2 ms·
> However, those who oppose software patents never bother to investigate them. They're just looking for something to confirm their position. I investigate plen
by _delirium 15y ago
> However, those who oppose software patents never bother to investigate them. They're just looking for something to confirm their position.
I investigate plenty in my research areas; fortunately, suing academics for patent infringement tends to be a poor use of funds, so I can ignore them with relative impunity in my own work. But the average amount of innovation in patents I read is pretty low.
In computer-music, for example, I'm willing to agree that there are some truly innovative patented methods; for example, the CCRMA patent on inventing FM synthesis surely counts. But for every one of those, there are 100 or maybe 1000 patents on minor variations of algorithms they didn't invent, sometimes stooping so low as to be nothing more than a choice of parameters in a well-known algorithm not invented by the patent-holder.
It makes the area a bit of a minefield if you want to do anything commercial, because everyone and their intern owns patents on hundreds of trivial permutations of everything. That's considerably different from there being one patent per truly significant innovation in computer-music synthesis. There are probably 100 of those in the history of computer music, maybe 200 if we want to be generous; and yet there somehow exist thousands of computer-music patents.