4 ms·
This shouldn't be voted down into oblivion. Some truths are uncomfortable to hear, but that doesn't make them less true. When I was in Egypt, everywhere I loo
by jiggawatts 5y ago
This shouldn't be voted down into oblivion.
Some truths are uncomfortable to hear, but that doesn't make them less true.
When I was in Egypt, everywhere I looked I saw signs of overpopulation and an idle, largely uneducated workforce standing around half the day in bread lines kilometres long.
- vidarh 5y agoIt starts with a claim that is fundamentally false, though: the suggestion that Egypt's fertility rate is not dropping. I hesitate to call it a lie, because it could simply be that they have not looked up the numbers. But it is questionable when they took time to look up a population pyramid but neglected to look up the actual fertility rate over time which would have immediately invalidated the central pillar of a comment that then went on to assign blame for a falsehood.
- ArkanExplorer 5y agoYou're right, its not dropping: its rising Egypt fertility rate 2006: 3.01 2018: 3.28 https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.TFRT.IN?locations=EG-JO-SA https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.TFRT.IN?location... Contrasted against neighbours Jordan and Saudi Arabia which show much more consistent declines and are now both down to aobout 2.3.
- vidarh 5y agoIt rose for a few years, and has been declining again for years. Why do you keep misrepresenting this? That you tried to make this about Islam, and now use Saudi Arabia and Jordan as comparison is just bizarre.
- smnrchrds 5y agoIt's getting downvoted because it's blatantly racist. How else do you interpret this but racism: > Earth is not gaining much by having millions of Egyptians - just increased resource degradation EDIT: It also says the reason for Egypt's higher fertility rate is Islam, while comparing it to Bangladesh, another Muslim country. So it's not like the comment is racist but insightful if you ignore racism. It's racist and nonsensical.
- jiggawatts 5y agoHistorically, Catholicism was also responsible for a high birth rate because of their religious dogma. Is that racist or a factual observation? Not everything is racist. Racism is when you judge someone by their ethnicity alone. Racism is when you deny someone opportunities based only on their skin colour. Etc... I'm not going to automatically assume that every Irish woman I meet is a baby-making machine just because most Irish tend to be catholic. That would be stupid. That however doesn't negate the prior fact. Catholics as a group generally tended to oppose birth control. Making statistical observations about a nation, with numbers, is just science. Making judgements about official policy, whether it is political or religious in nature, is a statement about the policy, not any individual person. Be careful not to fall into the trap of labelling things with the most extreme version, it limits your ability to think clearly. Not every left-leaning policy is communist. Not every right-leaning policy is fascist. Not every comment about a country is racist.
- redis_mlc 5y ago> Is that racist or a factual observation? Unfortunately most people today can't tell the difference. Partly it's because they don't read anything about current affairs, partly they're not interested in discerning the difference. (I remember when discourse started to become post-factual and "truthy," but today it's the norm. Truthy means it sounds like it could be true, but there's no evidence behind it. If you listen to White House spokesperson Jen Psaki, basically every other sentence is not factual. Luckily she's resigning in about a year.)
- lazyasciiart 5y agoI think you missed the point. To look at two Muslim countries and say one has slower population growth because the other is Islamic is not racist. It is nonsensical.
- inglor_cz 5y agoThere are a lot of parameters that correlate with higher fertility rate, and higher religiousness is one of them. Many religions explicitly stress the need to go and multiply and priests/imams/rabbis repeat this message to the believers. In countries as culturally different as the U.S., the Netherlands, Israel and India, the most religious subgroups of population tend to have the most children. And, conversely, once the total level of religiousness starts to drop (as in formerly strongly Catholic countries of the Mediterranean, or in cities like Istanbul and Tehran), the birthrates plummet as well.
- dang 5y agoNot only should it have been downvoted, we've banned the account. Religious and nationalistic flamewar is not allowed here, and outright slurs are utterly not ok. If you have something thoughtful and substantive to say about conditions in Egyptian society, or any other society, that's different.