3 ms·
First off, I totally agree that the manufacture and approval drugs and devices can be regulated differently with respect to different intended uses. Also, there
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
First off, I totally agree that the manufacture and approval drugs and devices can be regulated differently with respect to different intended uses. Also, there are specifics that I think both the majority and dissenting opinions got wrong. However, the key is that the FDA has jurisdiction over the manufacture and sale of devices, and no jurisdiction whatsoever over practice of doctors.
>While this clearly leaves open the option for general off-label use, I don't read this as barring the FDA from limiting a specific form of off-label use
There is no back door for intervening in the practice of medicine for specific forms of off-label use. They can go after manufacturers of products frequently used off label; they can make them add warnings, and perhaps even pull the product from the market, but they can't tell doctors what to do with a product that legally on market. For example, the FDA can't stop doctors from prescribing Viagra off-label as a cure for cancer, even if it is both dangerous and ineffective. The FDA can arrest doctors for prescribing Viagra for erectile disfunction if the pills are illegally imported from Canada because those pills are not legally on the market. Regulation and enforcement against using Viagra as a cancer cure is the jurisdiction of state legislature.
>The FDA should most certainly have the power to ban devices with clearly unsafe or ineffective control schemes.
They absolutely do have the power to recall these devices from the market. However, they can't tell doctors what to do with the devices or tell them not to substitute other legally marketed devices off-label.
This specific case is complex because this naturally creates a conflict when a device has multiple potential uses, and doctors refuse to head FDA warnings about off label use. The FDA naturally wants to keep the devices on the market for the effective use and discourage the ineffective use, but their hands are tied. It must be like a sheriff staring at a fugitive across the boarder.
The problem here is that the FDA is trying to cross the boarder between the manufacture devices and the practice of medicine instead of working within their jurisdiction.
They could recall all devices approved with indications for treating Self-Injurious or Aggressive Behavior. They can probably go after the Judge Rotenberg Educational Center in their capacity as manufacturer for knowingly manufacturing a device for off-label use.
- jjk166 5y ago> For example, the FDA can't stop doctors from prescribing Viagra off-label as a cure for cancer, even if it is both dangerous and ineffective. The entire point of the FDA is to make sure the drugs and medical devices being given are safe and effective. Why bother evaluating safety and effectiveness at all if that's supposed to be purely a case by case judgement call by a physician? The statements by congress clearly indicate that the intent of the law is for different use cases to be treated as separate devices, legal precedent clearly indicates that so long as the FDA's interpretation of the statute is reasonable that it should be deferred to by the courts, and their interpretation is reasonable. There is circular reasoning in the belief that the FDA can not impose a partial ban, and thus the device is legally on the market, and thus the FDA does not have the authority to impose a partial ban. You can not separate a device from its usage. The moment you start using an object to beat a nail into a piece of wood, it becomes a hammer, but if you use it to turn a screw, it's not a hammer, it's a screwdriver. If an agency has been invested with the power to ban screwdrivers, the fact that your screwdriver could theoretically be used as a hammer is irrelevant when you are using your screw driver to drive screws.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoAre you speaking from a place of expertise and knowledge of the current law, or drawing conclusions based on how you think it should work? I am speaking from some experience and this is the prevailing opinion in the field. Here is a decent primer on the topic [1] >Why bother evaluating safety and effectiveness at all if that's supposed to be purely a case by case judgement call by a physician? The point is to prevent the manufacture, false advertising, and sale of snake oil. Surely you see the value in this even if it stops short of telling doctors what to do in their own offices? As mentioned above, I wholly agree that intended use can not be separated from device. The FDA can absolutely revoke approval for one of a devices uses and not the others. The FDA can pull a device from the market entirely. However, doctors do not need approval from the FDA to use a device approved for one intended use outside of it's scope. If it is clear that a device is being used on a regular basis for an indication outside of the labeling, the situation then becomes an FDA and manufacturer issue.[2] I sincerely hope this helps. [1] https://aaos.org/contentassets/1cd7f41417ec4dd4b5c4c48532183b96/1177-physician-directed-use-of-medical-products.pdf https://aaos.org/contentassets/1cd7f41417ec4dd4b5c4c48532183... [2] https://evtoday.com/articles/2003-mar/0303_181.html#:~:text=A%3A%20Off%2Dlabel%20use%20is,an%20FDA%20and%20manufacturer%20issue https://evtoday.com/articles/2003-mar/0303_181.html#:~:text=....
- jjk166 5y agoAs I said repeatedly, I'm reading the law as it is written, agreeing strongly with the dissenting judge's opinion in this case. I work in medical device manufacturing, and everyone I know in the field considers devices to be usage specific - that's how they're designed and that's how they're regulated. The FDA has only ever banned 3 devices, and all of them have been banned only for specific use cases. You seem to be mistaking the argument as saying the FDA has authority to regulate the practice of medicine. No one is saying that. I am saying that the FDA has the authority to ban a device, and that the device's use is a part of it, a point you say you agree with. At issue here is the definition of legally marketed device. If you hold that an ESD for smoking is the same device as an ESD for self injury, then the legal availability of the former means that the latter is also legally available, and thus physicians may use it. However, my argument, which is also the FDA's argument, is that these are clearly two separate devices. They're not buying an ESD for smoking and using it off-label to treat self injury, they are making a custom device with a different control scheme to do a different task. If these are two distinct devices, the FDA unambiguously has the authority to ban one of them. And if it is banned, it is not a legally marketed device available for off-label use. Both common sense and precedent indicate devices with different intended uses are different devices which ought to be regulated differently. Paraphrasing from the FDA's ban: the reason that this device needed to be banned in the first place instead of just modifying the label is that the source of the risk is the labelled use, not an off-label use that would be covered by the exemption. Off-label use of a different type of ESD device is fine, but on-label use of this type is not. [1] https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2020/03/06/2020-04328/banned-devices-electrical-stimulation-devices-for-self-injurious-or-aggressive-behavior https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2020/03/06/2020-04...