10 ms·
Ok, let's be real, this is just plain stupid: 1. This is worse than cutting off your nose to spite your face. I can easily imagine some config being messed up,
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
Ok, let's be real, this is just plain stupid:
1. This is worse than cutting off your nose to spite your face. I can easily imagine some config being messed up, and then the author shoots themselves in the foot. Also, god forbid anyone else have maintain the Rube Goldberg machine you've decided to create.
2.The idea that this could provide some significant dent to Copilot's utility is laughable. First off, it's not hard to see how AI could catch stuff like this. But more importantly, Copilot is clearly and obviously not intended to just be paste and apply. Every comment I've seen from alpha testers has stated how Copilot is uncannily good, but all the code must still be reviewed and it is oftentimes just flat out off. Code like this that would fail immediately would easily be identified.
I understand the arguments over Copilot, but this is just a dumb response to it.
- zzodin 5y agoThis. At the end of the day source code is for human readability. If you pollute your code with a poison pill you just make it harder for other humans to use. ML Systems are doing sequence analysis and looking to predict the next token, for an arbitrary length of phrase. You've poisoned your code but compared to the volume of GitHub or any other public code data set it becomes the equivalent of noise. If you create a movement that puts poison pills on all Haskell files, now every project has painful boilerplate and an AI will learn to produce the same code. And every human that deals with it won't see a difference because you created a Haskell standard.