4 ms·
That was a highly political move and indeed not Germany's finest moment. Also, why build a plant with a useful life of less than 20 years? That year spells out
by jillesvangurp 5y ago
That was a highly political move and indeed not Germany's finest moment. Also, why build a plant with a useful life of less than 20 years? That year spells out how desperate things are for coal right now.
In any case, 1.1GW pales in comparison to the amount of renewables coming online every year. Also, Germany is actually shutting down more coal than that this year (1.5GW). That 2038 deadline is part of a plan to shut down most of their remaining coal plants: https://www.mining.com/germany-to-shut-1-5-gw-of-coal-generation-by-december/ https://www.mining.com/germany-to-shut-1-5-gw-of-coal-genera....
Call this a last 'success' for the coal lobby. They are going to lose most of the coal capacity by 2038 but they got to have a new plant. I'm sure that made sense in somebody's head when they agreed to take the plant into operation but only until 2038. That plant had already been built so they were negotiating about taking it into operation at all. They won that battle but then lost the battle about shutting down all of the coal plants. In any case, this might end up being the last coal plant Germany ever built. This being a relatively modern plant, it might also be the last one they will shut down.
That might happen a lot sooner than 2038 too. There will be elections in Germany at the end of this summer. Conservative CDU, and its coal friendly sister party CSU who were responsible for pushing this through, might find themselves having to negotiate with the green party over exactly this topic. And depending on how things go, they might have to swallow their pride and compromise. Like they compromised with SPD before.
Shutting down coal in Germany is a hot topic. Shutting down brown coal, which is the nastiest form of coal, doubly so. That's the real hot potato politically. My impression is that there will be lots of haggling over that final shut down year during every election between now and 2038. So, that deadline might start shifting a bit. Since that's only 17 years from now, I'd say 2030 is a nice round number to shoot for. Given some political will, that might actually happen. In the grand scheme of things whether its 2030 or 2038 won't actually matter a whole lot. It's going to be definitely a thing of the past somewhere in that time-frame.
I imagine at some point it also becomes a "lets just rip off the band-aid and get it over with" kind of thing for politicians. The less coal remains, the less power the coal lobby will have to preserve what remains. They are losing power every year. 1.5GW this year.