2 ms·
Right, this sort of thing drives me a bit nuts as well. Yearly global CO2 emissions are at 31Gt. This article is complaining because the Olympics adds 0.0004G
by cogman10 5y ago
Right, this sort of thing drives me a bit nuts as well.
Yearly global CO2 emissions are at 31Gt. This article is complaining because the Olympics adds 0.0004Gt -> 0.003Gt?
I dislike this part of the green movement. Absolutely it's important to cut down CO2 emissions. However, worrying about the emissions of a sporting event, even a really big one, is really just asinine.
- breuleux 5y agoAn event only accounting for 1/10,000th of global emissions doesn't mean it is asinine to worry or complain about it. That very much depends on how easy it is to cut it relative to other sources. If it's easy, it's absolutely worth complaining about: if you can find a thousand such events to eliminate, that's 10% of global emissions (I know, there aren't a thousand olympics :P) I'm not saying this particular argument has any merit, mind you. Just that it's legitimate to care about smaller sources of pollution if the effort required to eliminate them is proportionately smaller.
- voldacar 5y agoBasically any complex thing humans do consumes energy and therefore emits carbon dioxide. So you can selectively criticize anything you want by invoking carbon emissions. It's pretty funny actually, especially considering how much sway it seems to have over peoples' minds these days.
- cogman10 5y agoThe conspiracy side of my mind says it's likely by design. The fossil fuel industry used solar to attack nuclear back in the day. I'm pretty suspicious that a lot of that is happening today. Distract with minor issues while the big ones go unaddressed.
- neither_color 5y agoA funny slippery slope Ive read is "you are the carbon they want to remove" as some CO2 debates are rooted in misanthropy and the premise that earth is overpopulated and headed for an inevitable malthusian crisis.
- yosamino 5y agoIt makes sense for the same reason that advertizing at the olympics makes sense: It's a global event that a lot of people pay attention to. You can use it to make the topic that everything has to reduce CO2 emissions stay at the front of people's minds. Depending on which bubble one is in, that's not always a given. I do agree though, it does seem to have significant overlap with the idea that replacing plastic straws will save the ... something (?) ...
- SllX 5y agoMovements that depend on being at the forefront of peoples’ minds are precisely what people don’t want. Human activity of every kind is going to have environmental impacts of some variety, and part of that impact will increase atmospheric carbon dioxide. Given that there are now more people alive today than at any other point in history, seriously, every single day we’re breaking that record, human activity will remain high, and so will our environmental impact projected out into the future. When there are more deaths than births on a consistent basis, environmental measurements will be lagging indicators of a decrease in human activity. That does not mean we have to depend on combustible hydrocarbons in order to continue or advance our industry, if the concern is actually carbon dioxide, but we are almost entirely unwilling to build the one kind of power plant that would short circuit our carbon dioxide output in the shortest amount of time: nuclear plants. Instead we spend our time and waste our energy arguing about consumer uses of energy rather than how we can produce more or the same amount of energy with less carbon dioxide output because at the end of the day it always comes down to: how can we control our neighbors and make them live down to or below our standards?
- thecrash 5y agoCO2 emissions are a chemical problem. We know the answer to the chemical/physical problem: stop doing the reactions which produce CO2 gas as an output. But what makes it so confounding is it's also a political problem: people get to decide for themselves whether to do those reactions, and they overwhelmingly choose to do them. Their choices are informed by all kinds of social, emotional and symbolic influences - one of which is the Olympics. While the Olympics may not be a huge event relative to the entire global economy, it is pretty big relative to the entire global mindshare.
- cogman10 5y agoThis makes the assumption that the CO2 chemical experiment is done in a shared manner. That's not the case. In fact, very few organizations run the experiment to an extent that impacts the global climate. Businesses are certainly aware of climate change, who isn't at this point? The issue is that those businesses care FAR more about profit than they do about the future. You could say "Ok, it's the consumers responsibility to vote with their wallet!" But that doesn't mean anything. How can I impact agricultural CO2 emissions at the grocery store? There's not label on the food goods which says "This is a high CO2 emission product". And even if I did that, how can you expect the general population to do the same? We can't even convince the general population that wearing a mask to slow the spread of a respiratory illness is a good idea. We can't even convince everyone that a vaccine doesn't "magnetize" you. What's worse, this sort of thing would very likely backfire. Sure, everyone that thinks climate change is an issue will say it's a good to ok move. However, those in deep denial about climate change, the 40% of the population we need to convince it is a problem, will see a move like this as being "liberal cancel culture gone mad!" If I'm going to poke the outrage machine, I'd rather poke it with measures that are effective at addressing climate change. Carbon taxes and subsidies for green tech and farming.