3 ms·
None of them in particular. The author of this article seems mostly concerned with constructing pedantic strawmen and handily defeating them with clever demonst
by bob1029 5y ago
None of them in particular. The author of this article seems mostly concerned with constructing pedantic strawmen and handily defeating them with clever demonstrations. Claiming SQL is not expressive is a fault on the part of the developer of the schema. The notion of a broader ER model and why a good one matters seems to have completely eluded the author, aside from a brief mention of 6NF (which is definitely not the right place to start the conversation on normalization).
It is really easy to take a negative stance on a technology and poke holes in it without having some grounding in reality. If you are dealing with a problem domain that has hundreds of types/facts/relations, and the need to author logic spanning all of these things all at once, you are going to have a hell of a time managing this with any other technology. Looking at SQL through the lens of toy problems is a massive mistake. You have to look at it through the lens of the worst problems imaginable to begin seeing the light.
I used to think SQL was some ancient trash until I saw the glory of a 40 table join in a factory automation setting. If you need dynamic, hard answers right now, SQL is the only option that makes sense at this kind of scale.
I felt it would contribute more meaningfully to the overall discussion on HN if I were to sidestep a direct critique and present a view of the problem from a different perspective.