3 ms·
> Even the failed RCTs show improvement, just not a statistically significant one. This is usually due to bad trial design: This is usually caused by report an
by gus_massa 5y ago
> Even the failed RCTs show improvement, just not a statistically significant one. This is usually due to bad trial design:
This is usually caused by report and publication bias. All the similar studies that show no improvement or a bad outcome are never published.
> And you don't need a big RCT for everything. You need to do a risk/benefit analysis and ensure that it makes clinical sense. Doctors talk between each other and share what works for their patients and what doesn't.
Here is were we disagree. Except for cases when it's impossible (like open heart surgery), it's necessary to do a good RCT. Doctors sharing anecdotes is not reliable, for example it has a lot of confirmation bias. I've read very similar arguments to justify using hydroxychloroquine without a good RCT last year.
- shaicoleman 5y ago> I've read very similar arguments to justify using hydroxychloroquine without a good RCT last year The big RCTs for Hydroxychrloriquine used almost toxic doses in very late treatment stages, when there's no viral replication. These were studies that were designed to fail in order to discredit early treatments. The corruption of medical sciences has happened many times before (e.g. tobacco industry, asbestos, Vioxx, opioids...) HCQ is only effective in the early viral replication stage, (the first few days after symptoms). For example, in a peer-reviewed study of 29K patients for early treatment, it showed a 73% reduction in death. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1567576921002721 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S156757692... If you only include early treatment studies, you do see that HCQ definitely helps. https://hcqmeta.com/#fig_fpearly https://hcqmeta.com/#fig_fpearly https://hcqmeta.com/#exc https://hcqmeta.com/#exc That said, the results for HCQ compared to Ivermectin are less consistent, it only works early stages, it has no anti-inflammatory effect, the improvements are smaller, and there are more adverse effects. The risk/benefit there is smaller, but it's still much better than the current approach which is take paracetamol until you're sick enough to go the hospital. There are zero RCTs for paracetamol. If you're curious about the case for Ivermectin, this is a good video to start with: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LkIKCbwBcLU&t=708s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LkIKCbwBcLU&t=708s