4 ms·
> Kids like treats, have you met one? My comment was about what you attitude you teach them about sweets. Nothing in it implied they dont like it. They still s
by watwut 5y ago
> Kids like treats, have you met one?
My comment was about what you attitude you teach them about sweets. Nothing in it implied they dont like it. They still should not be used as reward.
Not having sweets is not punishment. It is just healthy behavior. You dont eat sweets as reward for being good either. Being good dont imply ability to eat more sweets.
> Preschoolers can understand conditional rewards and penalties and play simple games
Preschoolers have meltdowns over those super regularly. They actually completely sux at games with rules over rewards and punishments, because they sux at hangling the disappointment.
Have you worked with preschoolers, ever?
> Not sure what you on about here. What situation and what compliance are your referring to? We are taking about the design of a human behavior study, not how people should raise their kids.
The kids did as scientists asked them. That is compliance - there was no issue of kids ignoring doll or going to play chase.
- s1artibartfast 5y ago>The kids did as scientists asked them. That is compliance - there was no issue of kids ignoring doll or going to play chase This will be my last response because you clearly don't understand the OP study or the discussion in this thread. The study looked at a problem solving task with conflicting instructions, and measured the ability of children to complete the task correctly. acituan and ALittleLight raised valid points that rewards and punishment could change the study results. For example, maybe children would be complete the task better better if they were punished or rewarded if they complete the study wrong for right. My point is that while it would be unethical to beat or harm a child for completing the task wrong, there are ethical ways to include some other forms of punishment. It seems like you have some pet social and behavioral issues, but I find your poor grammar and communication skills trying, and have no interest in discussing them further.
- Tabular-Iceberg 5y ago> My comment was about what you attitude you teach them about sweets. Nothing in it implied they dont like it. They still should not be used as reward. Sure, but it’s hardly the time and place to grandstand about healthy eating, is it? The point is to find an ethical and less confrontational alternative to something like hitting the child with a ruler. You’re welcome to suggest a better idea. > You dont eat sweets as reward for being good either. Sure, in an adult study it would probably make more sense to have a monetary reward, but with children it’s better to use something less abstract. > The kids did as scientists asked them. That is compliance - there was no issue of kids ignoring doll or going to play chase. The idea is to figure out whether the poor performance was because they weren’t motivated to make an effort or because they were just dumb. It’s only natural for humans to put in only the minimum effort on a pointless task with no reward or risk of punishment. I certainly can’t think instance in my child- or adulthood where I made effort for no reason.