6 ms·
The repeated use of "stole" in the indictment is interesting, even beyond the usual metaphorical usage to discuss copyright infringement. In this case, the ind
by _delirium 15y ago
The repeated use of "stole" in the indictment is interesting, even beyond the usual metaphorical usage to discuss copyright infringement.
In this case, the indictment alleges that the documents were stolen from JSTOR, which does not even own them! In the vast majority of cases JSTOR scanned documents whose copyright is owned by someone else, and acquired or was donated a non-exclusive license to distribute copies via its service. In many cases the documents are even public domain. The indictment continues the theft metaphor by discussing the effort and expense JSTOR incurred in scanning the documents, and the alleged attempt to render this less valuable by redistributing "its" documents, analogizing this to the loss someone suffers in a theft.
But effort expended to build a private repository consisting of copies of things you don't own doesn't give you ownership of the result, any more than Google Books doing the same has given them ownership of the documents that they've scanned. If you scraped Google and "stole" their scans, you would be violating Google's Terms of Service, and Google might indeed feel subjectively like you've taken something of value (their exclusive access to this repository of scans), but I think it would be a stretch to say that you've "stolen" "their" documents.
- sp332 15y agoYeah, that bothered me too. Especially on page 14, where they demand that he give back the "proceeds obtained." How is that going to be determined in such an unrealistic sense?
- Alex3917 15y agoThey are talking about theft of services, not copyright infringement. In any event these charges are going to be very difficult to beat since they're federal, even though there are some obvious holes in the indictment. It will be almost impossible to get any of the evidence thrown out even if there was an illegal search and seizure. His best bet is probably to get the Harvard legal team to go to bat for him, although it's difficult to say how likely that is.
- _delirium 15y agoI wasn't really commenting on the legal sufficiency of the indictment, just the rhetorical dishonesty of accusing someone of "steal[ing] well over 4,000,000 articles from JSTOR" (quote from the indictment) when JSTOR didn't own those articles. They could've just alleged violation of JSTOR's TOS and thereby theft of network services. I suspect JSTOR or people sympathetic to them had a hand in writing the indictment, though; JSTOR has a long history of attempting to spread the misinformation that it somehow "owns" its archive.
- thisuser 15y agoHe is accused of stealing bandwidth from JSTOR, not the documents. "Theft of services" not theft of property. Theft of bandwidth is almost as absurd as theft via copying. JSTOR apparently isn't interested in free transmission of knowledge
- a3camero 15y agoIf you read the indictment you'll see that they very much are not interested in free transmission of knowledge. They charge >$50k/yr for access: " For a large research university, this annual subscription fee for JSTOR’s various collections of content can cost more than $50,000."
- jackpirate 15y agoThat price actually seems pretty reasonable for a large research university. The real question is how much they charge individuals who want to get an article. My first google search (http://www.jstor.org/pss/27757488 http://www.jstor.org/pss/27757488) results in $12/article. This is very steep when you're trying to do research and don't even know if the article is what you're looking for.
- Vivtek 15y agoWell, you wouldn't want any old rabble getting access to valuable knowledge. Far better for that access to be safely controlled by the major research institutions, who can clearly be trusted to pursue knowledge in a responsible manner.
- gcb 15y ago> They are talking about theft of services if it's theft of service why measure it on number of works? it's like accusing you of using your neighbour wifi to steal over one thousand emails (which you read from your own email account)
- gcb 15y agoMy point being, i have no idea what service they provide, didn't read the fine article. But if they have an all-you-can-eat plan for like $300 a month per seat. Then the charges should have been "joe doe hacks MIT network and steals $300 worth of replaceable goods". In the same lines that if someone break into a car-wash and use 5min of their water, he will hardly be convicted of organized crime and causing damages over $300 (because that's what they charge for the premium wash)... why it's so messed up when you put a computer in the middle?
- DenisM 15y agoYou're precisely incorrect as far as the law is concerned. If I make a painting, I own the copyright. If you take a picture of said painting, you own the copyright on the picture. If someone makes a collage of your picture they own the copyright on the collage. Both of you are liable for copyright infringement against my rights, but this is independent of your own rights as described above. This is not a legal advice, talk to a lawyer.
- Apocryphon 15y agoLet's try another analogy. What if someone hacked into Netflix and downloaded copies of all of the media that Netflix offered?
- a3_nm 15y ago> But effort expended to build a private repository consisting of copies of things you don't own doesn't give you ownership of the result Surprisingly, it sometimes does in the EU: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Database_right http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Database_right