6 ms·
If you're using paternity leave because "you've earned it", why should you get special leave? Just use annual leave! You've earned that too, and it leaves you o
by roenxi 5y ago
If you're using paternity leave because "you've earned it", why should you get special leave? Just use annual leave! You've earned that too, and it leaves you on equal footing with everyone else without getting special brownie points for being a lucky husband.
At the end of the day, this is unfair. People who have - in this case up to 3 - kids get a structural advantage. We're in an era where not only do we expect a lot of people not to have kids, the ones who aren't having them are in some sense making a sacrifice of some very precious moments for the ones who are.
This is an expression of the same old arguments against maternity leave as well - at the end of the day, this is making private choices a problem for the company and (to some extent) the people working at the company. The effects of this sort of thing can already be seen in the differences between men and women's pay & career opportunities - it is a substantial handicap!
We should be winding back on this sort of thing, not encouraging it. People should earn their living and take time off at their own expense.
EDIT And, having thought about it a bit, it might favour wealthy workers. You end up with situations where effectively the janitor's wage has to go down to cover for the risk the software engineer has kids.
- vianneychevalie 5y agoI respect your opinion but on a nation-by-nation basis we benefit from having kids (although it could be discussed on a worldwide basis), and we benefit from having well-educated kids that are cared for by their parents. It is a cost for people who don’t have kids, but a net gain for everyone. A bit like healthcare. People who chose not to smoke benefit from paying taxes used to heal smokers, although a cigarette brings a lot less joy and benefit than kids. It is my opinion and I’m politically strongly against demographic shrinking.
- roenxi 5y agoGo with a cash handout provided by the government. It is better than paternity leave. If there was a choice between a cash handout + keep on working vs. paternity leave a significant number of meant would prefer the cash handout. The basic "this is the deal you get" for men is if they work hard for it & finance the operation then they get a happy & loving family. There are men who'd prefer the time & men who undervalue the time. But there are a lot of men who correctly identify that hard work, maximising their career outcomes and earning as much money as they can is the best way to help their family and this scheme disadvantages them. If people want unpaid time off I'm all for it. But paid vacation is not justified.
- tarsinge 5y agoHave you read TFA? This is the issue discussed, that currently men don't really have that fair choice due to different factors.
- lm28469 5y ago> maximising their career outcomes and earning as much money as they can is the best way to help their family Where do you live ? In country with free education and health care I'd say people definitely prefer maximising family quality time than working hard. When you don't have to worry about getting bankrupt at any point for any reason you start to see things differently. You're not going to be a dad/mom if you drop your kids to a caregiver at 6am and pick them up at 6pm What's the point of having kids if you don't even take part in their education and just slave away at the office, get a tamagotchi, much cheaper and lower maintenance. Every cent spent on kids education, well being and providing them healthy family environments is paid 1000 time back to society
- Swenrekcah 5y agoMoney isn’t worth anything if you don’t use it to buy someone else’s time. If money could solve all problems, why don’t companies just send all their employees home and let their money do the work? No they really need the employees to be there, giving their time and attention to the company mission. For that they are willing to spend a lot of money. Parental time, care and attention is the most valuable thing you could provide a child with in the first few years of their life. Unless the time machine is invented, all the money in the world is no substitute.
- machinehermiter 5y agoEven as someone who hates kids I can see birth rates as huge problem. No one is deciding though to have kids or not based on the father getting paid time off. I think it is an easier argument that a knowledge worker who has been up all night taking care of a screaming baby is not effective anyway. I think we should give fathers paid time off out of pity basically.
- andrey_utkin 5y agoUnfortunately it's not simple enough to agree "i choose to have kids, i pay the price, i reap the rewards of my parental investment, leave me alone". I am a father who was lucky to have a paid paternal leave. I am also a former freelancer who is happy to take care of himself in all situations. I agree that this sort of benefits which you reap by choice is controversial; i don't see what I'd possibly consider a "fair" amount of benefits here. But I can't agree that cancelling it would make it fair. All societies typically provide various parenting benefits, but then society also reaps the benefits of having the kids - up to drafting them into the armed forces and sending them to war. Now, some countries don't have mandatory conscription nowadays, but it is not unheard of for countries to introduce it at critical times.
- Siira 5y agoTo summarize, you think it’s okay for the gov to subsidize people’s children so that they have an unspecified claim on them up to sending them to a violent death. Very humane business, having a monopoly on violence.
