3 ms·
In any of the British jurisdictions, neither parliament nor the government can dismiss judges. Nor can anyone else. If they displease the government, then they
by denton-scratch 5y ago
In any of the British jurisdictions, neither parliament nor the government can dismiss judges. Nor can anyone else.
If they displease the government, then they might not be chosen to head lucrative judicial inquiries - I think that's the only sanction that government can inflict on them.
Neither government nor parliament can "reverse" a patent decision.
Government and parliament have been known to "censure" (criticise) judicial decisions; usually that behaviour provokes a negative reaction among educated people and thoughtful newspapers. It doesn't happen often.
The government can also appeal against sentence in crimnal cases, if they think the sentence was unduly lenient. This is fairly recent statute legislation, and controversial.
- mjburgess 5y ago> neither parliament nor the government can dismiss judges This is wholly untrue. Parliament can do what it pleases, including disestablish the judiciary and the executive.
- denton-scratch 5y agoYou're right, it can do what it pleases; it has been known to behead a monarch. But it still can't dismiss a judge, because Parliament doesn't employ the judges.
- pjc50 5y agoThis is technically true but kind of irrelevant? If it comes down to that level of radical transformation, of abolishing the judiciary, the state is on its way to disintegrating. Rather like the Royal power that exists only as long as it's not used.