12 ms·
I love the historiography alluded to in the paper (and the meta-historiographic discussion of the arguments and counter arguments). The argument always seemed
by gumby 5y ago
I love the historiography alluded to in the paper (and the meta-historiographic discussion of the arguments and counter arguments).
The argument always seemed political to me: just look at Orwell’s Wigan Pier (~1920s) or Wylie’s Village in the Vaucluse, or hell, the 1939 German invasion of Poland with horse drawn cannon to see the flatness of the curve.
Zhou Enlai’s quip about the significance of the French Revolution is instructive here: “Too soon to tell”. For a “revolution” — a true turn of the wheel — is usually a slow motion and almost invisible affair, like swimming through a huge wave. Unless you’re close to the shore where it breaks, it’s hard to see and its implication unclear.
You don’t need a huge first derivative when you are collecting the AUC and that’s why you often don’t see it. Remember the computer “revolution” that was “visible everywhere but in the productivity statistics” (that was Solow in 87). The ARPANET had already transitioned to TCP by then but the consequences were still decades away.
So there was an industrial revolution, but trying to describe it as a kind of Big Bang is a parallel relic of the “great man” school of history.
- detritus 5y agoSadly, it appears that quip was a 'too delicious' a misinterpretation to correct. https://www.scmp.com/article/970657/not-letting-facts-ruin-good-story https://www.scmp.com/article/970657/not-letting-facts-ruin-g... But sssh! Don't tell anyone else.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Wildgoose 5y agoThe Zhou Enlai quip was actually the result of a mistranslation - he thought he was being asked about the 1968 student demonstrations.