33 ms·
A journey through the troubled former Yugoslavia
- dccoolgai 5y ago> The memory of Jasenovac, the "Auschwitz of the Balkans,” is one of the more neglected facets of recent Croatian history. The fascist Ustasha’s henchmen murdered around 100,000 people, mostly Serbs, Jews and Roma, in their satellite state, which was tolerated by Hitler. Funny, you didn't hear a lot about that in the media while we were bombing out Serbia in the late 90s / early 00s.
- nezirus 5y agoJasenovac happenned during WWII, one of the most despicable events in history of the Croatia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jasenovac_concentration_camp https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jasenovac_concentration_camp However, the memory of Jasenovac often serves as justification for new atrocities commited to revenge the victims (50 years later!) Serbia was bombarded for crimes on Kosovo, probably to stop Kosovo from becoming next Bosnia...
- dccoolgai 5y agoI did not comment at all about the "rightness or wrongness" of what either side did: My comment was more about the American media and how it covered the conflict. My honest feelings about the region are that it's a bunch of people who have been brutal to each other for centuries (and continue to be), but if you watched Christian Amanpour on CNN during that time, you would get the impression that it was an entirely one-sided conflict where only the Serbs did wrong and we were completely justified in stepping in and waging war. In my opinion, I think in 100 years looking back this will be remembered by some very observant historians as the prelude to Afghanistan/Iraq and the "beginning of the end" of America's dominance. People were complete tools, there was not even the hint of a counter-narrative to the "Serbs are bad" stories being pushed by the govt through mainstream media. The real story, of course, was a lot more complicated. The Serbs weren't "right" for trying to get revenge on people who collaborated with Hitler to exterminate them but that background information was never even presented while the war was being sold to US public.
- boomskats 5y agoMore concerning is the proud position Jasenovac holds in the modern day right-wing Croatian narrative - an increasingly socialised, romanticised version of neofascism. The Croatian Wikipedia Disinformation writeup from a few weeks ago [0] was some rabbithole - for those who understand the language. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27563118 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27563118
- ardit33 5y agoMuslim Bosnians and Albanians are not Croats and have nothing to do with whatever you are describing. Serbs find any way to justify their horrendous act, except come out clean and move on to have better relations with their neighbors.
- boomskats 5y agoCorrect. My comment made no mention of Bosnians or Albanians, nor did it have anything to do with Serbs. I’m assuming you wouldn’t pass a captcha test, but if I’m wrong and you want to elaborate on your comment I’d love to better understand the point you were trying to make.
- ardit33 5y agoThe bombing of Kosovo was to protect Albanians from ethnic cleansing. Also, Bosnians are not croats and had nothing to do with it and what happened during WW2. And the serbs did genocide to them anyway. This victim mentality is toxic. How is this justified in any way? "We got mistreated during WW2, so we feel justified to do war crimes to completely other groups 50 years later...."
- handzar 5y ago>had nothing to do with it and what happened during WW2 Outsiders meddling and their uninformed[1] rhetoric complicate things further. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/13th_Waffen_Mountain_Division_of_the_SS_Handschar_(1st_Croatian) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/13th_Waffen_Mountain_Division_...
- nezirus 5y agoI can't speak for other ex Yugoslav republics, but Bosnia and Herzegovina is in permanent state od limbo, for 25 years, and probably for the next 25. Corruption is rampant, nationalistic retoric abundant... One of the main reasons we are a failed state is Dayton peace agreement. It awarded war and genocide. Just imagine post WWII Germany, splitted in two parts, one ruled by ex facists, still denying holocaust, the other part ruled by self serving, corrupt, thieves and bastards (can't say they are better than facists, because all of them got into power and got rich during the war) The whole region will have half of the population (from year 1991), in just a few decades. Young people/families will never return...
- wolfhumble 5y agoSo what would have been a good solution?
- nezirus 5y agoFor starters, don't reward war crimes. Organize swift trials. They've only recently finished trials of high ranking generals and officials, there are thousands lower ranked ones which will never feel the hand of justice.
