5 ms·
Why would it be an entitled viewpoint? He/she wants to watch a series on a service he/she pays for. It is entirely reasonable to expect said service to continue
by kaba0 5y ago
Why would it be an entitled viewpoint? He/she wants to watch a series on a service he/she pays for. It is entirely reasonable to expect said service to continue to serve previously available content - it was of course a legal way of operation that the owner didn’t extend their license and that Netflix removed episodes. But gp has every right to be upset that netflix due to any reason didn’t live up to expectations.
- dylan604 5y ago> But gp has every right to be upset that netflix due to any reason didn’t live up to expectations. Those expectations are unrealistic, and quite frankly entitled. When did Netflix ever state that any content available now will be available for ever? It's the nature of the business that content is only made available for a set amount of time. What does complaining about it on the internet expect to do anyways?
- sillysaurusx 5y agoWhat's wrong with being entitled? We're entitled to our entertainment. If we don't get it, we torrent it.
- abnry 5y agoYou are not entitled to entertainment. If there is literally anything as petulant and first-world narcissistic it is the belief that one is entitled to entertainment.
- sillysaurusx 5y agoBut... we are, because we can pirate it if it's not available to us. I suppose "entitled" isn't the correct word. Is there a word for "That's just the way it is"? Basically, there exists a way to acquire entertainment. It's up to businesses to provide that entertainment to us at a reasonable market value. If the market value exceeds the threshold of reasonableness, then we downshift into torrenting the entertainment. It's a business opportunity. The music industry learned this in 2008 or so.
- dylan604 5y ago>"That's just the way it is"? How many sins of the past have used that as an excuse? It's just a very immature way of looking at life. >It's up to businesses to provide that entertainment to us And that doesn't sound entitled??? Wow. Not that we are lucky for someone providing us entertainment (within the confines of how they choose to share it)? >The music industry learned this in 2008 or so. Did they though? Really learned it? Seems like they got what the wanted where nobody actually owns anything and is only able to rent the content from them.
- sillysaurusx 5y agoIt’s an interesting question. I think I’ll meet you halfway and debate it. The central question here seems to be ethics. Is it moral to download entertainment when someone doesn’t want you to? My view is, nobody is harmed. You could argue that there was financial harm to the original show — in this case, Stargate SG-1. But I would say they’ve failed to give us a way to reasonably enjoy the show, when the best alternative is to simply torrent it. Suppose the show was made available for $2,000. Would you still argue that it’s wrong to torrent it? If so, we’ll have to agree to disagree; my view is that if nobody is harmed, then it’s usually fine. If not, then there exists a price threshold beyond which it would become unreasonable to expect someone to pay. The person you were replying to was saying that they felt the show crossed that threshold.
- dylan604 5y agoAn honest debate. I'm kind of shocked. I still come back to the fact that there is no right/expectation of anyone to be able to view anything. The fact that something exists and someone says they should be able to watch it is the entitled bit in my opinion. There is no "god given right" to entertainment. There is no "pursuit of entertainment" set out in the US Constitution. If someone graciously allows you to watch/view their work, then that's great and we hope you were entertained. The expectation one should be able to watch/view anything at anytime is a bit petty. If someone asks to be paid to view that entertainment but in a very controlled/restricted manner (ex: buying a ticket to a limited capacity venu), this seems to be accepted. However, once it was allowed to be broadcast/streamed with certain restrictions (for a limited 3 month period), people feel like this is not acceptable. At the end of the day, it is the content owner's discretion to allow/disallow as they see fit. People do not like calling it stealling because no physcial copy has been removed from the owner's possession, but the owner is still be wronged by not being allowed to control the thing they created. I do not know what to call that.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"Those expectations ... entitled." He is the customer, Netflix is asking for his money
- abnry 5y agoRight, he's the customer, but he violates the customer-supplier social contract by pirating.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoWell my grandma doesn't, and Netflix doesn't let her watch SG1 either, so how is this relevant?
- johnchristopher 5y agoNetflix is a rental platform. Like the old DVD and VHS rental shops. And regularly some content gets pull off the shelves because they don't have the licensing fees. It's a pretty well known fact some movies and TV shows come and go on Netflix. And for what ? Pirating "culture" that is not available on Netflix ? Star Trek Voyager ? I am huge Trek fan but come on. This is entertainment we are talking about. > He/she wants to watch a series on a service he/she pays for. It's like complaining a vegan restaurant doesn't serve meat. Netflix has very few of the shows, movies and documentaries I can watch on ARTe. Do people complain that ARTe doesn't stream every Netflix shows and vice versa ? There are a lot of comments on HN when this topic comes up that feel like people want their cake and eat it too "or else I'll just pirate, there's a gun to my head, they give me no choice".
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago> "It's like complaining a vegan restaurant doesn't serve meat." No, it's like complaining that a chain of restaurant randomly takes dishes off the menu, and it's different in every country. Eventually you get fed up with unpredictable menu and stop going there.
- johnchristopher 5y ago> No, it's like complaining that a chain of restaurant randomly takes dishes off the menu, and it's different in every country. Which is still ridiculous. Even McDonald's don't have the same menu everywhere. All restaurants I know have dishes that are taken off (because if's off season, because a new chef, because they try something else, etc.). Plus, the analogy is distorted, you can't complain about a different menu in another country, it's not like you can hop from countries to countries 20 times per evening to get your Mc Bulgogi Burger. > Eventually you get fed up with unpredictable menu and stop going there. Good, that's what competition is about between services.
- dmitriid 5y ago> Which is still ridiculous. Even McDonald's don't have the same menu everywhere. That's why analogies never work. Here, it's simple: - that person is already paying Netflix, legally - SG1 was available on Netflix, so the money was going to whoever owns the right to SG1, too - Then SG1 was not made available (for whichever reason, in 99% of the cases blame the rights owner, and you'll be right) So now the rights owner earns exactly zero dollars for SG1 from people who are paying for Netflix. If those people chose to pirate SG1, literally nothing in the equation will change: the owners will keep not getting the money. And the only fault lies with the people who decided to pull SG1 (and other content) from Netflix.
- sbuk 5y agoWhen they signed up for said service, was there an implicit agreement in place that said they would show whatever show he/she wanted, when they wanted? While I agree that the GP has the right to be upset that their expectations weren’t met, it doesn’t make the unreasonable expectations right. I’d argue that Netflix, or whoever, not carrying a show or file for whatever reason, save them explicitly stating that they would do and failing to do so, is unreasonable. That would be, to me, entitled.
- kaba0 5y agoIt frankly, doesn’t really matter whether it is a reasonable or an “entitled” reason a customer is upset. What matters is he/she is not happy with a service and thus will terminate his subscription.
- sbuk 5y agoThat's how commerce works...
- lloydatkinson 5y agoDid I ever say that I expected them to show X whenever I wanted? No, I simply eaid "for no reason". If I was entitled I'd have said "I demand to watch it". Stop being an idiot.
- lloydatkinson 5y agoIt's tragically my experience of HN - someone posts an interesting fact or discusses something they've done and someone comes up and picks up the smallest irrelevant detail to argue about.