8 ms·
When all of these (IMO, highly predictable) articles come out about paternity and maternity leave, I wish they would also highlight that these leave policies ju
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
When all of these (IMO, highly predictable) articles come out about paternity and maternity leave, I wish they would also highlight that these leave policies just show the gaping inequalities in the workforce, especially in the US where leave is not mandated.
I mean, the only reason the tech giants are able to offer such generous leave is because their businesses are almost unfathomably profitable, with limited competition, and because they are big enough that the work of any individual worker will not be missed that much. But why do virtually zero, say, small businesses like restaurants, cleaners, mechanics, etc. offer leave policies remotely like this? Because these businesses actually need all their workers to actually work, and when they don't, the business actually stops functioning.
If we really believe that parental leave and parental bonds are beneficial for society, then society should pay for it, instead of hoisting the cost onto companies, where only the richest companies are able to do so.
- metters 5y agoIn the USA, the cost of paternity leave have to be fully paid by the company? I thought it would be paid by both together (government and employer) at least. My paternity leave was fully paid by the government, but it was capped. Moreover the amount of paid months is limited and I had to share them with my wife.
- sofixa 5y agoAFAIK (not American) paid maternal or paternal leave isn't mandatory by labour laws/regulations, so yeah, it's up to the employer to offer it and pay for it. Logically, only the huge and very well off companies in competitive ( for employment) branches will do so because the others have little incentive to "waste" money on the matter.
- metters 5y agoThanks for the insight. It makes sense for small companies then to not offer paid parental leave, as they really cannot afford that most of the time (thinking of cafes, restaurants, small shops at the corner, etc.)
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe more progressive states do have government funded parental leave, but it is not much compared to other countries. The west coast states and the northeast states offer paid parental leave, and the amount you get partially depends on what you used to earn (and hence contributed to the parental leave taxes). You get 18 to 20 weeks off after the baby is born within the first year of life, generally.
- hnbad 5y agoIt's mandatory in Germany in the sense that employees are entitled to it, but they don't have to take it. The time off is paid by the state (in proportion to the previous year's salary and bonuses) not the employer. However because sexism is more complicated than just lack of equal access, parental leave is still mostly taken by women and women still find it harder to get back into regular employment after extended periods of maternity leave. I know several mothers who planned to have children and go on maternity leave and because of this accepted jobs that pay the bills but aren't places they enjoy working and now face the prospect of having to go back to a job they hate or have a second or third child (only to then have to either go back to a job they not only hate but also haven't done in years or find a new job with a multi-year gap in their resumé). For this to really change will likely take generations because the behavior and the social expectation of that behavior are mutually reinforcing.
- LatteLazy 5y agoI'd say the opposite is true in terms of work: it's much easier to replace a waitress for a week/month/year of leave than it is an engineer or a project manager. Google do it anyway because they and their employees like it and because they can afford to. The local restaurant could do it much MORE easily. But they have less profit margin (like you say). So we need a law to force them to do it, so everyone does it and puts their prices up to stay in business. That's exactly why countries mandate it: mandating it allows less profitable companies to do it because they know their competitors have to as well.
- DarkWiiPlayer 5y agoIn the USA, wouldn't missing out on the tipping be a huge problem when taking time off as a waiter?
- LatteLazy 5y agoYeah, the whole tipping thing seems pretty backwards to me. I'm not sure what to do for that...
- robin_reala 5y agoStop allowing companies to pay below minimum wage because it’ll be made up with tips? Seems fairly obvious.
- nosianu 5y ago> it's much easier to replace a waitress It's not about replacements, it's about still getting paid. Try your argument again with the premise that that small restaurant now has to pay two people for that one position. However, as someone who, for a short period of time, gave a small loan to an Italian friend (professional cook, very good too and able to produce in restaurant environment) so that he could (once again) open a restaurant, and also has another friend with a (better quality and very good environment) Mexican restaurant, and also other people managing hotels or restaurants and clubs/bars, in Germany, your argument about easy replacements does not hold water at least from what I witnessed. They struggled hard to keep people they knew, and any loss was not easy to replace at all. We also have seen headlines recently that those kinds of jobs are harder to fill now, after over a year of shutdown or very limited restaurant business, with many workers having found other jobs, for example "Covid and jobs: Why are hospitality workers leaving the industry?" -- https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-wales-57241370 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-wales-57241370
- egman_ekki 5y ago> If we really believe that parental leave and parental bonds are beneficial for society, then society should pay for it, instead of hoisting the cost onto companies, where only the richest companies are able to do so. Yup, that's what the article says at the end: > But ideally, says Banister, leave for fathers and financial support for that leave should be the state’s responsibility, because putting the onus on employers – as is the case in the US – can lead to a “two-tier system” where only certain sectors offer paternity leave. [...] “The government should offer an appropriate minimum package which encourages behaviours that support a more gender equal society,” says Banister.