- wolfhumble 5y agoThanks for your input. And what about the territorial control and governmental system?
- nezirus 5y agoDunno, we're probably fucked up anyway. Our education system is destroyed, splintered into many small pieces, low quality, that is the worst thing for the future. There are simply too many layers of government, half of the country considers itself part of Serbia, the other part is busy crying wolf (while stuffing money into pockets). Teritorial rearangements wont make people more educated, happier, wealthier... Even welcoming Bosnia into EU wouldn't help, that would be just a free pass to relocate for work, and a shot of a decent life (that is not easy to achieve in a foreign country, working jobs locals would not take)
- nathan_phoenix 5y agoArchive.is link: https://archive.is/GWohX https://archive.is/GWohX
- e2021 5y agoI remember when Spiegel did this same sort of travel story through the US and it turned out the author just made most of it up to fit whatever stereotypes he wanted to confirm about americans. Hard to take them seriously after that.
- Macha 5y agoWelcome to being on the receiving end of a travelogue, I guess.
- hef19898 5y agoThe Spiegel is great at this kind of storytelling. I came to see them as the BILD for people abl to read snetences with more than 5 words.
- hutzlibu 5y agoWhile looking down on anyone who reads the Bild and co. and feeling very superior in general.
- finiteseries 5y agoClaas Relotious, went on for a decade. Der Spiegel, its editors, its fact checkers, and its readers ate it all right up for years and years. https://www.newyorker.com/news/dispatch/the-deep-pathology-at-the-heart-of-the-scandal-at-der-spiegel https://www.newyorker.com/news/dispatch/the-deep-pathology-a... https://medium.com/@micheleanderson/der-spiegel-journalist-messed-with-the-wrong-small-town-d92f3e0e01a7 https://medium.com/@micheleanderson/der-spiegel-journalist-m...
- billfruit 5y agoI recommend Rebecca West's 'Black Lamb and Grey Flacon" as good book on the Balkans. The people seem strongly in touch with history going back centuries.
- emptyfile 5y agoAmazed that the article paints Croatia as a country with "rising anti-democratic forces" while for some reason not mentioning that a month ago the mayoral election in the capital city (quarter of the population) was won by a left-green coalition modelled on Podemos. They won 40% of the vote.
- madengr 5y agoThe left is anti-democratic when they establish power. Not saying that the right is either.
- hef19898 5y agoCroatia is strange in that regard. On the one hand you have that mayoral election, on the other you have their national soccer team flying the nationalists version of Croatias flag. (if what our newspaper claimed was true. even if it is, they also printed a wrong flag of the opposite team on their jerseys once, so it could also just be a stupid mistake). I love that country so, very nice people and a beautiful landscape!
- dinoooo 5y ago> nationalists version of Croatias flag It wasn't the nationalist version, any state flag is inherently a nationalist symbol, the problem is that the logo is from the NDH, a Nazi puppet state of Croatia, which created the Jasenovac concentration camp. It might be a mistake, but as a young adult, everyone around me (I live in Croatia) knows what the 'first white square' symbolizes.
- guerrilla 5y agoIt should be noted that while the article writes "communist" and "regime", the economy and political structure of Yugoslavia differed drastically from what was going on in the likes of the USSR, DRR, etc. as did their foreign policy [1][2][3] 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_the_Socialist_Federal_Republic_of_Yugoslavia#1950s_and_1960s https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_the_Socialist_Feder... 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Titoism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Titoism 3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_socialism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_socialism
- hef19898 5y agoTito was impressive just by managing to be somewhat communist but never falling under the control of the USSR. Maybe being the first real pain for Nazi Germany in WW2, resistance wise, helps not being affraid of larger powers.
- dominotw 5y agoI've always had ppl on HN Tell me that they never 'accept cookies' and just reader mode or some such thing. Whats the work around here?
