3 ms·
Well, the original topic of this discussion is water scarcity, and that is determined by absolute # of people living in the Nile basin. Not by just TFR. One can
by inglor_cz 5y ago
Well, the original topic of this discussion is water scarcity, and that is determined by absolute # of people living in the Nile basin. Not by just TFR. One can argue that in order to achieve sustainable levels of population, the TFR should have dropped much more and much earlier than it actually did, and discuss the reasons why the decline wasn't as fast.
After all, with the concentration of people in the Nile delta, everyone had to be aware of the fact that their country is becoming dangerously overcrowded by 1990 at least. Possibly sooner.
- vidarh 5y agoOne can argue about why the decline wasn't as fast, but the the comment I replied to misrepresented the development and then tried to blame Islam and Egyptian culture while pointing to muslim Bangladesh as a comparison, without addressing how Islam is relevant as a cause in Egypt but not Bangladesh. It's not a good starting point for discussing why. It gets worse when considering that had it not been for the few years of reversal a decade ago, Egypt would have been on track to similar levels as Bangladesh. Which means that any serious attempt at addressing why would have focused on the causes of that reversal rather than attempt at blaming a culture that did not prevent several decades of continuous drops. > After all, with the concentration of people in the Nile delta, everyone had to be aware of the fact that their country is becoming dangerously overcrowded by 1990 at least. Possibly sooner. The only place where attempting to address population growth by government intervention appears to have worked at scale is China, backed by decades of campaigning and authoritarian government intervention. We simply don't know of any effective non-authoritarian method of having large-scale impact on population growth short of economic development. So this is largely moot. Yes, people have known for a long time, but have not had means to do much about it.
- inglor_cz 5y agoAFAIK post-1989 Iran had a huge drop in fertility coupled with government intervention: " The decline was slow until the government population policy was reversed and a new family planning program was officially inaugurated in December 1989. Total fertility rate fell sharply after 1989, dropping from 5.5 in 1988 to below 2.8 in 1996, more than a 50 per cent decline in 6 years. The own-children estimates of fertility for Iran based on the 2000 Iran Demographic and Health Survey show that the TFR has declined further and reached replacement level (2.26) during the period 1998-2000. The figure for the year 2000 is 2.17." Source: https://www.un.org/development/desa/pd/sites/www.un.org.development.desa.pd/files/unpd_egm_200203_countrypapers_recent_changes_and_the_future_of_fertility_in_iran_abbasi-shavazi.pdf https://www.un.org/development/desa/pd/sites/www.un.org.deve...
- vidarh 5y agoThe economy grew rapidly following the end of the Iran-Iraq war. You'd expect to see a rapid drop as the economy recovered. It is possible the policy changes also had an effect, but again the point is not that policy changes can't have an effect, but that we don't know.
- inglor_cz 5y agoIDK, a lot of other countries actually experienced a baby boom immediately after end of a war. There are pro-natality effects to a war->peace transition. Men coming back and wanting to leave the bad experience behind by founding families. End of rationing system for food and other life necessities. Real estate demand decreasing because a lot of young people were killed.
- vidarh 5y agoAnd yet this is not universal, so the point remains: We don't know very well which types of policies are effective at reducing fertility rate without resorting the really draconian, authoritarian methods like China did. The only other thing we know consistently correlates with dropping fertility rates, to the point that it contributes to us not knowing to what extent other policies works, is economic development. To get it back to the subject at hand, the point is that the poster I originally replied to has no justification for the suggestion that this has to do with culture, even less so with bringing up Islam given they've since given three muslim countries as examples of places they claim are doing better (Bangladesh, Saudi Arabia, Jordan), misrepresented the data, and it's by no means clear what Egypt could have done differently that would have worked. Could they have tried more things? Sure. Might some of them have worked? Sure. But we don't know, and so blaming them for having had a brief dip in a multi-decade drop in fertility rates is unreasonable.
- inglor_cz 5y ago"The only other thing we know consistently correlates with dropping fertility rates, to the point that it contributes to us not knowing to what extent other policies works, is economic development." Educational achievement of girls and women seem to be consistently correlated with dropping fertility rates as well. Of course, this is correlated with economic development as well.