3 ms·
No, it's not untrue. If you optimize a CO2-free grid for minimum cost, you will find that the solutions don't usually involve both renewables (particularly win
by pfdietz 5y ago
No, it's not untrue. If you optimize a CO2-free grid for minimum cost, you will find that the solutions don't usually involve both renewables (particularly wind) and nuclear. Either nuclear is so expensive it goes to zero, or its so cheap it dominates. There's little synergy between renewables and nuclear.
This also happens in unplanned grids where market forces are being allowed to operate. Renewables, if they are cheaper per kWh than nuclear, drive down the price sufficiently often that nuclear struggles (and with production subsidies, they can drive prices negative, but never mind that). Today, even existing nuclear plants are struggling to make an operating profit in the US.
> And in general, renewables do need a flexible supplement. So what would you suggest?
For the moment, this would be natural gas. If you object to the CO2 from this, consider that to compete against NG CC for BASELOAD in the US, new nuclear would need a CO2 tax of $300/ton or more (see below for quote and link). For new nuclear to compete against NG to cover renewable intermittency, the CO2 tax would have to be much higher, perhaps $1000/ton or more, depending on the fraction of time the NG generators are needed. This is a ludicrously high CO2 tax, and shows how far out of contention new nuclear plants would be.
In the future, this last resort generation could be replaced with something like hydrogen (either produced from NG by SMR with CO2 capture, or from renewable energy by electrolysis.) And it would still be cheaper than new nuclear.
> Gas is extremely expensive to run,
No. Quote from Physics Today (Crane was the president of Exelon):
https://physicstoday.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/PT.3.4088 https://physicstoday.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/PT.3.4088
“The cost of new nuclear is prohibitive for us to be investing in,” says Crane. Exelon considered building two new reactors in Texas in 2005, he says, when gas prices were $8/MMBtu and were projected to rise to $13/MMBtu. At that price, the project would have been viable with a CO2 tax of $25 per ton. “We’re sitting here trading 2019 gas at $2.90 per MMBtu,” he says; for new nuclear power to be competitive at that price, a CO2 tax “would be $300–$400.” Exelon currently is placing its bets instead on advances in energy storage and carbon sequestration technologies.
(Since then, Exelon has announced they want to spin off all their nuclear generating assets.)
> More pumped hydro is impossible to build due to environmental regs, NIMBY and geography.
More pumped hydro ON EXISTING RIVERS is geographically constrained, but off-river PHES much less so. It has vast potential in most parts of the world, especially when coupled with long distance transmission.
- Gravityloss 5y agoNuclear would need to get cheaper than current nuclear methods. How to get rid of excess complexity in regulations while still retaining good safety... I have some ideas.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoEven with zero regulations, nuclear would still have a cost problem. Just the steam turbine part of a nuclear power plant is more expensive than renewables. Coal is uncompetitive for the same reason.
- pfdietz 5y agoWhen I see "less regulation!" talk, I want to ask "so, you're going to do away with the expensive parts, like the containment building?" If new nuclear is going to ever be plausible, it has to be some fundamentally new (like reactors with molten salts) that don't need massive containment buildings that can safely contain large volumes of steam in accidents. Such reactors will not be commercially viable soon.
- corty 5y agoThe containment isn't the most expensive part, the pressure vessel is. Single forged part of some magic stainless steel alloy able to withstand 300bar at 500K and high neutron flux costing a billion or more. Gen4 reactor designs try to do without that by having the actual core non-pressurized, e.g. in molten-salt reactors or pebble-bed reactors. The other idea is making a loss-of-coolant-accident harmless, thereby getting rid of the necessity to have too many redundant ultra-expensive cooling systems (current EPRs are at quadruple-redundant...). The problem with regulation there is that those novel designs are currently still regulated based upon the aforementioned PWR/BWR reactor designs (so your coolant system has to have X amount of redundancy, the reactor vessel must withstand Y amount of pressure, ...), forcing unnecessary cost that isn't necessary because the possible accidents and conditions are completely different.