- jaclaz 5y agoIt works for me in QTweb (yes I know) with javascript disabled.
- vladvasiliu 5y agoI clicked on "continue with ads" and it worked. Firefox with uBlock Origin + uMatrix.
- badjeans 5y agoI get "We were unfortunately unable to place the cookie that is necessary for the use of our site. Is your computer connected to the internet through a company network? We recommend that you ask your IT department for an exception for DER SPIEGEL content. Have you configured a browser extension or the browser itself such that cookies are blocked? Please add DER SPIEGEL to your list of exceptions. Should you continue to have problems, you can find more information here." I only have ublock origin and a minimum of config changes.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoWeird that didn't work for me.. FF + uBlock Origin. They have a really nasty paywall that checks if they can actually place a cookie. Thankfully nathan_phoenix' archive.is link worked great.
- 9front 5y agoThe conflict in what used to be Yugoslavia is not 30 something years old. It's about 14 centuries old. It is the clash of cultures between Christians and Islamist, with the later trying to impose their beliefs on the former. I stayed over there for about one year just before the fighting would start. Yugoslavia was a beautiful country indeed.
- shimonabi 5y agoThat is a false narrative. Yugoslavia was an ethnically mixed state, with the exception of Slovenia. Serbia tried to keep its terriorially disparate Orthodox communities in one state, but was too weak to do so in the end. There was also a growing unwillingness of the rich northern countries to pay for the less developed southern countries (just like today in the EU). After the economic failure of communism, there was also a crisis of idealism and people were trying to find meaning in their past religious traditions. Politicians inflamed the divisions to secure their power. Islamism had hardly anything to do with it.
- hcho 5y agoSo the Catholic-Orthodox secterianism is due to Islamist expansion. Gotcha.
- ardit33 5y agowut... are you smoking. first of all the region was Illyrian, then it was conquered by the Roman empire, and it was the border between the West and East Roman (Byzantine Empire), which was Christian. Then the pagan slavs migrated/invaded it in the 650-700, and the Byzantine Empire fought them back (there are still villages in Greece that have Slavic toponyms). The byzantine empire started declining, and the slavs created the first Bulgarian empire (the Bullgars were Turkic nomadic tribes who mixed with the local Slavs, but they were not Islamisiced then and eventually converted to Christian Orthodox). The different slavic tribes started fighting with each other and created the many petty kindoms which formed the today's south slav ethnicities. And eventually the Ottomans conquered the whole place in 1400s until the 1900s, including the Albanians and eventually the Romanians in north East, and parts of Hungary in the north. So.... there is 500 years of conflict against the ottomans, but really there is another 1000 years of medieval conflicts that you are completely ignoring.
- mishkovski 5y agoThe Slavic majority in Macedonia has a name, Walter Mayr. It is Macedonians. Western media’s ignorance of one small nation’s struggle for recognition really puzzles me. Yes we are Slavs but you don’t call Russians Slavic majority in Russia. After more than a century of neighbour's aggressive politics to stifle Macedonian’s national awakening the least I expect from the media is to call the majority of my home country Macedonians. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macedonians_(ethnic_group) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macedonians_(ethnic_group)
- mlang23 5y ago"national awakening", umpf. People still think this is a positive thing these days.
- creamytaco 5y agoNot to mention the blatant usurpation of the greek word "macedonia" without any linguistic, ethnic connection to it (ancient macedonians were greeks, not slavs). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancient_Macedonians https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancient_Macedonians
- mishkovski 5y agoNobody mentioned Ancient Macedonians.
- creamytaco 5y agoThe ancient kingdom of Macedon is geographically located in Greece: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macedonia_(ancient_kingdom)#/media/File:Map_Macedonia_336_BC-en.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macedonia_(ancient_kingdom)#/m... That region is still called Macedon and the modern inhabitants of that region are themselves called Macedonians. As opposed to the slavic macedonians, they do have strong historical, linguistic and ethnic connections to the term. Do you see the problem here?
