3 ms·
Nuclear is grossly uncompetitive even if waste disposal costs are ignored. So I agree waste is a red herring, in the sense that it's a strawman brought up by p
by pfdietz 5y ago
Nuclear is grossly uncompetitive even if waste disposal costs are ignored. So I agree waste is a red herring, in the sense that it's a strawman brought up by pro-nuclears as a diversion from nuclear's actual central problem, its economics.
- civilized 5y agoIt seems to me that we have two options: 1. Nuclear, an up-front expensive but proven reliable way to deliver no-carbon energy at civilization scale (cf. France). 2. Renewables, which are cheap upfront, but plans for scaling them up to deliver reliable power at civilization scale are currently dinner party ideas scrawled on the back of a napkin. It's not clear to me that we have a blowout winner here, and we should probably be hedging our bets by developing all viable options simultaneously.
- pfdietz 5y agoI would say it's the other way around. Renewable technologies (including storage) that are being installed could power the world. The only question is how much they would cost, and how much costs will decline as the world invests tens of trillions of dollars in the conversion, driving the technologies down their experience curves. Current commercially available nuclear technology, on the other hand, cannot power the world. Thermal reactors use uranium too inefficiently. Either new seawater U extraction will have to be matured (it's not ready yet), or breeder reactors will have to be matured (they are also not ready yet). Both of these would raise costs of the current nuclear system at current uranium prices. Renewables, at least, have large and growing markets driving the learning and cost reduction, and ditto for storage. Those nuclear technologies do not. In either case fossil fuels have to be penalized sufficiently to keep them in the ground or (and perhaps this will happen) to force CO2 capture to make them greenhouse safe too (but watch the methane leakage).
- jules 5y agoThe real question is energy storage.
- pfdietz 5y agoThe nuclear advocate is betting that even in the face of a market worth trillions of dollars, and with thousands of potential chemistries, none of the battery technologies work out. This seems a poor bet. But I tell you what: in the event that this bet incredibly pans out, the downside is just that batteries cost more than we had hoped. Civilization doesn't collapse. At that point nuclear plants could be built. Is it worth building nuclear plants now that we know are going to be expensive just because batteries have a chance of being expensive? (Also: long term storage like hydrogen doesn't need advances in batteries at all. Combustion turbines that burn hydrogen have been commercially available for years.)
- rob_c 5y agoConversely with all these attempts nobody is able to get a better ion battery _still_ And even Nasa had moved away from sorting liquid hydrogen and using it as fuel due to its crazy dangerous properties of being stored. This is not helium it effectively _eats_ the high pressure metal containing it. And again we reach a stalemate that we would have avoided 30years ago if we had just invested in nuclear. Nuclear is NOT perfect. No solution is. But its an excellent fit to the problems we as a species are trying to solve.
- pfdietz 5y agoWhat? Li-ion battery makers are constantly making better batteries. That's why competing technologies often have a hard time getting traction: the front runner is refusing to stop running. And remember, it's not just advances in the battery itself that matter, but advances in the factories that make the batteries. Making the factory more efficient and productive is as important as, if not more important than, making the battery itself better on some metric. Hydrogen storage would involve compressed gas underground, not liquid hydrogen. This is a demonstrated technology. It works.