4 ms·
Maybe I haven't made enough enemies today. I've been persistently arguing for years that climate change is simply a minor threat. 2020 may continue the trend o
by roenxi 5y ago
Maybe I haven't made enough enemies today.
I've been persistently arguing for years that climate change is simply a minor threat. 2020 may continue the trend of being the hottest year on record, and that will be completely dwarfed by both the damage from the coronavirus, the threat of overpopulation and the benefits of economic growth (powered by fossil fuels) in Asia. We might be facing a new war to end all wars in the South China sea. This is being driven by technology and equalisation of the worlds great powers more than by climate.
The climate emergency people are going to have to keep struggling to argue that the emergency here is the temperature rise. The evidence remains that running out of fossil fuels is a bigger threat to humanity's comfort than using them. At the timescales being talked about moving cities as a one-off thing if any problems become imminent is an entirely reasonable plan. Shenzhen was built in 40 years.
- quickthrower2 5y agoDon’t running out of fossil fuels and combating climate change have overlapping solutions anyway? Also not just temperature increases but more weather unpredictability. Impact on food supply and for many people impact on shelter. Basic life necessities. Coronavirus and wars might be a walk in the park by comparison as much as I hate to say that as it sounds callous
- Applejinx 5y ago>more weather unpredictability That's the one to watch. I don't think your estimate is out of line, even if 'compared to wars, this is a walk in the park' is seemingly inflammatory. Climate is a giant chaotic system. It gets more violent as the base energy put into it, increases. This is not linear. How nonlinear? We'll see. Our experience with catastrophic weather emergencies is the human-facing side of this chaotic system. The amount of energy vented by the atmosphere during these events is comparable to the destruction inflicted by wars… but the climate doesn't run out of bombs, or declare peace. It's a completely mindless thing that follows general heuristics which outline the extent of expected responses out of the chaotic, nondeterministic system… and we are in the process of redefining what these heuristics mean. While, at the same time, climate is in the process of rapidly altering these definitions out from under us. We're gonna be seeing city-flattening weather events way sooner and more often than we see sustained wet-bulb temperatures inimical to life in populated areas. Our whole understanding of surviving on this planet will get redefined, first slowly and then rapidly. We as a species will be able to do this and will survive, but it's a big deal and comparable to colonizing other planets.
- brazzy 5y ago>The climate emergency people are going to have to keep struggling to argue that the emergency here is the temperature rise. Nobody is struggling to argue that because it is absolutely obvious to anyone who's not wilfully stupid and ignorant. >The evidence remains that running out of fossil fuels is a bigger threat to humanity's comfort than using them What evidence? You have none. > At the timescales being talked about moving cities as a one-off thing if any problems become imminent is an entirely reasonable plan. Shenzhen was built in 40 years. Except you won't have any space to move those cities to that isn't already occupied. To say nothing about how you'll manage to feed everyone in a completely messed up ecosystem.
- fouc 5y agoThe economic cost of climate change is around $16 trillion right now, and still growing [0]. The economic cost of COVID-19 is probably about the same [1]. It seems hard to argue that climate change is a "minor threat" and "completely dwarfed by" the damage of coronavirus. I dunno about overpopulation per se, since part of that drives the economy, would be tricky to count the cost. [0] https://www.theworldcounts.com/challenges/climate-change/global-warming/cost-of-climate-change/story https://www.theworldcounts.com/challenges/climate-change/glo... [1] https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/10/economic-cost-covid-global-preparedness-monitoring-board/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/10/economic-cost-covid-g...
- XorNot 5y agoEvery 1st world nation on Earth currently has or is flirting with population decline except for immigration, and birth rates have consistently fallen with economic development in poorer parts of the world, and the world fertility rate is current 2.5 births per woman [https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.TFRT.IN https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.TFRT.IN] skewed by underdeveloped nations. The UN projection for total world population tops out at a little over 9 billion by 2050, and possibly up to 10.8 billion by 2100, but that figure is disputed as more recent population metrics have shown fertility rates crashing faster then usual in nations as their development ticks up - a likely outcome is a peak of 9 billion in 2050, followed by a steady state (ideal) or decline (actual problem since there'd be no reason for the trend to reverse after that) [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Projections_of_population_growth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Projections_of_population_grow...]
- shusaku 5y agoThis comment seems unnecessarily combative. If you just said “beyond the effects of climate change, I think a major threat is the depletion of fossil fuel stocks which will lead to regional conflicts” pretty much everyone would be on board.
- roenxi 5y agoWhat would be the point of saying something that everyone would agree with, in a forum filled to the brim with people who don't really understand the topic and have no real power to influence it? That'd be boring, unilluminating and nobody would have a chance to get much out of it. It is better for everyone to have something to argue about while trying to decide what is and isn't true.
- DubiousPusher 5y ago> dwarfed by both the damage from the coronavirus, the threat of overpopulation and the benefits of economic growth (powered by fossil fuels) in Asia Isn't the high end of the cost to address climate change now $50 trillion? Seems like a pretty good value to me.