3 ms·
A general observation that explains a lot about most martial arts is that over time they all become "watered down" to mere exercise or a strange stylised dancin
by jiggawatts 5y ago
A general observation that explains a lot about most martial arts is that over time they all become "watered down" to mere exercise or a strange stylised dancing.
That's because you can't have people permanently maiming each other during "friendly practice". If the village parents send their kids to the local monastery (or school, or wherever) for "training" and they come back with broken bones or just one of two eyes, they'll be rightfully very angry with the teachers of that martial art.
Hence, over time, every martial art accumulates restrictions, formalities, and the standard moves become just the safe ones. Grapples, deflections, etc...
A true "martial" art, the type optimised for maximising your chance at winning a fight to the death, cannot be taught safely in classes. Eventually people will get hurt. That's... the point!
People bringing up MMA are missing this: Even MMA has rules, and lots of them. If it was truly unlimited, very few people would escape without permanent, ruinous injuries.
What girls are told in self-defence classes is this: Go for the eyes, throat, and nose. Kick your opponent in the shins as hard as you possibly can. Knee men in the balls with full force.
If you did any of that even once in any formal training or competition, you'd likely be kicked out.
- markus_zhang 5y agoIndeed. One theory of Taichi is that Taichi was invented as a military martial arts back in the early Ming dynasty. Eventually it degenerated to a physical exercise.
- 99_00 5y agoIf girls can train in self defence without watering it down, then surely martial artists also can using the same system and equipment and maintain the deadly and brutal nature of the art. And in reality, many do.
- unishark 5y agoI think the biggest consideration for young (up to middle aged or so..) males is self-defense against bullies. Where there will be unwritten rules to a degree. Obviously it depends on the dojo, but the ones I've interacted with were genuinely concerned with real-world self-defense too, even if it wasn't their primary focus. So they included days and discussions that focused on it.