- ceilingcorner 5y agoThe viewpoint that this article is missing: much of this “reversion” to anti-democratic governments in Central Europe (Visegrad+ Balkans) is coming from Western EU members pushing their newfangled cultural ideologies a little too hard. Poland, Hungary, Slovakia, Ex-Yugoslavia want to be a part of the EU for economic reasons, not so they can participate in American-led cultural movements. If the EU doesn’t wise up and tone down their revolutionary zeal, these countries are going to be pushed even further away, eventually even towards Russia, China, or Turkey.
- nisa 5y agoI call bullshit on this. It's a propaganda tale from the controlled media in these states to avoid having to talk about oligarchs, corruption and and real issues. At least it's pretty visible in Czechia, where Andrej Babiš and the media controlled by him to use this narration. Hungary probably the same.
- ceilingcorner 5y agoDo you really think that every single country in the world has the same values as certain groups in the EU?
- nisa 5y agoAs far as I know most laws that are 'pushed' are based on providing equality, protection of minorities and avoiding discrimination (i.e. LBGT). Basically things like these are not okay: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hungarian_anti-LGBT_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hungarian_anti-LGBT_law
- ceilingcorner 5y agoThat is only a very small part of it. The only reason laws like this exist is because they are perceived as being defensive measures against a huge “Western” cultural / media project. As the other commenter said, most of these movements have nothing to do with Eastern and Central European history, so they aren’t received well. E.g. Poland and Hungary had no colonies so anti-colonialism ideology doesn’t make much sense to be there...yet it is being pushed.
- tchvil 5y agoStrange, not any word about Montenegro. One of the former republic. A beautiful place to visit.
- ardit33 5y agoit is very beautiful.... it has its own tensions. Montenegrins (which are slavs) are more west looking, vs. Serbs (which are also slavs, who are more east looking), vs. Albanians who are not slavs and really want to join Albania anyway, and the are the people of the Sanjak region, who are closer related to Bosnians but are are mixture of slavs + others. So, Montenegro is seen as a sleepy buffer state, created and kept by the great powers to keep Serbia (and Russia by proxy) away from the Adriatic and the Mediterranean Sea. It usually tries not to get involved into controversies. During the Yugoslav wars they wanted to stay out, but got ropped in by the Serbs.
- dang 5y agoAll: please don't wage national or religious wars via internet comments on Hacker News. There's a lot of that in the thread below—not cool, and not what this site is for. If you're going to comment on a topic like this please do so thoughtfully, substantively, and with respect for those who disagree—assume that there are a lot of them here, and their reasons for holding their views are just as valid, and just as rooted in their background, as yours are. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- locallost 5y agoAt this point this is probably on page 21 of HN, making my comment somewhat pointless, but I have an itch to scratch. As someone with ties to the region, I am always slightly confused by these articles because they are mostly an echo of the past. There is not much new here. You can place it at any point in the last 20 years and it would for the most part be valid. There's a lot going on in the world and I understand people don't have the attention span for all the details of the globe, but they don't even need to have. As a German newspaper, Spiegel could take a look at Germany's role, or even the EU's in what happened there. There are interesting topics even today, e.g. what is Gerhard Schröder doing there now and what was his role 20 years ago? As it is now, it's mostly just a stereotypical report that riles people up and kind of ends up amplifying those stereotypes. The article could be about some islands in the Pacific, but that's not true if you are a German newspaper! The article touches upon some interesting developments related to the EU, e.g. that it's unfortunately not really a solution as it's mostly resulted in people leaving, but it lacks focus in general, and it holds no critical views. Another interesting angle could've been the conflicts that have been brewing internally for decades now that there are clearly separated nation states, and the enemies are for the most part behind clearly defined borders. And lastly it could take an optimistic view that surely exists if for no other reason than that I'm an optimist, and I'm not alone. Not all people had severed ties completely even during the darkest times, and it's been a long time since. It's time for new perspectives.