5 ms·
Google is literally the only tech giant with an interest in the open internet. Facebook scored the mortal wound on the web — they reinvented a bigger, badder A
by Spooky23 5y ago
Google is literally the only tech giant with an interest in the open internet.
Facebook scored the mortal wound on the web — they reinvented a bigger, badder AOL closed garden.
- iratewizard 5y agoJust like how YouTube has become a more open and free platform in their care. Or how search results have become more open and free since they dominated market share.
- bluthund 5y agoDo you guys factor the deplatforming they do into this or are you not aware that they are heavily involved in censorship on their platforms
- logicchains 5y agoThe person you're replying to was likely being sarcastic.
- encryptluks2 5y agoLet me guess.. you're a huge fan of Tim Pool and the likes who constantly talked about how they are oppressed WHILE still on YouTube.
- iratewizard 5y agoLet me guess... You're not a huge fan of free speech because your college professor told you it was an outdated concept WHILE still using it as a shield to spew his moronic views.
- ryder9 5y agoprivate platforms dont have 'free speech' you moron
- throwaways885 5y agoTim Pool literally has to self-censor in real-time to avoid the robot bans. It's creepy as hell and has no place in a free society (regardless if you agree with him or not).
- ryder9 5y agoit's a private platform, he's free to go to any other platform, are you dense?
- tomc1985 5y agoYour definition of 'open and free' smells a lot like 'built to favor commercial entities over information pages' Most of my searches result in a wall of sales or product pages. Hardly 'open' when they turned it into glorified yellow pages
- pydry 5y agoI think it was sarcasm.
- encryptluks2 5y agoMuch like every other company, but at least I've see Google be mostly reasonable about it with a few exceptions. Much of the "deplatforming" isn't even do to Google per say but people abusing the copyright system on YouTube and many people not having adequate legal knowledge to defend themselves, or honestly just a lot of attention-seeking alt-right personality types constantly saying they are being deplatformed while they continue to use YouTube freely... Likely all one big part of a MCN pushing the same agenda.
- echelon 5y agoAnd Apple crippled the web on its locked-down as chastity iOS devices. These companies -- all of them -- are fucking with each other. None of us matter in the end. It's all about which company can screw the other out of engagement and eyeballs. Meanwhile Firefox, the open web, open source, right to repair, and digital ownership all wither away.
- musicale 5y ago> It's all about which company can screw the other out of engagement and eyeballs. Well that is kind of how media companies compete against each other, but the key question is: is it beneficial or harmful to the public? You could argue that Apple is acquiring users who they then lock in, sell to advertisers and developers (for a 30% cut on the App store) and monetize with service subscriptions, but you can also argue that half of Apple's profit is still from hardware sales, that apps and services are a big reason for buying that hardware, so Apple is still beholden to its hardware customers to some extent. And Google has https://wellbeing.google https://wellbeing.google as well as associated features in Android, and Apple has also implemented "screen time" tracking and limits.
- threatofrain 5y agoGoogle also seems to be one of the few entities in the world capable of building kick-ass web apps.
- _huayra_ 5y agoThe one exception being any sort of chat app. Now they're going from crusty old Hangouts to Chat while plenty of other chat apps have been far more polished for a long time
- jaimex2 5y agoGoogle also seems to be one of the few entities in the world capable of buying kick-ass startups. Fixed it for you.
- dmitriid 5y agoI've yet to see a single kick ass web app from Google. All of them are barely functioning slow-as-molasses slugs (or I'm jaded by the entire GCP experience).
- benjaminjosephw 5y agoRelying on giants to defend the interests of the rest of us mere humans sounds dangerous.
- nirui 5y agoBut if you look around across all the industries, it is not very hard to realize that most big names that you can easily recognize were created by few giants. Giants is the norm. A real hero knows when to resist the fear and borrow the power from the giants.
- quaintdev 5y agoTrue. Google at least does not create walled gardens like FB. You are not even allowed to post link in comment section. That's a tactic to keep users on its own platform. Recently they have stopped allowing people to browse even browse public profiles.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- benjaminjosephw 5y agoGiants are more visible, I won't dispute that but I'm not sure I agree with a strategy of surrendering to them because of that fact. I don't think we need a real hero here, we need end-user solidarity perhaps in the form of public policy and market regulation. Humans would have more freedom on the internet if corporate giants didn't.
- argvargc 5y agoThe "norm" is also... shit. Just because it's what's "always" happened before, doesn't mean we can't do better. This being the case is the very driving force of any innovation. Your statement seems like defeatism wrapped in a pretty bow of faux-insight. A tendency toward giants is also not necessarily a sustainable state of affairs. Once technology becomes sufficiently advanced and pervasive, the window of time available for a giant to gestate, before the next giant-level disruption, inevitably shrinks to the point the system reaches an equilibrium of innovational equanimity and balance. This is ordinary and expected, and parallels can be seen anywhere in nature. The - relatively-brief - "time of giants" of human progress may soon be coming to a close.
- argvargc 5y ago> Google is literally the only tech giant with an interest in the open internet. This statement is an oxymoron. "Tech giants" hobble the open principles of the internet by their own existence, persistence and, by-definition, over-bearing influence. Any entity genuinely concerned with preserving open principles would seek to limit its growth far-prior to where Google is now, and eliminate the pervasiveness of its influence, favouring and encouraging the results of diverse decentralisation over narrow centralisation. Google and Facebook are the antithesis of everything the concept of an open internet stands for.
- cromwellian 5y agoIf there is no open internet, there is nothing to index or organize. If anything Apple has does more harm than anyone to the Web by pushing the idea of native apps for everything served from a closed proprietary App Store that you can’t even side load around.
- WA 5y agoYou can index and organize billions of AMP pages. You can index and organize the content of an intranet of every large organization.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sjg007 5y agoI've worked at several large companies and all are very bad at documenting anything.
- Spooky23 5y ago> You can index and organize the content of an intranet of every large organization. Good luck. The magic of the internet is that everything is public and interlinked. Usually within a company the incentives are such that information is more tightly controlled. A software engineer doesn't see purchase orders and an HR specialist doesn't see software assignments. Usually a directory is more useful than a search within a company. Obviously there are exceptions.