3 ms·
I think people have to recognize that both digital technology and the process of "modernity" and state-formation of the 20th century make it a lot harder for un
by pjc50 5y ago
I think people have to recognize that both digital technology and the process of "modernity" and state-formation of the 20th century make it a lot harder for unsurveiled spaces to exist because suddenly everyone is operating in the same "space", a single market.
There used to be a rough equilibrium that it was difficult to move large amounts of money around, especially internationally, but small amounts of cash were totally invisible to the state. This ensured a certain amount of stability; the state control could be exercised at the border, where anything of significant value had to be declared to customs, but inside the state you could go about your business. It was pretty difficult for a state to spin up a subversive organisation or competing industry inside another state's borders. Conversely, to commit a large crime required serious planning to move the money, and it was infeasible to move it overseas.
Technology is forcing the dichotomy towards either ubiquitous surveillance of absolutely every transaction, versus increasingly large "perfect" crimes carried out by people who are untouchably overseas.
- walterbell 5y ago> There used to be a rough equilibrium that it was difficult to move large amounts of money around, especially internationally Apparently not that difficult with the active support of banks (the B in CBDC), https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/jasonleopold/fincen-files-financial-scandal-criminal-networks https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/jasonleopold/fincen-fil... > A huge trove of secret government documents reveals for the first time how the giants of Western banking move trillions of dollars in suspicious transactions, enriching themselves and their shareholders while facilitating the work of terrorists, kleptocrats, and drug kingpins. And the US government, despite its vast powers, fails to stop it. Even criminal convictions have little effect beyond fines, https://wallstreetonparade.com/2020/09/3-count-felon-jpmorgan-chase-caught-laundering-more-dirty-money/ https://wallstreetonparade.com/2020/09/3-count-felon-jpmorga... > Every American should be horrified by this latest report from the ICIJ; every American should be outraged that the U.S. is now second only to the Cayman Islands for hiding dirty money for criminals. It's unclear how surveillance of mom & pop CBDC payments could help when trillions of dollars of suspicious Bank activity can continue unabated.
- pjc50 5y agoThat article is dated 2020, while I'm referring more to changes throughout the 20th century, the Bretton Woods era etc. The UK had formal capital controls until 1979, for example. > the US government, despite its vast powers, fails to stop it. Yes, and so long as it fails to stop it there will be pressure to "do something". And establishing a threshold below which there is no surveillance is unstable, because immediately you have to face "structuring", and the digital space makes this worse. If there were to be truly free no-surveillance payments of $1, say, people would move a stolen billion as one billion payments of $1. This is already happening with gift cards: https://www.napier.ai/post/prepaid-cards https://www.napier.ai/post/prepaid-cards The truly big money laundering is incredibly difficult to stop, because it can fund its own bribery zone that can extend to entire countries.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- new_stranger 5y agoThe question then becomes, do states with absolute economic control or criminal groups pose the greater risk to society? I think history builds a case for the answer pretty well. Even criminal groups can't touch the level of mayhem and death caused by the string of overly powerful human rulers of entire countries. Maybe criminal groups just need to grow to compete. Perhaps they are the same in some cases.