3 ms·
That conjecture is one of the two foundational principles of relativity - that the laws of physics are the same in all valid frames of reference. "Violating ca
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
That conjecture is one of the two foundational principles of relativity - that the laws of physics are the same in all valid frames of reference. "Violating causality" means that in some valid frame of reference A, event X caused event Y, and in some other valid frame of reference B, event Y caused event X. The laws of physics cannot be the same in A and B for both of those to be true.
- gopher_space 5y agoI'm watching two friends go through a nasty breakup that "violates causality" if you take both points of view into account, and am realizing that it's impossible to do any work with pop-sci physics because I'm relying on an extended metaphor to grasp the topic. It's clear that your point of view matters in physics, but it's also clear that I have no idea what a "point of view" means in this context.
- salawat 5y agoPoint of view means coordinate system, or reference frame. If I am stationary and measuring you flying past me in a relativistic train, I would measure you in a coordinate grid say, centered on myself. You may be watching me from your train and doing the same, but from a reference grid stationary with respect to you but moving with respect to me. Even if we both agreed on identical measures ahead of time, your measurement of me from your reference frame and mine of you from my reference will be off from a measurement we do ahead of time in the same reference frame as a calibration. However, that difference comes out in the wash through the magic of the Lorentz Transformation. Using the Lorentz Transformation, I should be able to negotiate transforming a measurement I do of you in my own reference frame to what it would look like from yours and you should be able to transform yours to mine, through which we'd both come to the same numbersassuming we're in spacetime that shares the same general degree of curvature (same gravity). This can even be generalized to arbitrary degrees of spacetime curvature. I.e. if your relativistic train is racing past a black hole with a near tangent intersect, and I'm stationary with reference to the black hole centric reference frame but further out in the system, as you blast through the high curvature part of your trip your clock may seem to de-sync from mine. This too, however, can be mitigated through copious amounts of math I don't get for more than half an hour after looking away from a text book. I just know if I ever have a problem to solve that involves hitting that book again, I have either made some terrible or awesome decisions in my life.
- pa7x1 5y agoThis is not true. Relativity doesn't forbid and is not in contradiction with supraluminal phenomenona. You need to impose additional constraints on the theory (e.g., real mass conditions) to get rid of them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]