24 ms·
Why free speech is under attack from right and left
- jeffbee 5y agoSome ripe both-sides-ism in this one. The article equates not defending certain kinds of speech, on the part of the ACLU, with actively attacking other kinds of speech by legislative Republicans.
- bawolff 5y agoI didn't read it as equating the two actions as equal, but equating that both are retreating from their historic positions. I.e. they're equating the first derrivative.
- jeffbee 5y agoReading it that way is your right, of course, but the headline states that the Left is attacking free speech, and it also says "both sides in their own ways have begun to emphasize why government authorities, private businesses, or college administrators should more tightly regulate, if not suppress, certain kinds of public speech" but gives no examples of this happening on one of the sides. The only "attacks" they can mention for the Left are that certain university faculties might not invite some people to speak at their campus, and the ACLU might decline to defend you if you are literally an Illinois Nazi. Even the latter example is critically weak because while that article says that "internal tensions" existed at the ACLU over defending neo-Nazis in Charlottesville, the fact remains that the ACLU did defend the right of Nazis to assemble in Charlottesville! So again, I reject this both-sides-ism. On the one hand, a minority of ACLU decision makers will whine about defending Nazi parades, but the ACLU will still do it. On the other hand, Republicans in 30 states will throw you in jail for assigning the reading of a Ta-Nahisi Coates article. These two things are not similar.
- happytoexplain 5y agoIt might be more that they are acknowledging that both things exist, not asserting that both things are equally destructive.
- bawolff 5y agoI feel like the article didn't really address the "why" question of the headline.
- happytoexplain 5y agoI think they meant, "why the notion that it's one-sided is wrong". I.e. they are explaining their reasoning for the assertion that it's both sides - not explaining why each side is doing it. Emphasis in the title is on the word "and", not on the phrase "free speech is under attack".
- PaulHoule 5y agoI think it's also wrongheaded to look at online communications in 2021 through the lens of "rights", see https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Rights-Talk/Mary-Ann-Glendon/9780029118238 https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Rights-Talk/Mary-Ann-... Today people are overwhelmed with spam, disingenuous and wasteful communication. On my floor there is a bullpen full of graduate students with a sign that warns about the danger of a "Halon 1301 Fire Control System", but talking to the building manager they never got around to installing Halon in that room. In the kitchen there is a sign advertising NSF grants for graduate students that was there when I was a graduate student (20+ years ago!), when I called the phone number it was disconnected so I took it down. Exposed to thoughtless and irrelevant messages people learn to tune out real dangers and opportunity. On Hacker News every day I see people who seem to be fascinated with the idea of taking pet medicines to cure deadly diseases and they valorize anything "controversial". I wonder if, like the some cults, the point is not for the followers to convert anybody, but instead to face ridicule, rejection and marginalization, convince them that the world is hopelessly corrupt, and radicalize them so they'll attempt more violent attacks. Then there was the article that got posted about "How to pick the right handheld GPS... For You" that rambles on but never mentions specific models, that there is one Garmin model that is at least 10db more sensitive than all the others. It looks like legitimate communication but it's empty and meaningless. Those GDPR cookie popups train people to click "yes" to anything and someday somebody will click on something they shouldn't have and the power will go down to the US East Coast for two weeks. Gangs of people with the MO "we have to have the last word" stalk hacker news and try to draw people out and provoke them to anger. The first ones I noticed were "gender activists" (e.g. the kind of people who will get in the way of police when they are doing their work and get arrested after an hour of arguing and claim they can't understand why they got arrested) but soon the tactic was adopted by "alt right" people. I remember feeling so helpless when a certain rotter from a broken home would do this in person to my (then) six year old son who didn't understand that he couldn't win by arguing with this person at a "content" level. Criminals like the latter will talk about their "rights" but it's like saying that acid rain has rights or that leaded gas has rights.
- visarga 5y ago> “Hearing, honoring, and respecting dissent, even when inconvenient, can sharpen one’s own position, expand one’s knowledge, and help us see that “conflicting doctrines share the truth between them.” That won't work if the opposing side believes you have bad intentions and even engaging in debate with you is giving a platform to bias and discrimination. They won't debate, they think even science and math are racially and gender biased. Logic is no good, 'telling stories' (anecdotes and emotional appeal) is the new logic. They also do not care about individuals, just the group identities. Similarly the army only cares about winning and the church only cares about purity, individual thinking among their members being considered irrelevant or even harmful. Please use comments to explain the downvotes.
