3 ms·
I'll explain. Some scams are actually more effective when they appear like scams, see [1] for the classic example of why Nigerian Prince e-mail scams have inten
by crazygringo 5y ago
I'll explain. Some scams are actually more effective when they appear like scams, see [1] for the classic example of why Nigerian Prince e-mail scams have intentional bad grammar etc.
Any business that is sophisticated enough to build a genuine product is also usually sophisticated enough to realize that "the message is the medium", that a professional non-scammy appearance is required for most customers to even consider trusting it, and so invest in professional graphic design. This goes doubly or triply so for anything finance-related or that takes your finance credentials -- that requires huge trust.
So on those two principles, when something looks like a scam, it much more likely is -- because for certain categories of scams, scammers want it to look that way, and non-scammers don't. "Scammy apperance" is a genuinely meaningful signal in practice.
But if you don't believe that, then there's this bridge I'm selling... ;)
[1] https://www.businessinsider.com/why-nigerian-scam-emails-are-obvious-2014-5 https://www.businessinsider.com/why-nigerian-scam-emails-are...
- wruza 5y agoAny business that is sophisticated enough to build a genuine product is also usually sophisticated enough to realize that "the message is the medium", that a professional non-scammy appearance is required for most customers to even consider trusting it, and so invest in professional graphic design This is so middle-age stereotypical that I’m not even sure if it’s worth opposing. The first thing you see in every financial app is how much unprofessional it really is with regards to UI, and it only gets worse with time. It doesn’t take a ph.d. to understand that this “trust theater” is just that, and it’s beyond me how people trust someone with their money based on some CSS (which is presumably fubar in the source view).
- CogitoCogito 5y agoSo then why doesn't Google just say look less like a scam? Why don't they give their reasoning? Why don't they just provide that reasoning? Regardless, I still find your position kind of crazy. Basically you're saying (honestly totally subjectively without any real rational basis) that this _looks_ like a scam (opinion), therefore it's more likely to be a scam and therefore it should be banned. So if the user responds and demonstrates that it _isn't_ a scam, then you why the hell not allow it to work again? Personally I think Google should be legally required to provide this reasoning and to reinstate it if they are initially incorrect in their conclusion that it's a scam. I'm kind of amazed that that would even be required since it's basic human decency that if Google is incorrect, they fix their mistake. But well money is more attractive than morals and decency.