3 ms·
You are half right in that solar doesn't provide base load (obviously). However, other renewables do. E.g. offshore wind is pretty reliable and geothermal and h
by jillesvangurp 5y ago
You are half right in that solar doesn't provide base load (obviously). However, other renewables do. E.g. offshore wind is pretty reliable and geothermal and hydro are pretty decent too. And storage seems a more economical alternative to having gas-peaker plants and is commonly paired with solar. Having all of that seems to be a winning solution for many countries that never had much nuclear to begin with and that are shutting down remaining coal and gas production.
Germany's energy sector is dirtier than France because France has a lot of nuclear power plants left from mid last century. And Germany of course built a lot of coal plants during that time and never had that much nuclear due to the political sensibilities of that era. Germany has invested a lot in early and relatively inefficient solutions over the last few decades. As these are being modernized, their cost will gradually improve. E.g. wind turbines from last century are a very different proposition than a modern 15MW offshore turbine. So yes, Germans paid a price for being early but they now they have a thriving industry that is about helping others switch to renewables.
Many coal plants in Germany are being shut down until 2038 and most of those French nuclear plants are reaching their end of life pretty soon as well. France has actually been decommissioning old nuclear plants for a while and has been gradually shifting to other renewables. E.g. wind and solar are growing relative to nuclear in France (quite a lot actually). Of course the issue is less urgent in France as they have (mostly) clean production already. But proportionally, nuclear is becoming less important for them.
Both France and Germany pay too much for their power. Solar and wind can be cheaper than that. That's actually what is driving these changes and that's the point of this article. It's not just a little bit cheaper but massively cheaper and still getting cheaper. We are talking orders of magnitude here (plural long term). Enough that you can consider some pretty wild solutions to address the base load issue and still end up with an overall cheaper solution.
New nuclear plants to provide base load don't make a lot of sense economically when that is true. This seems to be what you are implying. France is of course still building some new plants and they are deploying wind and solar too. They are doing more of the latter and less of the former however. The net proportion of nuclear is actually decreasing. That's true for most countries that are still building nuclear plants: they are increasingly less dependent on those plants. Like China, the USA, etc.
That's because the base load argument is simply wrong. Neither nuclear, coal, nor gas are long term needed for that. All of those are unattractive from a cost perspective long term.