- bawolff 5y agoI didn't downvote you, but i feel like the reason is that you're basically doing what you complain the other side is doing - i.e. demonizing the other as irrational people who are all the same and beyond reason.
- visarga 5y agoMaybe they are not all the same, even though I sense there is strong pressure to conform in their ranks. That's a tragedy - abstract ideas (ideology) valued more than concrete humans with all their distinctions. Looks like I fell into an intolerance intolerance trap.
- amadeuspagel 5y agoBeneath a veneer of neutrality in the headline ("attack from right and left"), the article mostly attacks republicans. The only criticism of a left-wing organization is that the ACLU doesn't defend freedom of speech as much anymore. It doesn't mention the pressure on tech companies to censor more from the democratic party[1]. If you want to write a both-sides story about censorship, a great example would be the persecution of Julian Assange, the article doesn't mention that either. [1]: https://greenwald.substack.com/p/congress-in-a-five-hour-hearing-demands-0cf https://greenwald.substack.com/p/congress-in-a-five-hour-hea...
- jeffbee 5y agoIf you can link to an article where Glenn Greenwald wastes 4400 words ranting about BDS, but never bothers defining BDS because you are assumed to already know what that is, you are probably deep in an echo chamber.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- PaulHoule 5y agoIn a world where the goal is to mobilize your own supporters, not turn "swing voters" it is helpful to have grievances that can be endlessly recycled. If it wasn't for "cancel culture" Fox News might have to go somewhere and report the news, but somebody is always going to get "canceled" somewhere and even if they don't you can keep talking about somebody being canceled for years after it happened. The focus on BDS shows that Israel is no longer afraid of their neighbors and the Palestinians and now they can't bear it that somebody won't buy a Sodastream. (I was a little shocked to look through a big medicine cabinet though and not see anything from Teva.)
- the_third_wave 5y agoWhen I come across an unknown term in a discussion I take to the 'net to find out what it is all about. With new terms being born and bred every day this is not an uncommon occurrence which is I why I put that Searx [1] engine on my server, to be able to search without being pushed in a box by the incumbent search engine operators. This way I can use "politically charged" queries without marking myself as whatever it is I searched for. As to a "republican" attack on free speech I would point to Michael Knowles last book, "Speechless: Controlling Words, Controlling Minds" [2] for some examples of a proposed limit on freedom of speech in the style of "just because you can teach preschoolers about kink does not mean you should be allowed to" and similar examples. Interestingly enough the book is the best-selling non-fiction political book in the USA at the moment but it has failed to show up on the "New York Times bestseller list", pointing at part of the problem discussed in the book. He calls laissez-faire liberals and nominally conservatives "squishes" who need to stand up for their principles. He does have a point, it does not make sense to call yourself a "conservative", "libertarian" or "progressive" or what have you if you are not willing to both talk the talk and walk the walk. It is also important for people to speak their minds and not be silenced by a vocal minority, even if this means they are likely to suffer consequences for their speaking up. Sticks and stones break bones but words break employment contracts, employment opportunities and social connections. If we in the west are to survive the increase in speech suppression we need to speak out. If you do not agree you should enter the discussion instead of calling for an online mob to get someone fired. As it stands the silent majority outnumbers the vocal minority by a large amount, it is time for these people - on all sides of the debate - to start using their voices in a constructive way. Just speak your mind, your own mind, not whatever pablum is being pushed by "your side of the isle". Not everyone will have a thought-out opinion on all subjects - the homo universalis has become a very rare species since the industrial and scientific revolutions - but if enough people dare to speak their mind it should be possible to come to a real consensus, possibly/probably straddling "party lines". Sometimes there just is no consensus nor should there be since "once side" is demonstrably wrong but even that should be allowed to be said, by anyone, from any "side". [1] https://searx.me/ https://searx.me/ [2] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/55385983-speechless https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/55385983-speechless
- happytoexplain 5y agoNote well that there are two top-level comments in this thread, both claiming that the author is engaging in the both-sides fallacy, but each claiming that the bias is in opposite political directions. I'm not saying either of them is totally wrong, but it's food for thought.