3 ms·
There is that lovely quote floating around that change is slower than people expect in the short term but faster in the long term. It is far too early to write
by roenxi 5y ago
There is that lovely quote floating around that change is slower than people expect in the short term but faster in the long term.
It is far too early to write of plain ol' deep reinforcement learning as a failure. It hasn't yet been 5 years since AlphaGo really shocked the unwary, and that was rather cutting edge at in 2016.
- QuesnayJr 5y agoI first saw the quote in something by Robert Cringely. (The Internet claims that Cringely attributed it to Amara, but I couldn't find the original source. Maybe "Accidental Empires"?)
- AlexCoventry 5y agoI saw a similar quote from Asimov or Heinlein or the like, in the introduction to a science-fiction anthology in the eighties.
- stevesimmons 5y agoMaybe quoting Roy Amara, a 1960s Stanford Computer scientist. He said "we overestimate the impact of technology in the short-term and underestimate the effect in the long run" [0]. I dimly remember similar sentiments in Arthur C. Clarke's Profiles of the Future (1662) [1], where he talked about "Hazards of Prophecy", where predictions suffered from either "failure of imagination" (predicted too little change) or "failure of nerve" (could/should have foreseen far reaching change, but chickened out and wrote down a watered-down version). As ACC said it "The failure of nerve seems to be the more common; it occurs when even given all the relevant facts the would-be prophet cannot see that they point to an inescapable conclusion." [0] https://fs.blog/2019/05/gates-law/ https://fs.blog/2019/05/gates-law/ [1] https://fabiusmaximus.com/2017/12/26/arthur-c-clarke-about-predicting-technology/ https://fabiusmaximus.com/2017/12/26/arthur-c-clarke-about-p...
- beefman 5y agoI think short- and long-term predictions are wrong in different ways. Short-term predictions often fail to come true, leading to the diagnosis of slowness. Long-term predictions often fail to even come false, because the world has changed so much the prediction is no longer applicable. In these cases, change was faster than expected, but not in a way that settles the original point (often pertaining to progress or some other value judgement).