3 ms·
> I HAVE to believe that the number of folks that can both afford to buy the game and would buy the game, but would try to pirate first, is a fraction of a perc
by dijit 5y ago
> I HAVE to believe that the number of folks that can both afford to buy the game and would buy the game, but would try to pirate first, is a fraction of a percent of the market.
I have actual concrete data about this¹ and unfortunately the percentage is much larger than you realise.
I'm still under NDA until 2024 but it's in the region of 60-80% of sales for certain games, especially RPGs which seem to get pirated the most.
People like to cite hugely successful products being DRM-Free or something as proof that it works, but for every project that works well there's hundreds that die in obscurity.
Also, people like to back a champion to "prove that it works" which inflates the margins of the champion product.
¹ - based on my time at Ubisoft, and based on Ubisoft titles only and when accounting for other differences between franchised games.
- jobigoud 5y agoNote that the GP wrote "that would buy the game" which I think makes this unknowable / unmeasurable. You can measure how many players have pirated the game but not how many of them wouln't have bothered at all if they had had to pay for it. Take a person that has pirated many games, how do you know which ones they would have actually paid for? Even if you knew the ones they play the most, it woulnd't necessarily translate to a buy in the same order.
- dijit 5y agoYou can see the deficit of the pirated copies sales vs the non-pirated copies sales. You can also estimate sales within a 5% margin of error. Other factors such as play time and ratings also allow you to understand what sales would have been. There’s lots of data to draw from.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- DocTomoe 5y agoOn the other hand, many people refuse to buy anything with DRM on it, or wait for the massively-reduced "game of the year" edition that comes out a few years down the line, when a crack to remove DRM is available.
- 0-_-0 5y agoUbisoft games require installing a 3rd party gamestore (Ubisoft Connect) which people might be reluctant to install. I know I am, Steam is the only DRMed store I use because it always works. On others I've come close to losing access to the account or just failing authentication where I have to crack a game I paid for to finish playing it.
- RoyalBingBong 5y ago> 60-80% of sales Is what? Pirated? How can you have concrete data of something that didn't happen? A copy that didn't sell can not count towards sales. If it is based on sales estimation, then it could simply mean that the game didn't sell well because it was bad. Not every unsold copy of an estimation is automatically a pirated copy.
- mattowen_uk 5y agoIt's totally possible for a game to be cracked to accept a fake licence key, yet still have connect to an update server or what have you. That way the publishers end up easily seeing the amount of copies in the wild vs actual sales. Keygens tend to be based on the cracker reverse engineering the licence key check algorithm, and then just spitting out a bunch of keys that fit it. Most people will pick the first key the keygen creates, which makes it easy to track the pirated copies. The only way around the wholesale pirating of games is to make the game totally nerfed unless it can connect to a 'server'. This is why most AAA games all have at least some level of online features.
- roblabla 5y agoThat still doesn't tell you if whoever pirated the game would have bought the game, which is the point OP was making. Sure, you can know if 60% of the players are using a pirated copy, but if that pirate copy didn't exist, what percentage of the pirates would have bought the game? That's the interesting question that's hard to get an answer for.
- dijit 5y agoYou can track diffs between releases of a franchise, if you have enough releases. A release which gained 10M in sales which could not be pirated and scored 80/8 on metacritic can be compared to a release which sold 4 million but scored the same and has the same play time curves. Obviously this is contrived, there are way more inputs, but you can see where I’m going.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]