- andrey_utkin 5y agoI don't like it but I have little hope that the humanity will abolish the "appoint others to die for the tribe" business anytime soon (within my lifetime, or in 1000 years, or at all). Coercion is still such a powerful tool in hands of so many, pervasive on all levels, no way we're going to abolish it. Not sure whether we've made any progress historically; maybe? I guess we'll see the abolition of animals farming globally around the same time. This would be the expression of humanity's "sentiment" against coercion towards the weaker in general. I believe this may happen but not very soon. (I am myself a meat eater.)
- Siira 5y agoThey could pay the market price for soldiers. It’s not dying for others that’s the problem, it’s the forceful dying for others.
- Bayart 5y ago>At the end of the day, this is unfair. People who have - in this case up to 3 - kids get a structural advantage. As they should, at least in most of the Western world. People who make kids in demographically challenged countries are contributing more to society than those who don't, and accordingly deserve more privileges.
- the_wolo 5y agoIt's not just about economics but about forming bonds with ones child. This is one of the most important things you can do if you're having a family. Regarding the economics: In the end someone is going to have to look after the kids. Looking at how much it costs to have kids, your argument makes no sense, too. If you just work and don't have children, you get paid the whole time and you also don't have to pay the enormous amount of money an extra human life costs. So actually in the society you're proposing, having children would be even more of an economic drain than it is now, while parents would also miss out on the opportunity to form bonds with their child, therefore significantly worsening the child's life and maybe also even damage its psyche permanently ("my parents where never there for me" etc). Because not even remotely everyone can afford unpaid leave. In the end, what you're arguing for is to worsen everyone's life just so you don't feel treated unfairly, even of you are not. For the argument that the company has a problem by so called private choices: this is life. People get children. Self reproduction is basically the purpose of humanity. If your company (or to an extent your society) does not have the productivity to pay for their workers temporarily leaving, maybe it's just a shitty company. If your workers don't care for each other well being, maybe the company is just not a place worth of existence. Humans gotta look out for each other. That's basic human social behavior. That's what we're here for. As an employer of 10 people, I'm always happy to allow my workers taking off time for their children. Happens about once a year since I'm in the organization. Also we don't pay the full amount of the costs because it's subsidized by the state. Children are awesome. Parents are awesome. And giving both the opportunity to form a bond, to not be stressed out and depressed, to make a basis for all the things they will become, all the things they will achieve in their later lifes, because they are healthy, loving, social humans – that's awesome.
- artpi 5y agoThank you. Your comment is a very well articulated response to a typical early-20s-single developer tantrum about how parents have it easy.
- lm28469 5y ago> this is making private choices a problem for the company It really depends on how you look at it. In my view companies are here to support our lifestyle and societies, we're some robots working for a corporate overlord for the kick of it, having a kid isn't (or doesn't have to be) a "sacrifice" you have to pay a price for. A company offering maternal/paternal leave is a company that supports its employees and society at large. We evolved in societies and its structures to support each-other, not to slave our life away for some faceless corporation. Don't forget to live your life, like, out of the office, real life, with people, kids being born, parents dying, taking time of to breath, taking a few steps back, realising work isn't the be-all and end-all of life. Taking time to educate and bond with your kids is so much more important than a few months of typing shitty code no one will ever read or use in 5 years tops
- z3t4 5y ago> effectively the janitor's wage has to go down to cover for the risk the software engineer has kids. Salaries are usually not a zero-sum game. Having kids is a full time job. When you get kids you can kiss all your free time goodbye, say goodnight to the side projects. Having kids is not good for your career, or other life goals. And if you are alone, eg. you have to pay for everything yourself, it also means a life in poverty.
- ixacto 5y agoHaha got a vasectomy 10 years ago and never looked back. Never had the urge or empathy to raise kids.
- belorn 5y agoThis could be combined with the concept of reducing the 5 days work week to 4. Those that need paternity leave continue with 5 days after the leave until they have worked it off. In the end both would get the same amount of work days, and compared to today it would be the same(or better) as when there are paid paternity leave.
- UncleMeat 5y agoI don't think it is unreasonable for society to decide that supporting new parents is important and for "unfair" things to benefit them. In the US, even extremely generous vacation policies only accumulate like five weeks annually. That's nowhere near enough time to be functional for acting as a new parent. This is the difference between equity and equality. A system where we all just get paid and there is zero support structure is one that leads to ruin for those at the fringes.