a felon.
- anigbrowl 15y ago
- gcb 15y ago> They are talking about theft of services if it's theft of service why measure it on number of works? it's like accusing you of using your neighbour wifi to steal over one thousand emails (which you read from your own email account)
- gcb 15y agoMy point being, i have no idea what service they provide, didn't read the fine article. But if they have an all-you-can-eat plan for like $300 a month per seat. Then the charges should have been "joe doe hacks MIT network and steals $300 worth of replaceable goods". In the same lines that if someone break into a car-wash and use 5min of their water, he will hardly be convicted of organized crime and causing damages over $300 (because that's what they charge for the premium wash)... why it's so messed up when you put a computer in the middle?