4 ms·
"...should be able to set price caps on artwork owned by corporations" Because copyright protection is not a right, but a limited privilege granted by the Unit
by jamesbritt 18y ago
"...should be able to set price caps on artwork owned by corporations"
Because copyright protection is not a right, but a limited privilege granted by the United States Constitution and intended to "promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts", not to make a sure $ for some corporation.
Hence the idea of compulsory licensing, for example. If the cost of the license, though, is prohibitive, it has the same effect of refusing a license, which (one could argue) would interfere with the progress of science and useful arts.
- tptacek 18y agoThe "limit" on copyright is duration. The market owns price. You haven't answered my question.
- mrkurt 18y agoThat's one of the limits, yeah. You also get things like "fair use". You're correct that price is not currently a restriction in every case, but there's a good case to be made for compulsory licensing (which is partially a price limit). Copyright law creates artificial monopolies. Market based pricing breaks down in the face of a monopoly. Given that we're dealing with state enabled monopolies, it seems reasonable that we should clamor for changes to the framework they operate under.
- jamesbritt 18y ago"The "limit" on copyright is duration. The market owns price. You haven't answered my question." Yes, I did. See the other comments on compulsory licensing as being state-sanctioned price limit, if my own answer was not clear enough. Also, a reasonable counter-question is, what gives someone the right to prevent me from making a copy of a digital entity? Intellectual "property" is quite different from physical goods, and the fact that the Constitution has a special clause for copyright suggests that IP was not meant to be equated with, say, land or other material things. Perhaps copying is the real right, with government offering to restrict that right for a period of time so as to offer incentives to people to make their creations public.
- mtw 18y agoPlaying devil's advocate: "... the same effect of refusing a license, which (one could argue) would interfere with the progress of science and useful arts." So does that mean that Google or Coca-Cola should (must?) license their algorithm/recipe for the progress of science and useful arts?
- rglovejoy 18y agoNo, because those are not copyrights. They are trade secrets/patents, which are protected by a different set of laws.