5 ms·
Oof, that's not even a $700 repair. What's pictured looks more like a $200 repair. The rest is straight profit for Electrified Garage, for having Tesla knowledg
by mindslight 5y ago
Oof, that's not even a $700 repair. What's pictured looks more like a $200 repair. The rest is straight profit for Electrified Garage, for having Tesla knowledge at this point in time.
Personally, I would have used a plastic fitting so that if it were to get hit again, the fitting would take the damage instead of the part that has been threaded into.
The driving force being this story seems to be that the owner didn't have road hazard coverage. You've got to wonder how much Tesla is just raking in by defrauding insurance companies who don't yet know any better than to sign off on replacing the whole pack for a simple repair.
- samfisher83 5y agoUltimately consumers will need to decide whether they want to put with this or go with a easier car to repair like a Toyota.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- roflchoppa 5y agoHonestly I’m surprised that it would be exposed like that, rather than tucked behind a panel. The rubber fuel lines on my 1973 240z are behind a removable panel at the rear wheel. 3 screws and it’s off for access.
- turtlebits 5y agoIf you watch the video, the connector is behind a plastic panel (albeit not very rigid).
- gamache 5y agoElectrified Garage were the ones who knew where to hit it with a hammer -- seems like a fair deal to me! https://www.buzzmaven.com/old-engineer-hammer-2/ https://www.buzzmaven.com/old-engineer-hammer-2/
- mindslight 5y agoI'm not condemning it, just pointing out the current market value of Tesla repair knowledge!
- cartoonworld 5y agoThis repair is R&D that is definitely worth the price. There's no way this is a $200 repair, that Tesla took up a bunch of shop time and their specialized technician for the better part of a day, carefully researching and installing this repair fitting. If you are charging $25/hr labor you are out of business. If the repair fails, they will likely take it back and improve the fix. Your plastic mystery fitting would likely not be compatible and cause a leak of whatever coolant is running around in there. Lastly, road hazard insurance didn't cover any repair. Tesla doesn't do this kind of repair as well, leaving the only recourse replacing the entire part.
- mindslight 5y ago"R&D" ?? It's replacing a molded hose barb with a threaded fitting. Also FTA: "the shop had another significantly cheaper solution it had used once before". What's pictured in the article looks like 2 hours of labor, which would be a few hundred dollars at the rate for generic labor. I'm specifically highlighting the additional premium that Tesla expertise is commanding right now. > mystery fitting You do realize that all the usual pipe fitting shapes come in materials besides brass, right? > Lastly, road hazard insurance didn't cover any repair. Yes, this is reflected in my comment. > Tesla doesn't do this kind of repair as well, leaving the only recourse replacing the entire part. I'm sure Tesla takes the "broken" core pack, disassembles it, replaces that one plastic molding, and ships it off to the next repair for another $16k. For Tesla to charge an insurance company $16k with the justification of replacing the whole pack (while not even mentioning core charges!) is essentially insurance fraud. They're skating by because they're new, but I can imagine in a few years either insurance companies will only pay for repairs from third parties who charge reasonable prices, or they will raise premiums significantly if you want to be entitled to OEM service/parts. I'd bet this dynamic is one of the main reasons Tesla is fighting Right to Repair.
- bitexploder 5y agoYou have to know that repair is safe and meets all the coolant system design constraints. It certainly isn’t something most shops are going to just have a standard procedure for. That was what caused the problem in the first place.
- elsonrodriguez 5y agoGoogle says a Model 3 takes about 5 gallons of G48 anti freeze. That's $100 in just fluids. High end mechanics can charge about $150/hr. Let's say: 1 hour to dismantle and diagnose 1 hour to cut/drill/tap 1 hour to fill and bleed the system 1 hour for whatever diagnostics are needed to verify that the ECU is happy and the car drives well. Sounds like $700 to me.
- mindslight 5y agoGood point on the antifreeze. I think you're overestimating the time though. And the premium between $80/hr generic shop rate and $150/hr "high end mechanic" is exactly what I was trying to highlight.