5 ms·
That’s the kicker - almost no one pays these prices so when they get stupid nobody notices. Unless you’re uninsured then that’s the price they use. As someone
by refurb 5y ago
That’s the kicker - almost no one pays these prices so when they get stupid nobody notices. Unless you’re uninsured then that’s the price they use.
As someone in the healthcare field - the best way I can describe it is that providers and insurers fight it out however they can. The problem is is that patients get the shit end of the stick.
I think calling out that both hospitals and insurers are fucking over patients is a positive change. Hospitals used to always get a pass, but they’re a huge part of the problem.
- caturopath 5y ago> Unless you’re uninsured then that’s the price they use. I don't think many uninsured people are paying sticker. Sometimes they automatically get charged with a discount, sometimes they have to call and get it. Some folks don't know to call, but these folks' bills are, I expect, not usually getting paid in full in the end anyhow.
- refurb 5y agoTrue it’s not the price they pay typically, but it’s the price they start with. It’s “hey, well knock 50% off the cost if you pay now”. Which is stupid, since the price has no basis with reality. The insurance companies know this - when they negotiate, they look at $90k for stitches and say “yeah, we’ll pay you $1,200”. The uninsured get screwed because the hospital acts like their charge master prices have some basis in reality.
- hasbot 5y agoIn my case, there was no discount.
- caturopath 5y agoYou were charged the equivalent of 93k for stitches and paid it? That is exceedingly rare.
- atlasunshrugged 5y agoBut do uninsured people actually really pay this? My impression was that you still can (and should) try to negotiate with hospitals/providers whenever possible and/or ask them to create a payment plan for you. But maybe that's not common knowledge? Since you're in the space, what do you think of the startup they mentioned in the thread, turquoise.health (or rather the idea behind it, not literally the startup)?
- kgantchev 5y agoNo, uninsured people also don't pay it. They are offered a fraction of the cost if they pay "cash" once you're leaving. I went to the same ER in San Francisco with the same problem 3 months apart (kidney stones). The first time around I was uninsured and the bill was $2000- they told me that they'll cut it down to $500 if I paid on the spot, which I did. 3 months later I had the same problem, had purchased insurance, my bill came out to $8000 and my deductible was $2000.
- atlasunshrugged 5y agoOkay, interesting. I had read some articles about medical debt that alluded to those levels of savings for paying cash in one lump sum quickly but still, it's pretty striking that you get a 75% "discount" for cash on the spot.
- pc86 5y agoAnd not to mention when they say "on the spot," they mean it. In the room, right there, as you're checking out. If you don't have access to any payment methods or you need to wait two days until you get paid or something, you're looking at a 50-100% increase over the final quoted "cash price" even if you're still paying cash.
- Rapzid 5y agoCan confirm. Had a procedure (hernia repair) and at the time of setting it up my insurance was in flux. I asked for the cash price to move things along and was quoted just ~7k all up. Insurance ended up covering it but received one of those invoices were it starts at over 20k before the magic "discount" gets applied. I have been assuming the magic discount is some sham the insurance companies push for to scare people into believing they would not get it if it weren't for the insurance. It's BS IMHO to not be advertising the ACTUAL cash amounts they would quote somebody..