33 ms·
FDA’s ban on the use of electric shock devices overturned
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- detaro 5y agofull title: FDA’s ban on the use of electric shock devices used at Judge Rotenberg Center in Massachusetts overturned, truncated due to HN title length limit
- alyandon 5y ago“The GED is a treatment of last resort ... ” Sure it is. And if it is referred to in plain language as a treatment it sure sounds like it falls under the purview of the FDA to regulate it.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoAs someone familiar with this area, it is much more complicated than that. The FDA has legal restrictions on what it can and can't regulate. At the heart of this ruling is the fact that the FDA is forbidden from regulating the practice of medicine. State law is required to regulate the practice of medicine. from the Dissenting opinion: >There is no dispute that the FDA has power under the statute to ban a medical device altogether—i.e., across all its potential uses. The issue in this case is whether the FDA can exercise its banning authority in a more tailored fashion: rather than ban a device across the board, can the agency ban the device for a particular intended use while allowing it for other uses?[1] The question becomes, once a device is approved, does banning it for a specific use constitute regulating the practice of medicine. [1] https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-caDC-20-01087/pdf/USCOURTS-caDC-20-01087-0.pdf https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-caDC-20-01087/p...
- jjk166 5y agoThe FDA regulates medical device safety and effectiveness. Something that is safe and effective if used one way can most certainly be unsafe or ineffective if used in another way. Viagra as a treatment for erectile dysfunction? Safe and effective. Viagra as a treatment for low blood pressure? Extremely unsafe and the opposite of effective. And specifically, the law restricting the FDA from regulating the practice of medicine reads: > Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to limit or interfere with the authority of a health care practitioner to prescribe or administer any legally marketed device to a patient for any condition or disease within a legitimate health care practitioner-patient relationship. This section shall not limit any existing authority of the Secretary to establish and enforce restrictions on the sale or distribution, or in the labeling, of a device that are part of a determination of substantial equivalence, established as a condition of approval, or promulgated through regulations. While this clearly leaves open the option for general off-label use, I don't read this as barring the FDA from limiting a specific form of off-label use. The decision also relies on some peculiar interpretations of language - for example it recognizes that the FDA has the right to impose use-specific restrictions on a device, but does not consider a ban to be a subcategory of restriction. And reading the definition of device which is intended to distinguish between a device used for medicine vs one that is not (which obviously ties a device's classification to how it is utilized) as implying use is irrelevant simply because the word disease is not explicitly singular seems absurd. Consider a test that distinguishes bacterial from viral infections - it doesn't make sense to label it as a separate device for every single viral and bacterial disease, but that doesn't mean it's use is irrelevant. And an important point from the dissent: > The devices, for instance, can be used to treat smoking addiction. When used for that purpose, the agency found, the devices present a different, and acceptable, benefit-risk profile. Id. at 13,317. That is in part because a smoker typically controls the device and can stop its use when it causes undue pain, and she can also communicate any harmful symptoms to a healthcare provider. Id. By contrast, persons with intellectual or developmental disabilities receiving treatment for self-injurious or aggressive behaviors often do not control the electrical stimulation devices they wear (rather, the devices are controlled by a third party or automatically trigger upon detecting certain movements). Id.; Proposed Rule, 81 Fed. Reg. at 24,394, 24,396. Those persons also may lack the ability to discern a causal connection between the devices and physical or psychological harm, or may be unable to communicate the harmful symptoms to others. It's not just what they're using the device for, it's how the device is physically designed to be used. Imagine a defibrillator that instead of going off when an operator pushes a button, instead goes off at random intervals. Imagine a medical radiation source with its radiation shield that controls dosage removed. Imagine an anesthetic delivery system that delivered the same amount of anesthetic to every patient regardless of their physiology. Changing how a device is controlled changes the device, and the FDA should most certainly have the power to ban devices with clearly unsafe or ineffective control schemes. I very strongly agree with the dissenting opinion on this one, and I hope this ruling gets overturned.
- aaron-santos 5y agoThe article contains a link[1] which demonstrates one such device in use. If you do not wish to hear pleading and screams of pain then I suggest you not watch it. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YcxpGKctZMs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YcxpGKctZMs