4 ms·
I know you’re just trolling, but for the benefit of the reader: https://www.businessinsider.com/eric-adams-defund-the-police-young-white-affluent-people-2021-4
by rayiner 5y ago
I know you’re just trolling, but for the benefit of the reader: https://www.businessinsider.com/eric-adams-defund-the-police-young-white-affluent-people-2021-4 https://www.businessinsider.com/eric-adams-defund-the-police...
> In an interview with New York Magazine published Tuesday, Adams said the "defund the police" movement is led not by people of color in the Big Apple, but rather by young white professionals.
Adams is absolutely correct. He ran on a common-sense approach to policing, and won every non-white constituency in NYC. Maya Wiley supported defunding and her base was affluent white professionals: https://nypost.com/2021/07/04/nyc-mayor-race-shows-its-well-off-whites-who-back-far-left/ https://nypost.com/2021/07/04/nyc-mayor-race-shows-its-well-...
> But despite her leftish credentials, Wiley won only 22 percent of first-choice votes. She carried no assembly districts in Manhattan or The Bronx and none with large black percentages.
Calling criticism of defunding the police “racist” is an classic example of how left-wing white people (and non-whites platformed mainly by white people, whether in the media or academic) invoke the moral authority of purporting to speak people of color to push their own agendas.
- DeliriumTrigger 5y agoNice to dig even deeper.
- rayiner 5y agoSorry, what’s racist—or at least unseemly in the same way as stolen valor—is white progressives trading on the political capital of POC to further their own ends. I was never opposed to “identity politics” until I realized that, because white liberals control most media outlets as well as institutions, it’s trivial to invoke people’s identities for political ends without actually having their support. CNN will have some professor of XYZ studies on TV, but who selected that professor to be on TV? Or granted her tenure?
- dang 5y agoYour account has been breaking the site guidelines so badly and so frequently that I've banned it. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- throwawaysea 5y agoIt’s amazing to me that mostly-white progressive activists pushed so hard for defunding this last year, employing every aggressive tactic like rioting and political intimidation. They completely ignored what minority communities want and need in service of their ideological goals. There was a past discussion on HN (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24275500 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24275500) about how polls show that Black Americans overwhelmingly want policing to stay the same or increase, an inconvenient piece of data that was given little emphasis on news or social media, and ignored by politicians. In the end numerous cities defunded police departments anyways and the result was a predictable surge in crime. The failure of society to communicate and hold civil discourse just makes me sad and leaves me with little faith that our political process is more than just random noise.
- dragonwriter 5y ago“Defund the police” doesn't mean “reduce law enforcement activity”, it means “move funding and responsibility for non-law-enforcement activity out of police departments to entities that can do it more efficiently and without turning encounters that should not require armed law enforcement in the first place into bloodbaths that then consume even more.law enforcement resources”. Defunding has, as a corollary, more police resources dedicated to core law enforcement activities, despite less total resources. (The disband/abolish alternative works out similarly, though it envisions a more comprehensive reorganization of local community services that wont have a monolithic paramilitary “police department” as a component.)
- zepto 5y agoThis is not true. It is true that there is more than one view represented by the phrase ‘defund’, but many who say defund do mean abolish.
- throwawaysea 5y agoI’ve heard this claimed definition of defunding over and over, and it just feels like gaslighting or a distraction tactic. I still think defunding is an unacceptable concept for multiple reasons: 1. Minorities want police. Not social workers, police. Progressives want to play the role of a white savior, but they ignore what minorities want and need, which means this whole push for defunding amounts to exploitation of minorities for political goals. 2. I find the rhetoric around police response to be hyperbolic. Your use of the word “bloodbath” feels that way to me. Use of force is rare, and unjust use of force is incredibly rare. The entire notion of defunding is disrupting an effective system to address a near non-existent problem based on a few heavily popularized anecdotal incidents. 3. The defund movement and abolish movement are the same. First off this is true in the literal sense since to “defund” is to stop all funding. Second, activists regularly claim they truly do mean abolish - at best they are attempting incremental steps towards that dangerous goal. Third, both reduced funding and complete defunding of police go hand in hand with other dangerous ideas like restorative justice policies in places like SF, the goal of which is to not enforce the law in order to reduce consequences (like prison time) in search of “equity”. I would reject any reduced funding policy that is part of this collection of related policies, so the semantic debate doesn’t feel particularly useful (for me).