4 ms·
Forests in steady state are carbon neutral. This is an important insight not widely spread. They're also oxygen neutral. But a new forest will be a large carbo
by BurningFrog 5y ago
Forests in steady state are carbon neutral. This is an important insight not widely spread. They're also oxygen neutral.
But a new forest will be a large carbon sink if allowed to remain.
Individual trees are also great carbon sinks, as long as the resulting wood is not consumed.
I wonder about just growing trees/bamboo and storing the logs on big piles as a carbon sink.
Or what if we GMO some algae that grabs carbon through photosynthesis, and then sinks to the ocean floor?
- gonzo41 5y agoI think we're going to a have a boom of CRISPR derived plants that are going to help us out big time.
- SKILNER 5y agoInteresting! Can you point to any references?
- vbezhenar 5y agoIf you'll build things from the wood rather than burning it, it'll still be carbon-neutral for many years. And you can grow new tree where it was cut, to consume more carbon. Now the question is how to utilise used wood without releasing carbon. May be just drown it to deep water?
- BurningFrog 5y agoThe Baltic and, I believe. the Black Sea, preserves sunken ships for many centuries, because no wood eating organisms can live in that water. So it seems you could weigh wood with some rocks and sink it there as a permanent enough solution.
- gruez 5y ago>I wonder about just growing trees/bamboo and storing the logs on big piles as a carbon sink. Biochar is pretty similar to what you're describing.
- ArkanExplorer 5y agoEven if we recreated the entire Amazon Rainforest, it would only be equivalent in embedded carbon to 4-5x our annual human emissions: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/article/amazon-rainforest-now-appears-to-be-contributing-to-climate-change#:~:text=In%20trees%20and%20carbon%2Drich,year%20across%20the%20forest%20floor https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/article/amazo.... We would have to essentially recreate the Azolla event (a geological process that took place for 800,000 years) to undo the carbon we are putting into the atmosphere: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Azolla_event https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Azolla_event The only way to stop climate change is to stop digging coal and oil out of the ground and burning it.
- asdswe 5y agoIt would make much more sense to build houses out of those logs instead of storing them on big piles. That way you can reduce concrete use in buildings, which itself is a major source of carbon emissions. Log houses have been a thing for a LONG time in many parts of the world, and other types of wooden building exists as well. It seems like environmentalists have totally forgotten this obvious and superior form of carbon sink. Here in Finland we're building even large blocks of flats from wooden materials these days. Yet the EU keeps telling us not to utilize our forests as much as we do now...
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoI think we'd need to see the total carbon cost for the proessing of the lumber before we can say whether construction with wood has a net zero or net negative carbon impact. Harvesting, milling, kiln drying, and transport all seem to me like quite energy intensive operations.
- BurningFrog 5y agoUsing wood for construction is good, but it involves a lot of work, and there is a limit to how many houses we need. I imagine producing far more logs. Not that I've done any math, so I could be wildly wrong.
- asdswe 5y agoIt doesn't seem to be too much of work or uneconomical, here in Finland construction firms are already making large apartment buildings at least partially out of wood, smaller ones have been built from wood for thousands of years already. Apparently it can be also faster than concrete building, because you don't have to wait for the concrete to dry. If this were to become a global trend, I think it could really absorb a lot of carbon while also reducing concrete emissions. Admittedly logistics could increase the costs for many parts of the world that lack forests with suitable wood.
- inglor_cz 5y agoAFAIK the timber needs to be fairly dry as well, so there is a significant time gap between harvesting the timber and starting the construction. This can be managed as long as the demand curve moves in predictable ways.