- andyferris 5y ago> I mean, the only reason... Because these businesses actually need all their workers to actually work, and when they don't, the business actually stops functioning. Businesses do exist and function perfectly fine in countries where these policies are universal, so I don't buy the argument. I've only encountered this belief in North America. But yes, US tech giants pay voluntarily because they are quite profitable and hiring devs is (relatively) hard, and yes society should enforce it through government policy (I think whether it is taxpayer or company funded is a smaller detail IMO - e.g. annual leave and other entitlements are company funded - but yes 6 months paid leave for a very small business might be an expense it cannot pay, compared to predictable amounts of annual leave you can plan around, so it might make sense to "pool" the cost via taxation).
- lazide 5y agoThe parent posters point is actually agreeing with you I think? Other countries mandate these leaves and spread them out as social programs, and therefore the small companies in those countries ARE able to function - because the costs are spread out. In the US that is not the case, because the spreading of costs and mandating of leaves isn’t universal, and they can’t afford to take it on themselves.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoYes, thank you, this was exactly my point.
- est31 5y agoThe issue is market effects. If there is one company offering paternity leave, and one which doesn't, which one can offer cheaper prices? If both companies have to offer paternity leave, they are both in the same situation. Still however, one employee becoming pregnant is often a big problem for very small companies, because the effect is highly discretized. If you have 5 employees, then a pregnant employee means 20% of your company's workforce is gone. So you really need social programs that pay instead of the employer during the time of the absence.
- alkonaut 5y agoPaternity leave, to have any effect on societal norms, must of course be universally offered. To be universally offered it almost certainly needs to be mandated and/or subsidized (partially or fully). One can imagine different schemes where large employers are responsible for bearing more of the cost than small and so on, but in the end it almost has to be a national (at least partially) tax-funded scheme. To be accepted for fathers to use, a significant portion of it must be usable by each parent (non-transferable). > But why do virtually zero, say, small businesses like restaurants, cleaners, mechanics, etc. offer leave policies remotely like this? Because these businesses actually need all their workers to actually work, and when they don't, the business actually stops functioning. With a good parental leave system, any business no matter how small must be ready for any employee to disappear for 3-12 months. It’s just the reality of running a business. But again (and this is what’s important) if it’s universally used then the same applies to the restaurant across the street too! It’s not a competitive disadvantage. The same applies for employees: if your manager with 99% certainty took 6-12 months paternal leave with each child, just like every man in the company, then your taking 6-12 months will not be a disadvantage for your career as a man either. > If we really believe that parental leave and parental bonds are beneficial for society, then society should pay for it, instead of hoisting the cost onto companies, where only the richest companies are able to do so. Absolutely 100% agree. This isn’t a benefit for the parent it’s a benefit for the child. Non-transferable tax funded leave of at least 3 months per parent should be par for the course.
- pedrosorio 5y ago> With a good parental leave system, any business no matter how small must be ready for any employee to disappear for 3-12 months. It’s just the reality of running a business. But again (and this is what’s important) if it’s universally used then the same applies to the restaurant across the street too! It’s not a competitive disadvantage. Except it is because your business is the one that hired the young woman and the other business did not, so now you have 4 people working for a year and the other business has 5 at the same cost. For small businesses, if this is not tax funded, this is a huge liability and an incentive to discriminate when hiring.
- 5y ago
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoIIRC, Norway pays for most sick leave and maternity/paternity leave through taxes. For sick leave, I think the employer pays for a small amount (a week or two), then it shifts. (Am an immigrant, and could be misunderstanding). Vacations are kind of a tax too: They take a portion of your income, and give it to you in June of the next year. Not everything has to make things rough on the employer. Though, to be fair, if people and companies are taxed fairly, the richest people and companies would still be paying a larger share simply because they can afford to do so without slipping into despair.
- vmception 5y agoYeah even this article doesnt offer any framework, it just says “men in leadership roles take less paternity leave because they feel they must lead the team, hmmmmmmmmmmmmm so mysterious” and offers no solution to how such a team would have redundancy or operate
- throw0101a 5y ago> […] especially in the US where leave is not mandated. Slightly meta, but I wish people would stop saying "the US" as if it's a monolith. It's not. It's a federation of smaller entities. It's saying "the EU" parental leave policy as a monolith: it's non-sensical. The EU has a whole bunch of different countries which do their own thing, and the US has a whole bunch of states that do their own thing. Just like people might compare Denmark versus Spain on weeks given, you have to compare (e.g.) Illinois to Oregon. The EU as a whole has federalism, and so does the US.
- op00to 5y agoOr, maybe, force businesses to pay for this benefit themselves as a recognition that it’s workers are human, and having a family is an important piece of a stable life.
- mindslight 5y agoOr better yet, fix the economy so that the average worker gets paid enough that they can actually save wealth and exercise some economic power. Then people could take as much leave as they themselves would like, rather than needing to fit into the mold of what corporate policies allow.